基于合作博弈的碳配额交易价格形成机制研究

›› 2016, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (2): 15-24.

基于合作博弈的碳配额交易价格形成机制研究

谢晶晶, 窦祥胜

西南交通大学经济管理学院, 成都 610031

收稿日期:2014-01-17 出版日期:2016-02-28 发布日期:2016-03-01
作者简介:谢晶晶,西南交通大学经济管理学院博士研究生;窦祥胜,西南交通大学经济管理学院教授,硕士生导师,博士.
基金资助:
国家社会科学基金项目(10XJY004).

Carbon Cap-and-trade Pricing Mechanism Based on Cooperative Game Theory

Xie Jingjing, Dou Xiangsheng

School of Economics and Management, Southwest Jiaotong University of China, Chengdu 610031

Received:2014-01-17 Online:2016-02-28 Published:2016-03-01

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

现阶段我国碳交易试点已启动,形成碳配额交易价格机制的任务迫在眉睫.本文在考虑尤为复杂的碳市场风险体系的基础上,针对我国碳市场众多、有场无市、市场不成熟等特有现象提出了基于合作博弈理论的碳配额价格机制.本文首先运用网络层次分析法(ANP)来确定碳配额交易的风险值,综合考虑了影响碳市场的所有风险因子.然后应用班茨哈夫-克莱曼(B-C)权利指数来探讨交易伙伴的选择与交易量的瓜分,分散了交易风险.最后通过Shapley值和核仁法来探讨碳配额交易利益分配的合理性,保障了合作联盟的稳定性.此时,碳配额价格便可由利润公式求出.本文的研究结果表明,应用该三阶段博弈模型来模拟碳配额交易的价格形成机制可以有效地分散交易风险,能够很好地解决碳交易市场风险较一般市场大且复杂这一问题,是实现我国统一碳市场的重大推力.

关键词: 碳配额交易, 班茨哈夫-克莱曼权利指数, 网络层次分析法, Shapley值法, 核仁法

Abstract:

Carbon trading pilot was launched in China recently, and the next urgent task is to form a carbon cap-and-trade pricing mechanism. Given that the carbon market in China is highly fragmented, immature and lacking of transactions, this paper proposes a carbon cap-and-trade pricing mechanism based on cooperative game theory and takes account of particularly complex risk system of carbon market. This paper firstly determines the risk value of cap-and-trade by Analytic Network Process, which considers all risk factors of the carbon market synthetically. Then, to disperse the trading risk, B-C index is applied to discuss the choice of trading partners and the trading volume. Finally, this paper discusses the rationality of the carbon trading profit distribution by Shapley value and Nucleolus method, which guarantees the stability of the alliance. Here, carbon cap-and-trade price can be calculated by profit formula. The study shows that applying this three-stage game model to simulate the carbon cap-and-trade pricing mechanism can disperse trading risk effectively and solve the problem that the risk of carbon trading market is larger and more complex than common market. Hence, it is the key driver for implementing unified carbon market in China.

Key words: carbon cap-and-trade, B-C index, Analytic Network Process (ANP), Shapley value method, nucleolus method

谢晶晶, 窦祥胜. 基于合作博弈的碳配额交易价格形成机制研究[J]. , 2016, 28(2): 15-24.

Xie Jingjing, Dou Xiangsheng. Carbon Cap-and-trade Pricing Mechanism Based on Cooperative Game Theory[J]. , 2016, 28(2): 15-24.

