未来清晰一定会导致工作投入吗?系统视角下的定性比较研究

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 员工工作投入一直是管理领域的研究重点，其会受到多种因素的影响，包括未来工作自我、感知组织支持等。但是这些因素是如何组合导致工作投入的呢?这是近年来研究者和管理者比较关注的问题。本文在文献研究的基础上，通过问卷调查收集数据，并采用模糊集定性比较分析方法对影响工作投入的因素进行整合性分析。最终得出六条等效路径，并按照核心条件分为三类：对主动性人格的员工，企业可以通过塑造清晰的未来工作自我来提高工作投入；对非主动性人格的员工，企业可以通过塑造员工清晰的未来工作自我和共享价值观来刺激工作投入；对于未来工作自我不清晰的员工，企业可以通过塑造共享价值观和满足员工的自我实现需求来提高工作投入。

关键词: 工作投入, 未来工作自我, 定性比较分析

Abstract: Employees’ work engagement has been a research focus in the field of management, and it can be affected by a variety of factors, including future work self, perceived organizational support, etc. But how do these factors jointly lead to work engagement? This is a matter of concern to researchers and managers recently. On the basis of literature research, this paper collects data through questionnaires and uses fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis to analyze the factors that influence the work engagement. Finally, this study gets six equivalent configurations, and divides them into three categories: For employees with proactive personality, enterprises can improve their work engagement by shaping salient future work selves; for employees without proactive personality, enterprises can stimulate their work engagement by shaping employees’ salient future work selves and shared values; for employees who are not clear about their future work selves, enterprises can improve their engagement by building shared values and meeting employees’ self-actualization needs.

Key words: work engagement, future work self, qualitative comparative analysis

杨洋, 苏莹莹, 李仲秋, 刘宝巍. 未来清晰一定会导致工作投入吗?系统视角下的定性比较研究[J]. 管理评论, 2022, 34(1): 191-204.

Yang Yang, Su Yingying, Li Zhongqiu, Liu Baowei. Does Salient Future Necessarily Lead to Work Engagement? Qualitative Comparative Study from a Systematic Perspective[J]. Management Review, 2022, 34(1): 191-204.

