重大突发公共卫生事件应急合作网络演化及绩效研究——以武汉市应对新冠肺炎疫情为例

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 突发公共卫生事件的复杂性、动态性和不确定性给应急管理合作提出了更高的要求，因此构建和优化跨部门合作网络对于有效应对公共卫生事件具有重要意义。本文基于2020年新冠肺炎疫情期间武汉市疫情防控应急组织间关系数据，利用社会网络分析方法，融合非常态和常态两种社会形态，全面剖析重大突发公共卫生事件应急合作网络的演化情况及绩效差异。研究结果表明，具有相似组织属性的组织之间更易建立合作关系，形成复杂的合作网络;但非常态应急合作网络与常态化应急合作网络之间存在显著差异，且非常态应急合作网络的整体绩效更高。基于此，科学高效的应急管理需要兼顾非常态应急和常态化防控，依据应急情境的变化，协调不同阶段的重点任务及涉及的组织，并把组织间紧密的依赖关系作为维持组织信任、推动资源共享和信息交流的功能鲁棒，进一步探索提升应急合作网络有效性的可行路径。

关键词: 公共卫生事件, 应急合作, 网络分析, 网络绩效

Abstract: The complexity, dynamics, and uncertainty of public health emergencies put forward higher requirements for emergency man-agement cooperation. Therefore, building and optimizing a cross-departmental cooperation network is of great significance for effective re-sponse to public health incidents. Based on the relationship data between emergency organizations in Wuhan during the COVID-19 epi-demic in 2020, this paper uses the social network analysis method to integrate both abnormal and normal social states, and comprehen-sively analyzes the evolution and performance of the emergency cooperation network for major public health emergencies. The research shows that cooperative relationship and complex cooperation network are more likely to form among organizations with similar organiza-tional attributes. However, there are significant differences between the abnormal emergency cooperation network and the normal emer-gency cooperation network, and the overall performance of the abnormal emergency cooperation network is stronger. Based on this, scien-tific and efficient emergency management needs to take into account abnormal emergency and normal prevention and control, coordinate key tasks and organizations involved in different stages according to changes in emergency situations, and take the close inter-organiza-tional dependence relationship as a robust function for maintaining organizational trust, promoting resource sharing and information ex-change, to further explore feasible ways to improve the effectiveness of emergency cooperation networks.

Key words: public health emergencies, emergency cooperation, network analysis, network performance

王红梅, 石银凤, 郭小倩. 重大突发公共卫生事件应急合作网络演化及绩效研究——以武汉市应对新冠肺炎疫情为例[J]. 管理评论, 2024, 36(5): 207-220.

Wang Hongmei, Shi Yinfeng, Guo Xiaoqian. Research on the Evolution and Performance of the Emergency Cooperation Network for Major Public Health Emergencies: The Case of Wuhan's Response to COVID-19[J]. Management Review, 2024, 36(5): 207-220.