参考文献

[1] Lilley W. E., Reedman L. J., Wagner L. D., et al. An Economic Evaluation of the Potential for Distributed Energy in Australia[J]. Energy Policy, 2012,51:277-289
[2] Charles A., et al. Testing the Martingale Difference Hypothesis in CO2 Emission Allowances[J]. Economic Modeling, 2011,28(1):27-35
[3] Chevallier J., Ielpo F., Mercier L. Risk Aversion and Institutional Information Disclosure on the European Carbon Market: A Case Study of the 2006 Compliance Event[J]. Energy Policy, 2009,37(1):15-28
[4] Chevallier J. Carbon Futures and Macroeconomic Risk Factors: A View From the EU ETS[J]. Energy Economics, 2009,31(4):614-625
[5] 张跃军,魏一鸣.国际碳期货价值的均值回归: 基于EU ETS的实证分析[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 2011,31(2):214-220
[6] 蒋晶晶,叶斌,马晓明.基于 GARCH-EVT-VaR 模型的碳市场风险计量实证研究[J]. 北京大学学报(自然科学版), 2015,51(3):511-517
[7] 屈晓龙,李波,刘雪静.碳限额与交易机制下考虑次品率的供应链优化研究[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(9)187-200
[8] Dou X. S., Xie J. J., Ye Z. L. Policy Design and Implementation Issues of Regulating Greenhouse Gas Emissions in China[J]. International Journal of Environmental Science and Development, 2013,4(3):321-326
[9] 杨菁,冯欣楠.湖北将启动强制碳减排年耗6万吨标煤企业必须碳交易[N]. 长江日报, 2013-01-12
[10] 黄宙辉.广东试点碳交易进入实操阶段[N]. 羊城晚报, 2013-02-28
[11] Urs S. The Market for Tradable GHG Permits Under the Kyoto Protocol: A Survey of Model Studies[J]. Energy Economics, 2003,25(5):527-551
[12] Chesney M., Taschini L. The Endogenous Price Dynamics of Emission Allowances and an Application to CO2 Option Pricing[J]. Applied Mathematical Finance, 2012,19(5):447-475
[13] Tol R. S. J. A Cost-Benefit Analysis of the EU 20/20/2020 Package[J]. Energy Policy, 2012,49:288-295
[14] Middleton R. S., Eccles J. K. The Complex Future of CO2 Capture and Storage: Variable Electricity Generation and Fossil Fuel Power[J]. Applied Energy, 2013,108:66-73
[15] Nanduri V., Otieno W. Assessing the Impact of Different Auction-based CO2 Allowance Allocation Mechanisms[C]. IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting, IEEE Computer Society, 2011
[16] Mizrach B. Integration of the Global Carbon Markets[J]. Energy Economics, 2012,34(1):335-349
[17] Charles A., Darne O., Fouilloux J. Market Efficiency in the European Carbon Markets[J]. Energy Policy, 2013,60:785-792
[18] Palao F., Pardo A. What Makes Carbon Traders Cluster Their Orders?[J]. Energy Economics, 2014,43:158-165
[19] Brian M., Nicholas R. British Columbia's Revenue-neutral Carbon Tax: A Review of the Latest "Grand Experiment" in Environmental Policy[J]. Energy Policy, 2015,86:674-683
[20] Ronald H., Mehtap K. Time Variation in European Carbon Pass-through Rates in Electricity Futures Prices[J]. Energy Policy, 2015,86:239-249
[21] 隗斌贤,揭筱纹.基于国际碳交易经验的长三角区域碳交易市场构建思路与对策[J]. 管理世界, 2012,(2):175-176
[22] 袁永娜,石敏俊,李娜.碳排放许可的初始分配与区域协调发展——基于多区域CGE模型的模拟分析[J]. 管理评论, 2013,25(2):43-50
[23] 徐大伟,杨娜,陈德湖,等.商业银行碳金融业务收益模型构建与分析: 基于碳减排的视角[J]. 管理评论, 2013,25(6):19-23
[24] 张跃军,魏一鸣.化石能源市场对国际碳市场的动态影响实证研究[J]. 管理评论, 2010,22(6):34-41
[25] 谭志雄,陈德敏.区域碳交易模式及实现路径研究[J]. 中国软科学, 2012,(4):76-84
[26] Chevallier J. Econometric Analysis of Carbon Markets[M]. Dordrecht: Springer, 2011
[27] Heiða N. G., Haraldur ó. H. Predicting the Price of EU ETS Carbon Credits[J]. System Engineering Procedia, 2011,1:481-489
[28] Saaty T. L. Decision Making with Dependence and Feedback[M]. Pittsburgh, PA: RW S Publication, 1996
[29] Saaty T. L. Time Dependent Decision-making; Dynamic Priorities in the AHP/ANP: Generalizing from Points to Functions and from Real to Complex Variables[J]. Mathematical and Computer Modeling, 2007,46(7,8):860-891
[30] Banzhaf J. F. Weighted Voting Doesn't Work: A Mathematical Analysis[J]. Rutgers Law Review, 1965,(19):317-343
[31] Coleman J. S. Control of Collectivities and the Power of a Collectivity to Act[A]//Lieberman B. Social Choice[C]. New York: Gordon and Breach, 1971
[32] Shapley L. S. A Value for N-Person Games[A]//Kuhn H., Tucker A. W. Contributions to the Theory of Games II[C]. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1953
[33] Shapley L. S. Additive and Non-additive Set Function[D]. PhD Thesis, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University, 1953
[34] Schmeidler D. The Nucleolus of a Characteristic Function Game[J]. SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics, 1969,17(6):1163-1170
[35] Peleg B., Sudholter P. Introduction to the Theory of Cooperative Games[M]. Norwell: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2003