参考文献

[1] Christian M. S., Garza A. S., Slaughter J. E. Work Engagement:A Quantitative Review and Test of Its Relations with Task and Contextual Performance[J]. Personnel Psychology, 2011,64(1):89-136
[2] 唐汉瑛,龙立荣,周如意. 谦卑领导行为与下属工作投入:有中介的调节模型[J]. 管理科学, 2015,28(3):77-89
[3] Kahn W. A. To Be Fully There:Psychological Presence at Work[J]. Human Relations, 1992,45(4):321-349
[4] Lin W. P., Wang L., Bamberger P. A., et al. Leading Future Orientations for Current Effectiveness:The Role of Engagement and Supervisor Coaching in Linking Future Work Self Salience to Job Performance[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2016,92(Feb.):145-156
[5] Strauss K., Griffin M. A., Parker S. K. Future Work Selves:How Salient Hoped-For Identities Motivate Proactive Career Behaviors[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2012,97(3):580-598
[6] Markus K. W., Nurius P. Possible Selves[J]. American Psychologist, 1986,41(9):954-969
[7] Hoyle R. H., Sherrill M. R. Future Orientation in the Self-System:Possible Selves, Self-Regulation, and Behavior[J]. Journal of Personality, 2006,74(6):1673-1696
[8] Taber B. J., Blankemeyer M. Future Work Self and Career Adaptability in the Prediction of Proactive Career Behaviors[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2015,86(Feb.):20-27
[9] Guan Y. J., Bond M. H. New Job Market Entrants' Future Work Self, Career Adaptability and Job Search Outcomes:Examining Mediating and Moderating Models[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2014,85(1):136-145
[10] Hackman J. R., Oldham G. R. Motivation through the Design of Work:Test of a Theory[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1976,16(2):250-279
[11] Saks A. M. Antecedents and Consequences of Employee Engagement[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2006,21(7):600-619
[12] Campion M. A. Interdisciplinary Approaches to Job Design:A Constructive Replication with Extensions[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1988,73(3):467-481
[13] Furnham A., Petrides K., Jackson C., et al. Do Personality Factors Predict Job Satisfaction[J]. Personality and Individual Differences, 2002,33(8):1325-1342
[14] Maslach C., Schaufeli W. B., Leiter M. Job Burnout[J]. Annual Review of Psychology, 2001,52(1):397-422
[15] Gerstner C. R., Day D. V. Meta-Analytic Review of Leader-Member Exchange Theory:Correlates and Construct Issues[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1997,82(6):827-844
[16] Kahn W. A. Psychological Conditions of Personal Engagement and Disengagement at Work[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1990,33(4):692-724
[17] Rich B. L. Job Engagement:Antecedents and Effects on Job Performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2010,53(3):617-635
[18] May D. R., Gilson R. L., Harter L. M. The Psychological Conditions of Meaningfulness, Safety and Availability and the Engagement of the Human Spirit at Work[J]. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2004,77(1):11-37
[19] Ragin C. C. The Comparative Method:Moving beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies[M]. Berkeley, CA:University of California Press, 1987
[20] Ragin C. C. Fuzzy Set Social Science[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 2000
[21] Ragin C. C. Redesigning Social Inquiry:Fuzzy Sets and Beyond[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 2008
[22] Ragin C. C., Fiss P. Net Effects Analysis Versus Configurational Analysis:An Empirical Demonstration[A]. In Ragin C. C. (Ed.). Redesigning Social Inquiry:Set Relations in Social Research[C]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 2008
[23] Fiss P. C. Building Better Causal Theories:A Fuzzy Set Approach to Typologies in Organization Research[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2011,54(2):393-420
[24] Fiss P. C. A Set-theoretic Approach to Organizational Configurations[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2007,32(4):1180-1198
[25] Hackman J. R., Oldham G. R. Work Redesign[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1980,6(4):318-330
[26] Spreitzer G. M., Kizilos M. A., Nason S. W. A Dimensional Analysis of the Relationship between Psychological Empowerment and Effectiveness, Satisfaction, and Strain[J]. Journal of Management, 1997,23(5):679-704
[27] Edward J. R., Cable D. M. The Value of Value Congruence[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2009,94(3):654-677
[28] Maslow A. H. A Theory of Human Motivation[J]. Psychological Review, 1943,50(4):370-396
[29] Rokeach M. The Nature of Human Values[M]. New York:The Free Press, 1973
