媒体参与食品安全社会共治的条件与策略

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

现有研究多从理性假设出发探讨媒体参与食品安全治理的作用，鲜有探讨媒体参与食品安全治理的具体条件和情境。本文构建有限理性假设条件下的媒体与食品生产经营者的不完全信息动态博弈模型，研究表明，媒体参与食品安全社会共治有三个重要约束条件：一是生产经营者感知声誉损失的敏感程度，二是媒体参与社会共治的主观价值判断，三是政府需要对监管保持常态化而非“运动式”监管处罚。因此，媒体参与食品安全社会共治的主要策略有四：（1）社会声誉机制是媒体参与社会共治的重要前提，除惩罚和问责外，监管者还可采取判罚违规者社会服务令等多种方式提高社会声誉机制的有效性；（2）媒体对食品安全违规行为或事件进行持续跟踪调查或深度报道，而非“运动式”报道或采访；（3）媒体参与食品安全社会共治既需要权威媒体介入，也需要新媒体介入，形成全覆盖的媒体监督体系，才会对违规生产行为构成足够震慑；（4）媒体参与社会共治的监督尽可能采取媒体群体监督的模式，既需要从体制和社会责任感上建立制度和规则来参与，也需要从选拔合适的媒体记者角度来参与社会共治。

关键词: 食品安全, 社会共治, 媒体参与, 声誉机制, 制度安排

Abstract:

The existing literature often starts from the rational behavior assumption to discuss the value of media participating in the food safety governance, but seldom discusses the condition and strategy media participating in food safety. This paper develops a dynamic game theory model of media and food safety firm based on the bounded rational behavior assumption. Result shows that the condition of media participating in food safety social co-governance includes three parts:the level of reputation sensitivity of food firm, the judge of media and the punishment of government regulation. As a result, the strategy of media participating in food safety social co-governance is as follows:(1) The social reputation of media is the condition of media participating in co-governance, so that government can use other methods to maintain the social reputation institution; (2) The style of media reporting food safety violation behavior should be constant and deep, rather than just transient. (3) Both traditional media and new media should participate in food safety social co-governance, so that media can deter the violation of food safety; (4) Government should develop a media supervision system so that media participation can become legal and more qualified reporters would participate in this area.

Key words: food safety, social co-governance, media participation, reputation institution, institutional arrangement

谢康, 刘意, 赵信. 媒体参与食品安全社会共治的条件与策略[J]. , 2017, 29(5): 192-204.

Xie Kang, Liu Yi, Zhao Xin. The Condition and Strategy of Media Participating in Food Safety Social Co-governance[J]. , 2017, 29(5): 192-204.

