一致性文化和成就动机对自我导向型工作重塑行为的双核驱动——基于自我调节理论的实证研究

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 基于自我调节理论，以来自31家企业283名员工的配对调查数据，考察一致性文化、成就动机对自我导向型工作重塑多维多向行为的驱动机制。多层次分析结果显示：成就动机和一致性文化（作为强文化）均能独立驱动促进型重塑行为（即增加关系性资源、增加结构性资源、增加挑战性要求），但并不能抑制防御型重塑行为（即减少阻碍性要求）；一致性文化（作为关系导向型文化）仅能减弱成就动机对增加关系性资源的积极影响，但并不能强化成就动机对增加结构性资源、增加挑战性要求和减少阻碍性要求的影响。这些结论揭示了成就动机和一致性文化是自我导向型工作重塑行为的双核驱动力，并且一致性文化在成就动机和自我导向型工作重塑行为之间的调节效应具有一定指向性。研究结论不仅从理论上丰富了自我导向型工作重塑行为的前因研究，也为实务界对如何引导员工开展更多促进型工作重塑活动拓宽了思路。

关键词: 工作重塑行为, 成就动机, 一致性文化, 自我调节理论

Abstract: Based on self-regulatory theory, this paper uses the dyad data of 283 employees from 31 companies to investigate how consistent culture and achievement motivation drive multi-dimensional and multi-directional behaviors of self-centered job-crafting. The results of multilevel analysis show: Both achievement motivation and consistent culture (as a strong culture) can independently drive individuals to perform more promotion-focused job-crafting behavior (including increasing relational resources, increasing structural resources and increasing challenging demands), but can not inhibit the prevention-focused job-crafting behavior (i.e., decreasing hindering job demands); Consistent culture (as a relationship-oriented culture) can only mitigate the positive impact of achievement motivation on increasing relational resources, but can not moderate the effect of achievement motivation on increasing structural resources, increasing challenging demands and decreasing hindering demands. These results highlight that achievement motivation and consistent culture are the dual core drivers of job-crafting behaviors, and the interaction effects between the dual core driving forces exist only in specific culture type and its corresponding behavior. These conclusions not only enrich the antecedents of self-centered job-crafting behavior but also provide some viewpoints on how to guide the employees to craft their job positively.

Key words: job crafting behavior, achievement motivation, consistent culture, self-regulatory theory

陈建安, 程爽, 陈瑞. 一致性文化和成就动机对自我导向型工作重塑行为的双核驱动——基于自我调节理论的实证研究[J]. 管理评论, 2020, 32(11): 170-183.

Chen Jianan, Cheng Shuang, Chen Rui. An Empirical Study on Achievement Motivation and Consistent Culture as Dual Core Drivers of Self-oriented Job-Crafting Behavior: Based on Self-regulatory Theory[J]. Management Review, 2020, 32(11): 170-183.

