基于Meta分析的团队断裂研究：分类，效果与情境

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

人口统计学断裂带的断裂效果是团队研究领域的重要内容之一，深入开展该问题的研究对企业的管理实践有着直接的指引作用。但目前关于团队断裂的研究存在如下几点不足：研究结论存在争议、缺乏对于断裂效果的分类与整合、未考虑具体的情境因素等。本文将人口统计学断裂细分为社会分类断裂带和信息基础断裂带两个维度，并将效果变量划分为团队过程效果和团队结果效果。根据断裂理论基础和作用机理的不同，将团队过程效果划分为社会整合和认知整合两类，而团队结果效果则重点关注断裂对团队绩效的影响。采用"input-process-outcome"的研究框架，探讨了不同类型的断裂对团队过程（社会整合和认知整合）与团队结果（团队绩效）的差异化影响，此外还比较了产业类型和团队特征等因素对于断裂关系的调节作用。采用Meta分析方法，对38篇独立文献的119个效应值进行了再统计分析，分析结果表明：社会分类断裂带和信息基础断裂带在与认知整合和团队绩效的关系上存在作用方向上的差异；产业类型与团队特征对信息基础断裂带与创新绩效之间的关系具有显著调节作用。文章最后从理论贡献、实际应用和研究不足等方面对结果进行了讨论，并提出了未来的研究方向。

关键词: 社会分类断裂带, 信息基础断裂带, 断裂效果, Meta分析

Abstract:

Demographic faultline is one of the most important concepts in the team field, and the outcomes of demographic faultline raise lots of attention. But by now, the researches about team faultline still have some shortages. For instance, the conclusions are in disputes, there is no research about outcomes of faultline by category and specific situation is not taken into consideration. In this paper, we divide the team faultline into social category faultline and information-based faultline. Then we divide the faultline effect into process effect and outcome effect. On the basis of different theoretical bases and function mechanism, we divide the process effect into two parts:social integration and cognitive integration. Referring to the outcome effect, we pay more attention the team performance. Based on this classification, we use the "input-process-outcome" paradigm to discuss the different effects on the faultline process (social integration and cognitive integration) and faultline outcome (especially team performance). In addition, we pick the industry type and team characteristic as the moderators to explore the influence on the faultline and its effects. This study uses Meta-analysis to integrate results on the 119 effect sizes from 38 independent papers. The results show that there is a difference on the outcomes between social category faultline and information-based faultline, and industry type and team characteristic play significant role between information-based faultline and team creativity. In the end, we discuss the outcomes from the theory contribution, practical application and the shortage of research, in addition to the future research directions.

Key words: social category faultline, information-based faultline, the effects of faultline, Meta-analysis

陈慧, 梁巧转, 张悦. 基于Meta分析的团队断裂研究：分类，效果与情境[J]. , 2019, 31(3): 116-130.

Chen Hui, Liang Qiaozhuan, Zhang Yue. A Meta-Analysis on Team Faultline: Category, Effect and Situation[J]. , 2019, 31(3): 116-130.