[30] Meglino B. M., Ravlin E. C., Adkins C. L. A Work Values Approach to Corporate Culture:A Field Test of the Value Congruence Process and Its Relationship to Individual Outcomes[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1989,74(3):424-432
[31] Connor P. E., Becker B. W. Values and the Organization:Suggestions for Research[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1975,18(3):550-561
[32] Geunpil Ryu. The Missing Link of Value Congruence and Its Consequences:The Mediating Role of Employees' Acceptance of Organizational Vision[J]. Public Personnel Management, 2015,44(4):473-495
[33] Zhang Z., Wang M. O., Shi J. Leader-follower Congruence in Proactive Personality and Work Outcomes:The Mediating Role of Leader-member Exchange[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2012,55(1):111-130
[34] Kalliath T. J., Bluedorn A. C., Strube M. J. A Test of Value Congruence Effects[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1999,20(7):1175-1198
[35] Chatman J. A. Improving Interactional Organizational Research:A Model of Person-organization Fit[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1989,14(3):333-349
[36] Li M. J., Wang Z. H., You X. Q., et al. Value Congruence and Teachers' Work Engagement:The Mediating Role of Autonomous and Controlled Motivation[J]. Personality and Individual Difference, 2015,80:113-118
[37] Dylag D., Jaworek M., Karwowski W., et al. Discrepancy between Individual and Organizational Values:Occupational Burnout and Work Engagement among White-collar Workers[J]. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 2013,43(3):225-231
[38] Krems J. A., Kenrick D. T., Neel R. Individual Perceptions of Self-Actualization:What Functional Motives Are Linked to Fulfilling One's Full Potential?[J]. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2017,43(9):1137-1352
[39] Cable D. M., Derue D. S. The Convergent and Discriminant Validity of Subjective Fit Perceptions[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2002,87(5):875-884
[40] Steven S. N., Cheung C. K., Yuan R. Effects of Vocational Training on Unemployed Youths' Work Motivation and Work Engagement:Mediating Roles of Training Adequacy and Self-Actualization[J]. Children and Youth Services Review, 2016,63:93-100
[41] Amabile T. M. The Social Psychology of Creativity[J]. Springer New York, 1983,13(3):253-271
[42] Eisenberger R., Huntington R. Perceived Organizational Support[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1986,71(3):500-507
[43] Eisenberger R., Armeli S., Rexwinkel B., et al. Reciprocation of Perceived Organizational Support[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2001,86(1):42-51
[44] Eisenberger R., Stinglhamber F. Perceived Organizational Support:Fostering Enthusiastic and Productive Employees[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2011,71(3):500-507
[45] Gillet N., Huart I., Colombat P., et al. Perceived Organizational Support, Motivation, and Engagement Among Police Officers[J]. Professional Psychology:Research and Practice, 2013,44(1):46-55
[46] Dallner M., Elo A-L., Gamberale F., et al. Validation of the General Nordic Questionnaire for Psychological and Social Factors at Work[M]. Copenhagen:Nordic Council of Ministers, 2000
[47] Meierhans D., Rietmann B., Jonas K. Influence of Fair and Supportive Leadership Behavior on Commitment and Organizational Citizenship Behavior[J]. Swiss Journal of Psychology, 2008,67(3):131-141
[48] Finne L. B., Christensen J. O., Knardahl S. Psychological and Social Work Factors as Predictors of Mental Distress:A Prospective Study[J]. Plos One, 2014,9(7):1-12
[49] De Cremer D., Van Knippenberg D. Cooperation with Leaders in Social Dilemmas:On the Effects of Procedural Fairness and Outcome Favorability in Structural Cooperation[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human, 2003,91(1):1-11
[50] Van Knippenberg D., Hogg M. A. A Social Identity Model of Leadership Effectiveness in Organizations[J]. Research in Organizational Behavior, 2003,25(25):243-295
[51] Daan V. K., David D. C, Barbara V. K. Leadership and Fairness:The State of the Art[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2007,16(2):113-140
[52] Colquitt J. A., Rodell J. B. Measuring Justice and Fairness[M]. In:Cropanzano R., Ambrose M. A. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Justice in the Workplace. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2015
[53] Colquitt J. A., Scott B. A., Rodell J. B., et al. Justice at the Millennium, A Decade Later:A Meta-Analytic Test of Social Exchange and Affect-Based Perspectives[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2013,98(2):199-236
