“说话算话”的领导让下属更效忠：中国传统“报”文化视角下的领导言行一致与下属忠诚

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

领导言行一致是指领导者言语与行动的吻合程度。现实中，领导言行不一的情况比比皆是，对下属、团队和组织造成了不良影响。本文立足于中国组织情境，从传统“报”文化出发，考察了领导言行一致对下属“私忠”（领导忠诚）和“公忠”（组织忠诚）的影响机制。基于430名企业员工的两时间点调查数据，结果发现：（1）领导言行一致能正向影响下属“公忠”，下属“私忠”中介了二者关系；（2）下属的父权主义导向和上下级情感关系认定均能正向调节领导言行一致对下属“私忠”的影响，且进一步调节领导言行一致通过下属“私忠”对“公忠”的间接影响。本研究在中国情境下拓展了领导言行一致的影响效果、作用机理与边界条件，并丰富了学界对下属忠诚转换机理的认识。

关键词: 领导言行一致, 父权主义导向, 上下级情感关系认定, 领导忠诚, 组织忠诚

Abstract:

Leader's behavioral integrity is defined as the perceived pattern of alignment between a leader's words and deeds. Despite of a large number of studies, there is no any empirical investigation specific to Chinese context. This is surprising in that leader's words and deeds alignment is emphasized and considered an important ethical characteristic in Chinese philosophical culture and management practice. Rooted in Chinese background and adopting Chinese traditional Bao culture as an overarching theoretical framework, the current study aims to explicate the underlying mechanisms of relationship between leader's behavioral integrity and followers' organizational-based and leader-based loyalty. We examine these research questions with 430 employee data collected from a manufacturing firm in Guangdong. Consistent with hypotheses, it is found that:(1) leader's behavioral integrity is positively correlated with followers' loyalty to the organization, wherein followers' loyalty to the leader plays a mediating role in the link; (2) both the followers' paternalism orientation and leader-member affective relational identity moderate the relationship between leader's behavioral integrity and followers' loyalty to the leader, and further moderate the indirect effect of leader's behavioral integrity on follower's loyalty to the organization via loyalty to the leader. Exploring the consequences of leader's behavioral integrity in Chinese background and its influencing mechanism as well as boundary conditions based on Chinese traditional culture, the current study provides insights into the effects of leader's behavioral integrity and would boost Chinese researchers' and practitioners' interest in this topic.

Key words: leader behavioral integrity, paternalism orientation, leader-member affective relational identity, loyalty to leader, loyalty to organization

王震, 许灏颖, 宋萌. “说话算话”的领导让下属更效忠：中国传统“报”文化视角下的领导言行一致与下属忠诚[J]. , 2018, 30(4): 106-119.

Wang Zhen, Xu Haoying, Song Meng. How does Leader's Behavioral Integrity Affect Follower's Loyalty? An Investigation Based on Traditional Chinese “Bao” Culture[J]. , 2018, 30(4): 106-119.