参考文献

[1] Devine D. J., Clayton L. D., Philips J. L., et al. Teams in Organizations:Prevalence, Characteristics, and Effectiveness[J]. Small Group Research, 1999,30(6):678-711
[2] Kochan T., Bezrukova K., Ely R., et al. The Effects of Diversity on Business Performance:Report of the Diversity Research Network[J]. Human Resource Management Journal, 2003,42(1):3-21
[3] Thatcher S. M. B., Patel P. C. Group Faultlines:A Review, Integration, and Guide to Future Research[J]. Journal of Management, 2012,38(4):969-1009
[4] Williams K., O'Reilly C. A. Demography and Diversity in Organizations:A Review of 40 Years of Research[J]. Research in Organizational Behavior, 1998,20(1):77-140
[5] Lau D. C., Murnighan J. K. Demographic Diversity and Faultlines:The Compositional Dynamics of Organizational Groups[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1998,23(2):325-340
[6] 谢小云,张倩. 国外团队断裂带研究现状评介与未来展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2011,33(1):34-42
[7] Horwitz S. K., Horwitz I. B. The Effects of Team Diversity on Team Outcomes:A Meta-Analytic Review of Team Demography[J]. Journal of Management Official Journal of the Southern Management Association, 2007,33(6):987-1015
[8] Catton A. M., Cummings J. N. The Impact of Subgroup Type and Subgroup Configurational Properties on Work Team Performance[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2013,98(5):732-758
[9] Jehn K. A., Bezrukova K. The Faultline Activation Process and the Effects of Activated Faultlines on Coalition Formation, Conflict, and Group Outcomes[J]. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes, 2011,112(1):24-42
[10] 曹红军,肖国团. 高管团队断层线对绩效的非线性影响——基于CEO权变管理的研究视角[J]. 科技与产业, 2016,16(1):121-140
[11] Bezrukova K., Spell C. S., Caldwell D., et al. A Multilevel Perspective on Faultlines:Differentiating the Effects Between Group-and Organizational-Level Faultlines[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2015,101(1):86-107
[12] Chung Y., Liao H., Jackson S. E., et al. Cracking But not Breaking:Joint Effects of Faultline Strength and Diversity Climate on Loyal Behavior[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2015,58(5):1-6
[13] Bezrukova K., Jehn K. A., Zanutto E., et al. Do Faultlines Hurt or Help? Exploring Distance, Identity, Task Conflict, and Individual Performance in Diverse Groups[C]. IACM 18th Annual Conference, 2005
[14] Charles A., O'Reilly., David F., et al. Work Group Demography, Social Integration, and Turnover[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1989,34(1):21-37
[15] Cronin M. A., Bezrukova K., Weingart L. R., et al. Subgroups Within a Team:The Role of Cognitive and Affective Integration[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2011,32(6):831-849
[16] Gladstein D. L. Groups in Context:A Model of Task Group Effectiveness[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1984,29(4):499-517
[17] 王海珍,刘新梅,张若勇,等. 国外团队断裂研究的现状及展望——团队多样性研究的新进展[J]. 管理学报, 2009,6(10):1413-1420
[18] Hambrick D. C., Li J., Xin K., et al. Compositional Gaps and Downward Spirals in International Joint Venture Management Groups[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2001,22(11):1033-1053
[19] Hutzschenreuter T., Horstkotte J. Performance Effects of Top Management Team Demographic Faultlines in the Process of Product Diversification[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2013,34(6):704-726
[20] Pelled L. H. Demographic Diversity, Conflict, and Work Group Outcomes:An Intervening Process Theory[J]. Organization Science, 1996,7(6):615-631
[21] Tajfel H., Billig M. G., Bundy R. P., et al. Social Categorization and Intergroup Behavior[J]. European Journal of Social Psychology, 1971,1(2):149-178
[22] Webber S. S., Donahue L. M. Impact of Highly and Less Job-Related Diversity on Work Group Cohesion and Performance:A Meta-Analysis[J]. Journal of Management, 2001,27(2):141-162
[23] Bezrukova K., Jehn K. A., Zanutto E. L., et al. Do Workgroup Faultlines Help or Hurt? A Moderated Model of Faultlines, Team Identification, and Group Performance[J]. Organization Science, 2009,20(1):35-50
[24] Molleman E. Diversity in Demographic Characteristics, Abilities and Personality Traits:Do Faultlines Affect Team Functioning?[J]. Group decision and Negotiation, 2005,14(3):173-193
[25] Jiang Y., Jackson S. E., Shaw J. B., et al. The Consequences of Educational Specialty and Nationality Faultlines for Project Teams[J]. Small Group Research, 2012,43(5):613-644
[26] Rupert J., Blomme R. J., Dragt M. J., et al. Being Different, But Close:How and When Faultlines Enhance Team Learning[J]. European Management Review, 2016,13(4):275-290
[27] Harrison D. A., Price K. H., Gavin J. H., et al. Time, Teams, and Task Performance:Changing Effects of Surface and Deep-Level Diversity on Group Functioning[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2002,45(5):1029-1045