[54] Macey W., Schneider B. The Meaning of Employee Engagement[J]. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 2008,1(1):3-30
[55] Colquitt J. A., Conlon D. E., Wesson M. J., et al. Justice at the Millennium:A Meta-Analytic Review of 25 years of Organizational Justice Research[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2001,86(3):425-445
[56] Rupp D. E., Shao R., Jones K. S., et al. The Utility of a Multifoci Approach to the Study of Organizational Justice:A Meta-Analytic Investigation into the Consideration of Normative Rules, Moral Accountability, Bandwidth-Fidelity, and Social Exchange[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2014,123(2):159-185
[57] Long C. P. Mapping the Main Roads to Fairness:Examining the Managerial Context of Fairness Promotion[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2016,137(4):1-27
[58] Morten B. N., Jan O. C., Live B. F., et al. Are Leadership Fairness,Psychological Distress, and Role Stressors Interrelated? A Two-Wave Prospective Study of Forward and Reverse Relationships[J]. Original Research, 2018,9(90):1-12
[59] Bateman T., Crant J. The Proactive Component of Organizational Behavior:A Measure and Correlates[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1993,14(2):103-118
[60] Crant J. M. Proactive Behavior in Organizations[J]. Journal of Management, 2000,26(3):435-462
[61] Wang Z. X., Zhang J., Candice L. T., et al. Explaining Benefits of Employee Proactive Personality:The Role of Engagement, Team Proactivity Composition and Perceived Organizational Support[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2017,101(Aug.):90-103
[62] Bakker A. B, Tims M., Derks D. Proactive Personality and Job Performance:The Role of Job Crafting and Work Engagement[J]. Human Relations, 2012,65(10):1359-1378
[63] Bakker A. B., Demerouti E. The Job Demand-Resources Model:State of the Art[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2007,22(3):309-328
[64] Woodside A. G. Visualizing· Matching· Generalizing:Case Identification Hypotheses and Case-Level Data Analysis[J]. Australasian Marketing Journal, 2015,23(3):246-258
[65] 杜运周,贾良定. 组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA):管理学研究的一条新道路[J]. 管理世界, 2017,(6):155-167
[66] 王凤彬,江鸿,王璁. 央企集团管控架构的演进:战略决定、制度引致还是路径依赖?——一项定性比较分析(QCA)尝试[J]. 管理世界, 2014,(12):92-114
[67] Katz D., Kahn R. L. The Social Psychology of Organizations[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1978,46(1):1-23
[68] Sumerlin J. R., Bundrick C. M. Brief Index of Self-Actualization:A Measure of Maslow's Model[J]. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality, 1996,11(6):253-271
[69] Hekman D. R., Steensma H. K., Bigley G. A., et al. Combined Effects of Organizational and Professional Identification on the Reciprocity Dynamic for Professional Employees[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2009,52(3):506-526
[70] Niehoff B. P., Moorman R. H. Justice as A Mediator of the Relationship between Methods of Monitoring and Organizational Citizenship Behavior[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1993,36(3):527-556
[71] Crant J. M. The Proactive Personality Scale and Objective Job Performance among Real Estate Agents[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1995,80(4):532-537
[72] Claudius W., Jonas B., Markus B. S. QCA and Business Research:Work in Progress or a Consolidated Agenda?[J]. Journal of Business Reaearch, 2016,69(7):2531-2540
[73] Magali A., Delmas, Sanja P. Organizational Configurations for Sustainability and Employee Productivity:A Qualitative Comparative Analysis Approach[J]. Business & Society, 2018,57(1):216-251
[74] Ragin C. C. Set Relations in Social Research:Evaluating Their Consistency and Courage[J]. Political Analysis, 2006,14:291-310
[75] Chang M. L., Cheng C. F. How Balance Theory Explains High-Tech Professionals' Solutions of Enhancing Job Satisfaction[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2014,67(9):2008-2018
[76] Fugate M., Kinicki A. K., Ashforth B. E. Employability:A Psycho-social Construct, Its Dimensions, and Applications[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2004,65(1):14-38
[77] 夏鑫,何建民,刘嘉毅. 定性比较分析的研究逻辑——兼论其对经济管理学研究的启示[J]. 财经研究, 2014,40(10):97-107
[78] 郭钟泽,谢宝国,程延园. 昨天的积极体验影响今天的工作投入吗?——一项经验取样的日记研究[J]. 管理评论, 2019,31(1):171-182
[79] 张静,宋继文,郑晓明,等. 基于调节性中介模型的领导与下属特质正念对工作投入的影响研究[J]. 管理学报, 2018,15(11):1629-1637
[80] Robert G. L., Douglas J. B., Steven J. F. Understanding the Dynamics of Leadership:The Role of Follower Self-Concepts in the Leader/Follower Relationship[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Process, 1999,78(3):167-203