企业危机事件网络舆情负性偏向驱动机制研究——基于40个案例的两阶段fsQCA分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 负性偏向是指受众倾向于关注和传递负面信息而忽略正面信息,这种消极的信息感知偏差现象给企业危机网络舆情的引导和治理带来极大阻力。本文以40起企业危机舆情案例为样本,基于内部认知与外部刺激的组合框架,从组态视角探索要素驱动企业危机舆情负性偏向的因果复杂机制。通过两阶段的fsQCA分析发现:企业危机舆情在曝光阶段存在3条高负性偏向的驱动路径,分别为"消极解释驱动""认识差距驱动"和"消极启发式加工驱动";在回应阶段也存在3条高负性偏向的驱动路径,分别为"质疑态度驱动""期望违背驱动"和"消极启发式加工驱动"。同时,在曝光和回应阶段各存在2条非高负性偏向的形成路径,它们均呈现出"群众吃瓜"的特征。此外,通过组态间的对比分析发现:威胁感知对企业危机舆情的负性偏向具有重要驱动作用,良好的企业形象并不总是带来正面效益,以及公众在危机舆情曝光阶段积累的态度是回应阶段负性偏向的关键驱动力。

关键词: 企业危机事件, 网络舆情, 负性偏向, 信息感知, 定性比较分析

Abstract: Negativity bias refers to the audience's tendency to focus on and pass on negative information while neglecting positive information, which brings great resistance to the guidance and management of corporate crisis network public opinion. Based on the combined framework of internal cognition and external stimulus, this paper explores the driving mechanism of negativity bias in enterprise crisis public opinion from the perspective of configuration. After an analysis of staged fsQCA, we find that there are three driving paths of high negativity bias in the public opinion of enterprise crisis in the exposure stage, which are "negative explanation driven", "cognition gap driven" and " negative heuristic processing driven". In the response stage, there are also three driving paths of high negativity bias, namely "questioning attitude driven", "expectation deviation driven" and "negative heuristic processing driven". At the same time, two non-high negativity bias formation paths are found in both exposure and response stages, all showing the characteristics of "crowd eating melon". In addition, through comparison analysis between configurations, it is found that threat perception has an important promoting effect on negativity bias of corporate crisis public opinion; good corporate image does not always bring positive benefits; attitude accumulated by public in crisis publicity stage is a key influencing factor for negativity bias in response stage.

Key words: enterprise crisis events, network public opinion, negativity bias, information perception, qualitative comparative analysis

谢乐, 杨波, 杨美芳, 谭亮. 企业危机事件网络舆情负性偏向驱动机制研究——基于40个案例的两阶段fsQCA分析[J]. 管理评论, 2023, 35(7): 339-352.

Xie Le, Yang Bo, Yang Meifang, Tan Liang. The Driving Mechanism of Negativity Bias in Network Public Opinion of Enterprise Crisis Events: A Two-stage fsQCA Analysis Based on 40 Cases[J]. Management Review, 2023, 35(7): 339-352.