[28] Wendt H., Euwema M. C., Emmerik I. J. H. V. Leadership and Team Cohesiveness across Cultures[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2004,20(3):358-370
[29] Mach M., Baruch Y. Team Performance in Cross Cultural Project Teams:The Moderated Mediation Role of Consensus, Heterogeneity, Faultlines and Trust[J]. Cross Cultural Management, 2015,22(3):464-486
[30] Jehn K. A. A Qualitative Analysis of Conflict Types and Dimensions in Organizational Groups[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1997,42(3):530-557
[31] Hogg M. A., Turner J. C. Interpersonal Attraction, Social Identification and Psychological Group Formation[J]. European Journal of Social Psychology, 1985,15(1):51-66
[32] Van Knippenberg D., De Dreu C. K. W., Homan A. C. Work Group Diversity and Group Performance:An Integrative Model and Research Agenda[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2004,89(6):1008-1022
[33] 屈晓倩,刘新梅. 信息型团队断裂影响团队创造力的作用机理研究[J]. 管理科学, 2016,29(2):18-28
[34] 屈晓倩,刘新梅. 信息型团队断裂与团队创造力关系的实证研究——交互记忆系统的中介作用[J]. 研究与发展管理, 2016,28(1):52-61
[35] Meyer B., Schermuly C. C. When Beliefs Are Not Enough:Examining the Interaction of Diversity Faultlines, Task Motivation, and Diversity Beliefs on Team Performance[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2012,21(3):456-487
[36] 陈伟,杨早立,朗益夫. 团队断裂带对团队效能影响的实证研究——关系型领导行为的调节与交互记忆系统的中介[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(4):99-110
[37] Gruenfeld D. H., Williams K. Y., Mannix E. A., et al. Group Composition and Decision Making:How Member Familiarity and Information Distribution Affect Process and Performance[J]. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes, 1996,67(1):1-15
[38] Bell S. T. Deep-Level Composition Variables as Predictors of Team Performance:A Meta-Analysis[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2007,92(3):595-615
[39] Choi J. N., Sy T. Group Level Organizational Citizenship Behavior:Effects of Demographic Faultlines and Conflict in Small Work Groups[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2010,31(7):1032-1054
[40] 王黎萤,陈劲. 国内外团队创造力研究述评[J]. 研究与发展管理, 2010,22(4):62-68
[41] Tjosvold D., Poon M. Dealing with Scarce Resources Open-Minded Interaction for Resolving Budget Conflicts[J]. Group & Organization Management, 1998,23(3):237-255
[42] Barkema H. G., Shvyrkov O. Does Top Management Team Diversity Promote or Hamper Foreign Expansion?[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2007,28(7):663-680
[43] 杨陈,唐明凤. 团队断裂带对团队创新绩效的作用机理研究[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2017,38(3):172-180
[44] Ellis A. P. J., Michael M. K., Jessica Siegel C. Examing the Asymmetrical Effects of Goal Faultlines in Groups:A Categorization-Elaboration Approach[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2013,98(6):948-961
[45] Lau D. C., Murnighan J. K. Interactions within Groups and Subgroups:The Effects of Demographic Faultlines[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2005,48(4):645-659
[46] Grant R. M. Toward a Knowledge-based Theory of the Firm[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1996,17(S2):109-122
[47] Hambrick D. C., Mason P. A. Upper Echelons:The Organization as a Reflection of Its Top Managers[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1984,9(2):193-206
[48] 李辉. 高管团队特征与决策效果研究:行为整合的中介作用[D]. 辽宁大学博士学位论文, 2014
[49] Oakley J. G. Gender-based Barriers to Senior Management Positions:Understanding the Scarcity of Female CEOs[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2000,27(4):321-334
[50] 张美兰,车宏生. 目标设置理论及其新进展[J]. 心理科学进展, 1999,17(2):35-40
[51] 彭正龙,何培旭. 企业战略导向的权变选择及差别绩效效应:探索性/利用性学习的中介作用和产业类型的调节作用[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(5):121-187
[52] 秦凡媚. 高管团队特征对R&D投入与企业价值关系的调节效应研究[D]. 华南理工大学硕士学位论文, 2014
[53] Hunter J. E., Schmidt F. L. Methods of Meta-Analysis[M]. Newbury Park, CA:Sage, 1990
[54] Lipsey M.W., Wilson D. B. Practical Meta-Analysis[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage, 2001
[55] 王丹,牟振云,翟俊霞,等. Stata软件在Meta分析中异质性检验的应用[J]. 中华流行病学杂志, 2008,29(7):726-729
[56] Li J., Hambrick D. C. Factional Groups:A New Vantage on Demographic Faultlines, Conflict, and Disintegration in Work Teams[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2005,48(5):704-813
[57] Tuggle C. S., Schnatterly K., Johnson R. A. Attention Patterns in the Boardroom:How Board Composition and Processes Affect Discussion of Entrepreneurial Issues[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2010,53(3):550-571
[58] Alexander L., Van Knippenberg D. Teams in Pursuit of Radical Innovation:A Goal Orientation Perspective[J]. IEEE Engineering Management Review, 2017,45(1):105-120