参考文献

[1] Wrzesniewski A., Dutton J. E. Crafting a Job:Revisioning Employees as Active Crafters of Their Work[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2001,26(2):179-201
[2] Tims M., Bakker A. Job Crafting:Towards a New Model of Individual Job Redesign[J]. SA Journal of Industrial Psychology, 2010,36(2):1-9
[3] Esteves T., Lopes M. P. Crafting a Calling:The Mediating Role of Calling between Challenging Job Demands and Turnover Intention[J]. Journal of Career Development, 2017,44(1):34-48
[4] Kira M., Eijnatten F. M., Balkin D. B. Crafting Sustainable Work:Development of Personal Resources[J]. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 2010,23(5):616-632
[5] Mattarelli E., Tagliaventi M. R. How Offshore Professionals' Job Dissatisfaction Can Promote Further Offshoring:Organizational Outcomes of Job Crafting[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2012,52(5):585-620
[6] Nielsen K., Abildgaard J. S. The Development and Validation of a Job Crafting Measure for Use with Blue-collar Workers[J]. Work & Stress, 2012,26(4):365-384
[7] Rosso B. D., Dekas K. H., Wrzesniewski A. On the Meaning of Work:A Theoretical Integration and Review[J]. Research in Organizational Behavior, 2010,30:91-127
[8] Slemp G. R., Vella-Brodrick D. A. Optimising Employee Mental Health:The Relationship between Intrinsic Need Satisfaction, Job Crafting and Employee Well-being[J]. Journal of Happiness Studies, 2014,15(4):957-977
[9] Tims M., Bakker A., Derks D. Development and Validation of the Job Crafting Scale[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2012,80(1):173-186
[10] Tims M., Bakker A. B., Daantje D. The Impact of Job Crafting on Job Demands, Job Resources and Well-being[J]. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2013,18(2):230-240
[11] Tims M., Bakker A., Derks D. Daily Job Crafting and the Self-Efficacy-Performance Relationship[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2014,29(5):490-507
[12] Tims M., Derks D., Bakker A. B. Job Crafting and Its Relationships with Person-Job Fit and Meaningfulness:A Three-Wave Study[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2016,92(2):44-53
[13] Wellman N., Spreitzer G. Crafting Scholarly Life:Strategies for Creating Meaning in Academic Careers[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2011,32(6):927-931
[14] Hakanen J. J., Seppälä P., Peeters M. C. W. High Job Demands, Still Engaged and Not Burned Out? The Role of Job Crafting[J]. International Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 2017,24(4):619-627
[15] Rudolph C. W., Katz I. M., Lavigne K. N., et al. Job Crafting:A Meta-analysis of Relationships with Individual Differences, Job Characteristics and Work Outcomes[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2017,102:112-138
[16] Wingerden J. V., Bakker A. B., Derks D. Fostering Employee Well-being via a Job Crafting Intervention[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2017,100:164-174
[17] Chen C. Y., Yen C. H., Tsai F. C. Job Crafting and Job Engagement:The Mediating Role of Person-Job Fit[J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2014,37(1):21-28
[18] Lotta K. H., Jari J. H., Wilmar B. S. Can Job Crafting Reduce Job Boredom and Increase Work Engagement? A Three-Year Cross-Lagged Panel Study[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2016,95/96:11-20
[19] Vogt K., Hakanen J. J., Brauchli R., et al. The Consequences of Job Crafting:A Three-Wave Study[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2016,25(3):353-362
[20] 尹奎,孙健敏,陈乐妮. 基于串联中介模型的认知重塑对工作投入的影响研究[J]. 管理学报, 2017,14(4):528-536
[21] Demerouti E., Bakker A. B., Halbesleben J. R. B. Productive and Counterproductive Job Crafting:A Daily Diary Study[J]. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2015,20(4):457-469
[22] Gordon H. J., Demerouti E., Blanc P. M. L., et al. Individual Job Redesign:Job Crafting Interventions in Healthcare[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2018,104:98-114
[23] Tims M., Bakker A. B., Derks D. Job Crafting and Job Performance:A Longitudinal Study[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2015,24(6):914-928
[24] Wingerden J. V., Derks D., Bakker A. B. The Impact of Personal Resources and Job Crafting Interventions on Work Engagement and Performance[J]. Human Resource Management, 2017,56(1):51-67
[25] Peeters M. C. W., Arts R., Demerouti E. The Crossover of Job Crafting between Coworkers and Its Relationship with Adaptivity[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2016,25(6):819-832
[26] Petrou P., Demerouti E., Xanthopoulou D. Regular Versus Cutback-Related Change:The Role of Employee Job Crafting in Organizational Change Contexts of Different Nature[J]. International Journal of Stress Management, 2017,24(1):62-85
[27] Bakker A. B., Tims M., Derks D. Proactive Personality and Job Performance:The Role of Job Crafting and Work Engagement[J]. Human Relations, 2012,65(10):1359-1378
[28] Lyons P. The Crafting of Jobs and Individual Differences[J]. Journal of Business & Psychology, 2008,23(1):25-36
[29] Cenciotti R., Alessandri G., Borgogni L. Psychological Capital and Career Success Over Time:The Mediating Role of Job Crafting[J]. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 2017,24(3):372-384
[30] Miraglia M., Cenciotti R., Alessandri G., et al. Translating Self-efficacy in Job Performance Over Time:The Role of Job Crafting[J]. Human Performance, 2017,30(5):254-271
[31] Sekiguchi T., Li J., Hosomi M. Predicting Job Crafting From the Socially Embedded Perspective:The Interactive Effect of Job Autonomy, Social Skill and Employee Status[J]. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2017,53(4):470-497
[32] Kooij D. T. A. M., Tims M., Akkermans J. The Influence of Future Time Perspective on Work Engagement and Job Performance:the Role of Job Crafting[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2017,26(1):4-15