参考文献

[1] Simons T. The High Cost of Lost Trust[J]. Harvard Business Review, 2002,80(9):18-19
[2] Simons T. Behavioral Integrity:The Perceived Alignment between Managers' Words and Deeds as a Research Focus[J]. Organization Science, 2002,13(1):18-35
[3] Andrews M. C., Kacmar K. M., Kacmar C. The Interactive Effects of Behavioral Integrity and Procedural Justice on Employee Job Tension[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2015,126(3):371-379
[4] Kacmar K. M., Tucker R. The Moderating Effect of Supervisor's Behavioral Integrity on the Relationship between Regulatory Focus and Impression Management[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2016,135(1):87-98
[5] Palanski M. E., Yammarino F. J. Impact of Behavioral Integrity on Follower Job Performance:A Three-Way Study Examination[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2011,22(4):765-786
[6] Simons T., Friedman R., Liu L. A., et al. Racial Differences in Sensitivity to Behavioral Integrity:Attitudinal Consequences, In-Group Effects, and "Trickle-Down" among Black and Non-Black Employee[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2007,92(3):650-665
[7] Davis A. L., Rothstein H. R. The Effects of Perceived Behavioral Integrity of Managers on Employee Attitudes:A Meta-Analysis[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2006,67(4):407-419
[8] Martin G. S., Keating M. A., Resick C. J., et al. The Meaning of Leader Integrity:A Comparatively Study across Anglo, Asian, and Germanic Cultures[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2013,24(3):445-461
[9] 姜定宇,郑伯埙,郑纪莹,等. 华人效忠主管的概念分析与量表构建[J]. 中华心理学刊, 2007,49(4):407-432
[10] 皇甫刚,姜定宇,张岗英. 从组织承诺到组织忠诚:华人组织忠诚的概念内涵与结构[J]. 心理科学进展, 2013,21(4):711-720
[11] 郑伯埙,姜定宇. 华人组织中的主管忠诚:主位与客位概念对员工效能的效果[J]. 本土心理学研究, 2000,(14):65-113
[12] 姜定宇,郑伯埙,任金刚,等. 组织忠诚:本土建构与测量[J]. 本土心理学研究, 2003,(19):273-337
[13] 李海东,段锦云,曾恺. 主管忠诚:概念内涵、影响因素与结果[J]. 心理科学进展, 2017,25(1):133-144
[14] Aycan Z. Paternalism:Towards Conceptual Refinement and Operationalization[C]//Yang K. S., Hwang K. K., Kim U. (Eds), Scientific Advances in Indigenous Psychologies:Empirical, Philosophical, and Cultural Contributions, London:Sage, 2006
[15] 蔡松纯,郑伯埙,周丽芳,等. 领导者上下关系认定与部属利社会行为:权力距离之调节作用[J]. 中华心理学刊, 2009,51(1):121-138
[16] Hinkin T. R., Schriesheim C. A. Leader Reinforcement, Behavioral Integrity, and Subordinate Outcomes:A Social Exchange Approach[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2015,26(6):991-1004
[17] Kannan-Narasimhan R., Lawrence B. S. Behavioral Integrity:How Leader Referents and Trust Matter to Workplace Outcomes[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2012,111(2):165-178
[18] Leroy H., Palanski M. E., Simons T. Authentic Leadership and Behavioral Integrity as Drivers of Follower Commitment and Performance[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2012,107(3):255-264
[19] Palanski M. E., Kahai S. S., Yammarino F. J. Team Virtues and Performance:An Examination of Transparency, Behavioral Integrity, and Trust[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2011,99(2):201-216
[20] 翟学伟. 报的运作方位[J]. 社会学研究, 2007,(1):83-98
[21] 张志学,鞠冬,马力. 组织行为学研究的现状:意义与建议[J]. 心理学报, 2014,46(2):265-284
[22] 贾良定,尤树洋,刘德鹏,等. 构建中国管理学理论自信之路[J]. 管理世界, 2015,(1):99-117
[23] Palanski M. E., Cullen K. L., Gentry W. A., et al. Virtuous Leadership:Exploring the Effects of Leader Courage and Behavioral Integrity on Leader Performance and Image[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2015,132(2):297-310
[24] 刘云. 领导者行为一致性研究:过去、现在与未来[J]. 心理科学进展, 2016,24(5):773-782
[25] Dineen B. R., Lewicki R. J., Tomlinson E. C. Supervisory Guidance and Behavioral Integrity:Relationships with Employee Citizenship and Deviant Behavior[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2006,91(3):622-635
[26] Fritz J. H., O' Nell N. B., Popp A. M., et al. The Influence of Supervisory Behavioral Integrity on Intent to Comply with Organizational Ethical Standards and Organizational Commitment[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2013,114(2):251-263
[27] Paustian-Underdahl S. C., Halbesleben J. R. B. Examining the Influence of Climate, Supervisor Guidance, and Behavioral Integrity on Work-Family Conflict:A Demands and Resources Approach[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2014,35(4):447-463
[28] Prottas D. J. Perceived Behavioral Integrity:Relationships with Employee Attitudes, Well-Being, and Absenteeism[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2008,81(2):313-322
[29] Prottas D. J. Relationships among Employee Perception of Their Manager's Behavioral Integrity, Moral Distress, and Employee Attitudes and Well-Being[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2013,113(1):51-60
[30] Tomlinson E. C., Lewicki R. J., Ash S. R. Disentangling the Moral Integrity Construct:Values Congruence as a Moderator of the Behavioral Integrity-Citizenship Relationship[J]. Group & Organization Management, 2014,9(6):720-743
[31] Tomlinson E. C., Carnes A. M. When Promises are Broken in A Recruitment Context:The Role of Dissonance Attributions and Constraints in Repairing Behavioral Integrity[J]. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2015,88(2):415-435
[32] Erkutlu H., Chafra J. Impact of Behavioral Integrity on Organizational Identification[J]. Management Research Review, 2016,39(6):672-691