参考文献

[1] Xie Y., Qiao R., Shao G., et al. Research on Chinese Social Media Users' Communication Behaviors during Public Emergency Events[J]. Telematics and Informatics, 2017,34(3):740-754
[2] 徐宪平,鞠雪楠.互联网时代的危机管理:演变趋势、模型构建与基本规则[J].管理世界, 2019,35(12):181-189
[3] 王满仓,佘镜怀,王伟.现代企业危机管理理论综述[J].经济学动态, 2004,45(3):80-83
[4] Zheng B. W., Liu H. F., Davison R. M. Exploring the Relationship between Corporate Reputation and the Public's Crisis Communication on Social Media[J]. Public Relations Review, 2018,44(1):56-64
[5] Bebbington K., MacLeod C., Ellison T. M., et al. The Sky Is Falling:Evidence of a Negativity Bias in the Social Transmission of Information[J]. Evolution and Human Behavior, 2017,38(1):92-101
[6] 张梅,丁书恒,刘国芳,等.网络突发事件中的负性偏向:产生与表现[J].心理学报, 2021,53(12):1361-1375
[7] Jennifer C. Rethinking the Negativity Bias[J]. Review of Philosophy and Psychology, 2018,9(3):607-625
[8] 陈旭辉,苏晓娟,崔丽霞.基于社交媒体关系互动的旅游城市形象负面偏差引导策略——以"青岛天价虾"事件为例[J].旅游学刊, 2017,32(7):47-56
[9] 朱永泽,毛伟宾,王蕊.负性偏向的神经机制[J].心理科学进展, 2014,22(9):1393-1403
[10] Smith N. K., Larsen J. F., Chartrand T. L., et al. Being Bad Isn't Always Good:Affective Context Moderates the Attention Bias toward Negative Information[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2006,90(2):210-220
[11] Wang L., Schuetz C. G., Cai D.H. Choosing Response Strategies in Social Media Crisis Communication:An Evolutionary Game Theory Perspective[J]. Information&Management, 2020,58(9):103-132
[12] He S., Rui H. X., Whinston A. B. Social Media Strategies in Product-Harm Crises[J]. Information Systems Research, 2018,29(2):362-380
[13] 张栋凯,齐佳音.基于微博的企业突发危机事件网络舆情的股价冲击效应[J].情报杂志, 2015,34(3):132-137
[14] 张洁梅,孔维铮.网络负面口碑对消费者冲动性购买意愿的影响——负面情绪的中介作用[J].管理评论, 2021,33(6):144-156
[15] 齐丽云,李晓鸿,曹硕.企业社会责任负面事件网络舆情演化与政企合作研究[J].系统工程理论与实践, 2020,40(7):1792-1805
[16] 王家坤,王新华.双层社交网络上的企业舆情传播模型及控制策略研究[J].管理科学, 2019,32(1):28-41
[17] Su L. Y., Augustine P., Michelle C., et al. Emotions in Social Media:An Analysis of Tweet Responses to MH370 Search Suspension Announcement[J]. International Journal of Business Communication, 2020,57(2):194-211
[18] Stefan S., Milad M., Tobias K., et al. "Silence" as a Strategy During a Corporate Crisis-The Case of Volkswagen's "Die-selgate"[J]. Internet Research, 2019,29(4):921-939
[19] Coombs W. T. Protecting Organization Reputations During a Crisis:The Development and Application of Situational Crisis Communication Theory[J]. Corporate Reputation Review, 2007,10(3):163-176
[20] Bandura A. Social Cognitive Theory of Mass Communication[J]. Media Psychology, 2001,3(3):265-299
[21] Rozin P. Negativity Bias, Negativity Dominance, and Contagion[J]. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 2001,5(4):296-320
[22] Van D. M., Toni G. L. Crafting Our Own Biased Media Diets the Effects of Confirmation, Source, and Negativity Bias on Selective Attendance to Online News[J]. Mass Communication&Society, 2020,23(6):937-967
[23] Silvia K., Cornelia M., Nick P. Confirmation Bias, Ingroup Bias, and Negativity Bias in Selective Exposure to Political Information[J]. Communication Research, 2020,47(1):104-124
[24] Lengauer G., Esser F., Berganza R. Negativity in Political News:A Review of Concepts, Operationalizations and Key Findings[J]. Journalism, 2011,13(2):179-202
[25] Kim H. J., Cameron G. T. Emotions Matter in Crisis:The Role of Anger and Sadness in the Publics' Response to Crisis News Framing and Corporate Crisis Response[J]. Communication Research, 2011,38(6):826-855
[26] Brauer M., Chekroun P. The Relationship between Perceived Violation of Social Norms and Social Control:Situational Factors Influencing the Reaction to Deviance[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2005,35(7):1519-1539
[27] Cooper W. H. Ubiquitous Halo[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 1981,90(2):218-244