参考文献

[1] 张煜,汪寿阳. 食品供应链质量安全管理模式研究——三鹿奶粉事件案例分析[J]. 管理评论, 2010,22(10):67-74
[2] 谢康,赖金天,肖静华. 食品安全社会共治下供应链质量协同特征与制度需求[J]. 管理评论,2015,27(2):158-167
[3] Zhang W., Xue J. Economically Motivated Food Fraud and Adulteration in China: An Analysis Based on 1553 Media Reports[J]. Food Control, 2016,6(7):192-198
[4] 王永钦,刘思远,杜巨澜. 信任品市场的竞争效应与传染效应:理论和基于中国食品行业的事件研究[J]. 经济研究, 2014,(2):141-154
[5] Rutsaert P., Regan Á., Pieniak Z., et al. The Use of Social Media in Food Risk and Benefit Communication[J]. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 2013,30(1):84-91
[6] Dillaway R., Messer K. D., Bernard J. C., et al. Do Consumer Responses to Media Food Safety Information Last?[J]. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 2011,33(3):363-383
[7] Fuentes M., Fuentes C. Risk Stories In the Media: Food Consumption, Risk and Anxiety[J]. Food, Culture & Society, 2015,18(1):71-87
[8] Piotroski J. D., Wong T. J., Zhang T. Political Incentives to Suppress Negative Information: Evidence From Chinese Listed Firms[J]. Journal of Accounting Research, 2015,53(2):405-459
[9] Phillipov M. Using Media to Promote Artisan Food and Beverages: Insights from the Television Industry[J]. British Food Journal, 2016,118(3):588-602
[10] 全世文,曾寅初. 我国食品安全监管者的信息瞒报与合谋现象分析——基于委托代理模型的解释与实践验证[J]. 管理评论, 2016,28(2):210-218
[11] 倪国华,郑风田. 媒体监管的交易成本对食品安全监管效率的影响[J]. 经济学(季刊), 2014,13(2):559-582
[12] 李想,石磊. 行业信任危机的一个经济学解释:以食品安全为例[J]. 经济研究, 2014,(1):169-181
[13] Peng Y., Li J., Xia H., et al. The Effects of Food Safety Issues Released by We Media on Consumers' Awareness and Purchasing Behavior: A Case Study in China[J]. Food Policy, 2015,5(1):44-52
[14] 周开国,杨海生,伍颖华. 食品安全监督机制研究——媒体,资本市场与政府协同治理[J]. 经济研究, 2016,(9):58-72
[15] Kuttschreuter M., Rutsaert P., Hilverda F., et al. Seeking Information about Food-Related Risks:The Contribution of Social Media[J]. Food quality and preference, 2014,37(4):10-18
[16] Rieger J., Kuhlgatz C., Anders S. Food Scandals, Media Attention and Habit Persistence Among Desensitised Meat Consumers[J]. Food Policy, 2016,6(4):82-92
[17] 李秀利. 食品安全报道——构建科学与理性的媒介景观[J]. 新闻世界, 2009,(12):130-131
[18] 李玉峰,刘敏,平瑛. 食品安全事件后消费者购买意向波动研究:基于恐惧管理双重防御的视角[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(6):186-196
[19] Chen W. The Effects of Different Types of Trust on Consumer Perceptions of Food Safety: An Empirical Study of Consumers in Beijing Municipality [J]. China Agricultural Economic Review, 2013,5(1):43-65
[20] Rutsaert P., Pieniak Z., Regan Á., et al. Social Media as a Useful Tool in Food Risk and Benefit Communication? A Strategic Orientation Approach[J]. Food Policy, 2014,4(6):84-93
[21] Sharma A., Sneed J., Beattie S. Willingness to Pay for Safer Foods in Foodservice Establishment[J]. Journal of Foodservice Business Research, 2012,15(1):101-116
[22] Ergönül B. Consumer Awareness and Perception to Food Safety: A Consumer Analysis[J]. Food Control, 2013,32(2):461-471
[23] 洪小娟,姜楠,洪巍,等. 媒体信息传播网络研究——以食品安全微博舆情为例[J]. 管理评论, 2016,28(8):115-124
[24] Tiozzo B., Mari S., Magaudda P., et al. Development and Evaluation of a Risk-Communication Campaign on Salmonellosis[J]. Food Control, 2011,22(1):109-117
[25] 雷宇. 声誉机制的信任基础:危机与重建[J]. 管理评论, 2016,28(8):225-237
[26] 雷勋平,邱广华. 基于前景理论的食品行业行为监管演化博弈分析[J]. 系统工程, 2016,34(2):82-88
[27] Mahon J., Wartick S. L. Corporate Social Performance Profiling: Using Multiple Stakeholder Perceptions to Assess a Corporate Reputation[J]. Journal of Public Affairs, 2012,12(1):12-28
[28] Kahneman D., Tversky A. Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision Under Risk[J]. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 1979,47(2):263-291
[29] Kahneman D., Tversky A. Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk[J]. Rationality in Action: Contemporary Approaches, 1990,(6):140-170
[30] Kahneman D., Tversky A. Conflict Resolution: A Cognitive Perspective[M]. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1992
[31] 赵欣. 食品安全事件报道的特征及 “新闻螺旋”——以大公报对 “三鹿事件”的报道为例[J]. 新闻世界, 2010,(3):69-70
[32] 鄢子为. 食品安全事件报道的特点及 “新闻螺旋”——以《21 世纪经济报道》对 “工业明胶事件”的报道为例[J]. 青年记者, 2013,(23):39-40
[33] Friedman D. On Economic Applications of Evolutionary Game Theory[J]. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 1998,8(1):15-43
[34] Stanwick P. A., Stanwick S. D. The Relationship between Corporate Social Performance, and Organizational Size, Financial Performance, and Environmental Performance: An Empirical Examination[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 1998,17(2):195-204
[35] Lai C. S., Chiu C. J., Yang C. F., et al. The Effects of Corporate Social Responsibility on Brand Performance: The Mediating Effect of Industrial Brand Equity and Corporate Reputation[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2010,95(3):457-469
[36] 范春梅,贾建民,李华强. 食品安全事件中的公众风险感知及应对行为研究——以问题奶粉事件为例[J]. 管理评论, 2012,24(1):163-168
[37] 李新春,陈斌. 企业群体性败德行为与管制失效——对产品质量安全与监管的制度分析[J]. 经济研究, 2013,(10):98-111
[38] 赖金天. 有限理性情境下食品安全事件发生机制及社会共治解决策略研究[D]. 中山大学博士学位论文, 2015
[39] 谢康,赖金天,肖静华,等. 食品安全、监管有界性与制度安排[J]. 经济研究, 2016,(4):174-187
[40] 王海燕,陈欣,于荣. 质量链协同视角下的食品安全控制与治理研究[J]. 管理评论, 2016,28(11):228-234
[41] 吴元元. 信息基础, 声誉机制与执法优化——食品安全治理的新视野[J]. 中国社会科学, 2012,(6):115-133