参考文献

[1] 郭雪松,朱正威.跨域危机整体性治理中的组织协调问题研究——基于组织间网络视角[J].公共管理学报, 2011,8(4):50-60 Guo X. S., Zhou Z. W. Study on the Issues of Organization and Coordination in Terms of Transboundary Crisis Governance:From the Perspective of Interorganizational Network[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2011,8(4):50-60
[2] 张铮,李政华.中国特色应急管理制度体系构建:现实基础、存在问题与发展策略[J].管理世界, 2022,38(1):138-144 Zhang Z., Li Z. H. Emergency Management System Construction with Chinese Characteristics:Realistic Foundation, Existing Problems and Development Strategy[J]. Journal of Management World, 2022,38(1):138-144
[3] 林蓉蓉.突发公共事件应急管理合作中的合作结构、过程和结果——基于应急合作的研究述评[J].中国行政管理, 2021, 37(1):138-146 Lin R. R. Collaborative Structure, Process and Outcomes in Collaborative Emergency Management:A Literature Review[J]. Chinese Public Administration, 2021,37(1):138-146
[4] 李安楠,邓修权,赵秋红.分形视角下的非常规突发事件应急组织动态重构——以8.12天津港爆炸事件为例[J].管理评论, 2016,28(8):193-206 Li A. N., Deng X. Q., Zhao Q. H. Unconventional Emergency Organizational Dynamic Reconstruction Based on Fractal-8.12 Tianjin Explosions Case Study[J]. Management Review, 2016,28(8):193-206
[5] 俎富豪,赵秋红,邓修权,等.基于嵌套循环结构的分形应急组织构建研究[J].管理评论, 2020,32(10):293-306 Zu F. H., Zhao Q. H., Deng X. Q., et al. Research on Fractal Emergency Organization Reconstruction Based on Nested Loop Structure[J]. Management Review, 2020,32(10):293-306
[6] Bryson J. M., Crosby B. C., Stone M. M. The Design and Implementation of Cross-Sector Collaborations:Propositions from the Literature[J]. Public Administration Review, 2006,66(5):44-55
[7] Comfort L. K., Kapucu N. Inter-organizational Coordination in Extreme Events:The World Trade Center Attacks, September 11, 2001[J]. Natural Hazards, 2006,39(2):309-327
[8] Simo G., Bies A. L. The Role of Nonprofits in Disaster Response:An Expanded Model of Cross-sector Collaboration[J]. Public Administration Review, 2007,67(S1):125-142
[9] Nohrstedt D. Explaining Mobilization and Performance of Collaborations in Routine Emergency Management[J]. Administration&Society, 2016,48(2):135-162
[10] 颜烨.过度与匮欠:应急管控合理化的系统协同分析[J].南京社会科学, 2022,33(3):57-62 Yan Y. Scarcity and Excess:System Collaborative Analysis of Emergency Management and Control Rationalization[J]. Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences, 2022,33(3):57-62
[11] 童星.兼具常态与非常态的应急管理[J].广州大学学报(社会科学版), 2020,19(2):5-15 Tong X. Combined Normal and Abnormal Condition in Emergency Management[J]. Journal of Guangzhou University (Social Sci-ence Edition), 2020,19(2):5-15
[12] Kapucu N., Bryer T., Garayev V., et al. Interorganizational Network Coordination under Stress Caused by Repeated Threats of Disasters[J]. Journal of Homeland Security&Emergency Management, 2010,7(1):1-30
[13] Chen W., Zhang H., Comfort L. K., et al. Exploring Complex Adaptive Networks in the Aftermath of the 2008 Wenchuan Earth-quake in China[J]. Safety Science, 2020,30(8):1-15
[14] Jung K., Song M., Park H. J. The Dynamics of an Interorganizational Emergency Management Network:Interdependent and In-dependent Risk Hypotheses[J]. Public Administration Review, 2018,79(2):225-235
[15] 康伟,陈茜,陈波.基于SNA的政府与非政府组织在公共危机应对中的合作网络研究——以"4· 20"雅安地震为例[J].中国软科学, 2014,29(5):141-150 Kang W., Chen X., Chen B. Analysis of the Cooperation Network between Government and Non-governmental Organizations in Public Crisis Response Based on Social Network Theory-A Case Study on 4.20 Ya-an Earthquake[J]. China Soft Science, 2014,29(5):141-150
[16] Kapucu N., Hu Q. Understanding Multiplexity of Collaborative Emergency Management Networks[J]. The American Review of Public Administration, 2016,46(4):399-417
[17] 孔静静,韩传峰.应急组织合作的结构逻辑及运行机制——以2008年汶川地震应对为例[J].公共管理学报, 2013,10(4):88-101 Kong J. J., Han C. F. Structural Logic and Operation Mechanisms of Emergency Organizations Collaboration:A Case Study of the Response to the 2008 Wenchuan Earthquake in China[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2013,10(4):88-101
[18] Mandell M., Keast R. Evaluating Network Arrangements:Toward Revised Performance Measures[J]. Public Performance&Management Review, 2007,30(4):574-597
[19] Kapucu N., Garayev V. Structure and Network Performance:Horizontal and Vertical Networks in Emergency Management[J]. Administration&Society, 2016,48(8):931-961
[20] Hu Q., Knox C. C., Kapucu N. What Have We Learned since September 11, 2001?A Network Study of the Boston Marathon Bombings Response[J]. Public Administration Review, 2014,74(6):698-712
[21] Kapucu N., Demiroz F. Measuring Performance for Collaborative Public Management Using Network Analysis Methods and Tools[J]. Public Performance&Management Review, 2011,34(4):549-579
[22] Hu Q., Yeo J., Kapucu N. A Systematic Review of Empirical Emergency Management Network Research:Formation and Devel-opment, Properties, and Performance[J]. The American Review of Public Administration, 2022,52(4):280-297
[23] Fan B., Liu R., Huang K., et al. Embeddedness in Cross-agency Collaboration and Emergency Management Capability:Evidence from Shanghai's Urban Contingency Plans[J]. Government Information Quarterly, 2019,36(4):1-12
[24] Goodreau S. M., Morris K. M. Birds of a Feather, or Friend of a Friend?Using Exponential Random Graph Models to Investigate Adolescent Social Networks[J]. Demography, 2009,46(1):103-125
[25] Song M., Park H. J., Jung K. Do Political Similarities Facilitate Interlocal Collaboration?[J]. Public Administration Review, 2017,78(2):261-269
[26] Comfort L. K. Crisis Management in Hindsight:Cognition, Communication, Coordination, and Control[J]. Public Administration Review, 2007,67(2):189-197
[27] 童星,张海波.基于中国问题的灾害管理分析框架[J].中国社会科学, 2010,31(1):132-146 Tong X., Zhang H. B. An Analytical Framework of Disaster Management in the Context of China[J]. Social Sciences in China, 2010,31(1):132-146
[28] Feiock R. C. The Institutional Collective Action Framework[J]. Policy Studies Journal, 2013,41(3):397-425
[29] 李哲,唐福杰,袁淳,等."一省包一市"模式对慈善组织信息披露的空间溢出影响:基于突发疫情期间抗疫款物信息披露的文本分析[J].管理评论, 2020,32(12):263-272 Li Z., Tang F. J., Yuan C., et al. Spatial Spillover Effects of Partner Assistance on Charitable Organizations' Information Disclo-sure:A Text Analysis Based on the Information Disclosure of Anti-epidemic Provisions[J]. Management Review, 2020,32(12):263-272
[30] Woong L. D. Collaboration and Performance in Disaster and Emergency Management:Focusing on SouthKorea[J]. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2019,35(1):1-9
[31] Mandell M., Steelman T. Understanding What can Be Accomplished through Interorganizational Innovations:The Importance of Typologies, Context and Management Strategies[J]. Public Management Review, 2011,5(2):197-224
[32] 康伟,陈波.公共危机管理领域中的社会网络分析——现状、问题与研究方向[J].公共管理学报, 2013,10(4):114-124 Kang W., Chen B. The Application of Social Network Analysis in the Field of Public Crisis Management:Situation, Problems and Research Directions[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2013,10(4):114-124
[33] 高小平,张强.再综合化:常态与应急态协同治理制度体系研究[J].行政论坛, 2021,28(1):59-67 Gao X. P., Zhang Q. Re-integration:The Institutional System of Normalcy and Collaborative Governance[J]. Administrative Tribune, 2021,28(1):59-67