[33] 谢文心,杨纯,周帆. 资质过剩对员工工作形塑行为关系的研究:工作疏离感与心理弹性的作用[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2015,36(2):149-160
[34] Niessen C., Weseler D., Kostova P. When and Why do Individuals Craft Their Jobs? The Role of Individual Motivation and Work Characteristics for Job Crafting[J]. Human Relations, 2016,69(6):1287-1313
[35] Petrou P., Demerouti E. Trait-Level and Week-Level Regulatory Focus as a Motivation to Craft a Job[J]. Career Development International, 2015,20(2):102-118
[36] Veerle B., Marleen H. K. To Craft or Not to Craft:The Relationships between Regulatory Focus, Job Crafting and Work Outcomes[J]. Career Development International, 2015,20(2):147-162
[37] Wong S. I., Škerlavaj M., Černe M. Build Coalitions to Fit:Autonomy Expectations, Competence Mobilization, and Job Crafting[J]. Human Resource Management, 2017,56(5):785-801
[38] Bavik A., Bavik Y., Tang P. M., et al. Servant Leadership, Employee Job Crafting and Citizenship Behaviors:A Cross-Level Investigation[J]. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 2017,58(4):364-373
[39] Yang R., Ming Y., Ma J., et al. How do Servant Leaders Promote Engagement? A Bottom-up Perspective of Job Crafting[J]. Social Behavior and Personality, 2017,45(11):1815-1828
[40] Wang H. J., Demerouti E., Blanc P. L. Transformational Leadership, Adaptability and Job Crafting:The Moderating Role of Organizational Identification[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2017,100:185-195
[41] Bizzi L. Network Characteristics:When an Individuals Job Crafting Depends on the Jobs of Others[J]. Human Relations, 2017,70(4):436-460
[42] Bakker A. B., Rodriguez-Munoz A., Vergel A. I. S. Modelling Job Crafting Behaviours:Implications for Work Engagement[J]. Human Relations, 2016,69(1):169-189
[43] Kroon B., Kooij D. T. A. M, VanVeldhoven M. J. P. M. Job Crafting and Engagement:Differences in Teams with a Restrictive versus an Unrestrictive Work Context?[J]. Gedrag & Organisatie, 2013,26(1):46-65
[44] Tims M., Bakker A. B., Derks D. The Impact of Job Crafting on Job Demands, Job Resources and Well-being[J]. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2013,18(2):230-240
[45] Berg J. M., Wrzesniewski A., Dutton J. E. Perceiving and Responding to Challenges in Job Crafting at Different Ranks:When Proactivity Requires Adaptivity[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2010,31(2-3):158-186
[46] Denison D., Nieminen L., Kotrba L. Diagnosing Organizational Cultures:A Conceptual and Empirical Review of Culture Effectiveness Surveys[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2013,23(1):145-161
[47] 樊耘,邵芳,张翼. 基于文化差异观的组织文化友好性和一致性对组织变革的影响[J]. 管理评论, 2011,23(8):152-161
[48] 张玮,刘延平. 组织文化对组织承诺的影响研究——职业成长的中介作用检验[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(8):117-126
[49] Lichtenthaler P. W., Fischbach A. Job Crafting and Motivation to Continue Working beyond Retirement Age[J]. Career Development International, 2016,21(5):477-497
[50] Demerouti E. Design Your Own Job through Job Crafting[J]. European Psychologist, 2014,19(4):237-247
[51] Demerouti E., Bakker A. B., Gevers J. M. P. Job Crafting and Extra-Role Behavior:The Role of Work Engagement and Flourishing[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2015,91:87-96
[52] Petrou P., Demerouti E., Peeters M. C. W., et al. Crafting a Job on a Daily Basis:Contextual Correlates and the Link to Work Engagement[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2012,33(8):1120-1141
[53] Petrou P., Demerouti E., Schaufeli W. B. Job Crafting in Changing Organizations:Antecedents and Implications for Exhaustion and Performance[J]. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2015,20(4):470-480
[54] Weseler D., Niessen C. How Job Crafting Relates to Task Performance[J]. Journal of Management Psychology, 2016,31(3):672-685
[55] Lu C., Wang H., Lu J. Does Work Engagement Increase Person-Job Fit? The Role of Job Crafting and Job Insecurity[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2014,84(2):142-152
[56] Simmering M. J., Colquitt J. A., Noe R. A., et al. Conscientiousness, Autonomy Fit and Development:A Longitudinal Study[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2003,88(5):954-963
[57] Vogel R. M., Rodell J. B., Lynch J. W. Engaged and Productive Misfits:How Job Crafting and Leisure Activity Mitigate the Negative Effects of Value Incongruence[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2016,59(5):1561-1584
[58] Wingerden J. V., Poell R. F. Employees' Perceived Opportunities to Craft and In-Role Performance:The Mediating Role of Job Crafting and Work Engagement[J]. Frontiers in Psychology, 2017,8:1-9
[59] Berdicchia D., Nicolli F., Masino G. Job Enlargement, Job Crafting and the Moderating Role of Self-Competence[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2016,31(2):318-330
[60] Denison D. R., Mishra A. K. Toward a Theory of Organizational Culture and Effectiveness[J]. Organization Science, 1995,6(2):204-223
[61] Berg J. M., Grant A. M., Johnson V. When Callings Are Calling:Crafting Work and Leisure in Pursuit of Unanswered Occupational Callings[J]. Organization Science, 2010,21(5):973-994
[62] Leana C., Appelbaum E., Shevchuk I. Work Process and Quality of Care in Early Childhood Education:The Role of Job Crafting[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2009,52(6):1169-1192
[63] 叶仁敏,Hagtvet K. A. 成就动机的测量与分析[J]. 心理发展与教育, 1992,(2):14-16
[64] Bipp T., Demerouti E. Which Employees Craft Their Jobs and How? Basic Dimensions of Personality and Employees' Job Crafting Behaviour[J]. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2015,88(4):631-655
[65] Brenninkmeijer V., Hekkertkoning M. To Craft or Not to Craft:The Relationships between Regulatory Focus, Job Crafting and Work Outcomes[J]. Career Development International, 2015,20(2):147-162