[28] Nickerson R. S. Confirmation Bias:A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises[J]. Review of General Psychology, 1998,2(2):175-220
[29] Betty K. L. Audience-Oriented Approach to Crisis Communication:A Study of Hong Kong Consumers' Evaluation of an Organizational Crisis[J]. Communication Research, 2004,31(5):600-618
[30] Jagiello R. D., Hills T. T. Bad News has Wings:Dread Risk Mediates Social Amplification in Risk Communication[J]. Risk Analysis, 2018,38(10):2193-2207
[31] Hatfield E., Cacioppo J. T., Rapson R. L. Emotional Contagion[J]. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 1993,2(3):96-100
[32] 魏建良,朱庆华.基于信息级联的网络意见传播及扭曲效应国外研究进展[J].情报学报, 2019,38(10):1117-1128
[33] 丁汉青,王亚萍. SNS网络空间中"意见领袖"特征之分析——以豆瓣网为例[J].新闻与传播研究, 2010,17(3):82-91
[34] 吴华.意见领袖道德情绪与大众风险感知对组织污名的作用机制研究[D].中央财经大学博士学位论文, 2018
[35] Piccinini G., Scarantino A. Information Processing, Computation, and Cognition[J]. Journal of Biological Physics, 2011,37(1):1-38
[36] 徐颖,郭雯君,张梦柳.企业微博内容呈现特性对信息渗透度的作用机理研究——基于情绪认知理论的研究[J].图书情报工作, 2018,62(21):96-104
[37] 李静,谢耘耕.网络舆情热度的影响因素研究——基于2010-2018年10600起舆情事件的实证分析[J].新闻界, 2020, 36(2):37-45
[38] Jin Y. Making Sense Sensibly in Crisis Communication:How Publics' Crisis Appraisals Influence Their Negative Emotions, Coping Strategy Preferences, and Crisis Response Acceptance[J]. Communication Research, 2010,37(4):522-552
[39] Lauran N., Kunneman F., Wijngaert L. Connecting Social Media Data and Crisis Communication Theory:A Case Study on the Chicken and the Egg[J]. Journal of Risk Research, 2019,23(10):1259-1277
[40] 成俊会,张思,吉清凯.基于SNA的社会热点事件微博舆情阶段性传播网络的结构分析——以"于欢案"为例[J].管理评论, 2019,31(3):295-304
[41] 安璐,吴林.融合主题与情感特征的突发事件微博舆情演化分析[J].图书情报工作, 2017,61(15):120-129
[42] 顾明毅,周忍伟.网络舆情及社会性网络信息传播模式[J].新闻与传播研究, 2009,16(5):67-73
[43] 刘康杰,于霄,王丹."双微时代"的危机传播趋势和影响因素研究——以2016年百度、携程事件为例[J].社会科学, 2016,38(8):23-34
[44] Cheng Y. The Social-Mediated Crisis Communication Research:Revisiting Dialogue between Organizations and Publics in Crises of China[J]. Public Relations Review, 2020,46(1):164-175
[45] Meyer A. D., Tsui A. S., Hinings C. R. Configurational Approaches to Organizational Analysis[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1993,36(6):1175-1195
[46] Ragin C. C. Redesigning Social Inquiry:Fuzzy Sets and Beyond[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 2008
[47] 彭祝斌,范岳鋆,朱晨雨.欧洲焦点事件在华传播热度的影响因素及作用机制——基于30起案例的模糊集定性比较分析[J].新闻与传播研究, 2021,28(2):106-125
[48] 费显政,李陈微,周舒华.一损俱损还是因祸得福?——企业社会责任声誉溢出效应研究[J].管理世界, 2010,(4):74-82
[49] Fiss P. C. Building Better Causal Theories:A Fuzzy Set Approach to Typologies in Organization Research[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2011,54(2):393-420
[50] 杜运周,贾良定.组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA):管理学研究的一条新道路[J].管理世界, 2017,(6):155-167
[51] Schenider C. Q., Rohlfing I. Case Studies Nested in Fuzzy-set QCA on Sufficiency:Formalizing Case Selection and Causal Inference[J]. Sociological Methods&Research, 2016,45(3):526-568
[52] 王林,何玉锋,杨勇,等.基于fsQCA的跨境电商品牌依恋促进与抑制因素案例研究[J].管理评论, 2020,32(12):320-332
[53] 王德东,房韶泽,王新成.组织因素对重大工程项目绩效影响研究[J].管理评论, 2021,33(1):242-253
[54] Jeong M., Zo H., Lee C. H., et al. Feeling Displeasure from Online Social Media Postings:A Study Using Cognitive Dissonance Theory[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2019,97(8):231-240
[55] Tversky A., Kahneman D. Judgment under Uncertainty:Heuristics and Biases[J]. Science, 1974,185(4157):1124-1131
[56] 云薏霏,刘希平,陈世平.情绪在危机新闻框架和团体危机回应中的作用[J].心理学报, 2017,49(6):814-828
[57] Lee S. Y., Lim E. R., Drumwright M. E. Hybrid Happening:Organizational Reputations in Corporate Crises[J]. Public Relations Review, 2018,44(4):598-609
[58] 屈启兴,齐佳音,宋绍义,等.企业在线危机沟通效果影响因素研究[J].管理评论, 2020,32(4):250-261