[33] Yang L. The Concept of ‘Pao’ as a Basis for Social Eelations in China[C]//Fairbank J. K.(Ed.). Chinese Thought and Institutions. Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 1957
[34] Blau P. M. Exchange and Power in Social Life[M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons, 1964
[35] 杨国枢. 中国人的社会取向:社会互动的观点[C]//杨国枢,余安邦,(主编). 中国人的心理与行为——理念和方法篇. 台北:桂冠图书公司, 1992
[36] 朱苏丽,龙立荣,贺伟,等. 超越工具性交换:中国企业员工-组织类亲情交换关系的理论建构与实证研究[J]. 管理世界, 2015,(11):119-134
[37] Farh J. L., Hackett R. D., Liang J. Individual-Level Cultural Values as Moderators of Perceived Organizational Support-Employee Outcome Relationships in China:Comparing the Effects of Power Distance and Traditionality[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2007,50(3):715-729
[38] Rockstuhl T., Dulebohn J. H., Ang S., et al. Leader-Member Exchange (LMX) and Culture:A Meta-Analysis of Correlates of LMX across 23 Countries[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2012,97(6):1097-1130
[39] 刘兆明. 报的概念及其在组织研究中上的意义[C]//杨国枢,余安邦(主编). 中国人的心理与行为——理念和方法篇. 台北:桂冠图书公司, 1992
[40] Yeung I. Y. M., Tung R. L. Achieving Business Success in Confucian Societies:The Importance of Guanxi (Connections)[J]. Organization Dynamics, 1996,25(2):54-65
[41] Yum J. The Impact of Confucianism on Interpersonal Relationships and Communication Patterns in East Asia[J]. Communication Monographs, 1988,55(4):374-388
[42] 邹文篪,田青,刘佳. "投桃报李"——互惠理论的组织行为学研究述评[J]. 心理科学进展, 2012,20(11):1879-1888
[43] Huang K. K. Face and Favor:The Chinese Power Game[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1987,92(4):944-974
[44] Dirks K. T., Ferrin D. Trust in Leadership:Meta-Analytic Findings and Implications for Research and Practice[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2002,87(4):611-628
[45] 张祥润,王宗水,时勘,等. 内隐领导原型对领导有效性的影响机制:领导信任的中介效应和上下级沟通频率的调节效应[J]. 管理评论, 2017,29(5):75-86
[46] Sahlins M. Stone Age Economics[M]. New York:Aldine De Gruyter, 1972
[47] 姜定宇. 华人企业主管知觉部属效忠[J]. 中华心理学刊, 2009,51(1):101-120
[48] 刘好贤. 中国人报恩的心理行为浅析[J]. 社会心理科学, 2012,27(3):10-12
[49] Molm L. D. The Structure of Reciprocity[J]. Social Psychology Quarterly, 2010,73(2):119-131
[50] Kinicki A. J., Vecchio R. P. Influence on the Quality of Supervisor-Subordinate Relations:The Role of Time-Pressure, Organizational Commitment, and Locus of Control[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1994,15(1):75-82
[51] Webster. Webster's dictionary[M]. Springfield, MA:Merriam-Webster, 1975
[52] Kim U. M. Significance of Paternalism and Communalism in the Occupational Welfare System of Korean Firms[C]//Kim U., Triandis H. C., Kagitcibasi C., Choi S., Yoon G. (Ed.), Individualism and Collectivism:Theory, Method and Applications. California:Sage, 1994
[53] Pasa S. F., Kabasakal H., Bodur M. Society, Organization, and Leadership in Turkey[J]. Applied Psychology, 2001,50(4):559-589
[54] 郑伯埙,周丽芳,樊景立. 家长式领导:三元模式的建构与测量[J]. 本土心理学研究, 2000,(14):3-64
[55] 姜定宇. 华人部属与主管关系、主管忠诚及其后续结果:一项两阶段研究[D]. 台湾大学心理学研究所博士学位论文, 2005
[56] Aycan Z., Schyns B., Sun J. M., et al. Convergence and Divergence of Paternalistic Leadership:A Cross-Cultural Investigation of Prototypes[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 2013,44(9):962-969
[57] Liang L. H., Lian H., Brown D. J., et al. Why are Abusive Supervisors Abusive? A Dual-System Self-Control Model[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2016,59(4):1385-1406
[58] Pellegrini E. K., Scandura T. A. Leader-Member Exchange (LMX), Paternalism, and Delegation in the Turkish Business Culture:An Empirical Investigation[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 2006,37(2):264-269
[59] Jiang D. Y., Cheng B. S. Affect-and Role-Based Loyalty to Supervisors in Chinese Organization[J]. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 2008,11(3):214-221
[60] Mayer D. M., Ehrhart M. G., Schneider B. Service Attribute Boundary Conditions of the Service Climate-Customer Satisfaction Link[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2009,52(5):1034-1050
[61] McClean E. J., Burris E. R. Detert J. When Does Voice Lead to Exist? It Depends on Leadership[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2013,56(2):525-548
[62] MacKinnon D. P., Fritz M. S., Williams J., et al. Distribution of the Product Confidence Limits for the Indirect Effect:Program PRODCLIN[J]. Behavior Research Methods, 2007,39(3):384-389
[63] Edwards J. R., Lambert L. S. Methods for Integrating Moderation and Mediation:A General Analytical Framework Using Moderated Path Analysis[J]. Psychological Methods, 2007,12(1):1-22
[64] 刘东,张震,汪默. 被调节的中介和被中介的调节:理论构建与模型检验[C]//陈晓萍, 徐淑英, 樊景立(主编). 组织与管理研究的实证方法. 北京:北京大学出版社, 2012
[65] Bagozzi R. P., Yi Y. Assessing Method Variance in Multitrait-Multimethod Matrices:The Case of Self-Reported Affect and Perceptions at Work[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1990,75(5):547-560
[66] 凌文辁,陈龙,王登. CPM领导行为评价量表的建构[J]. 心理学报, 1987,19(2):199-207
[67] Brown M. E., Treviño L. K., Harrison D. A. Ethical Leadership:A Social Learning Perspective for Construct Development and Testing[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2005,97(2):117-134
[68] Greenbaum R. L., Mawritz M. B., Piccolo R. F. When Leaders Fail to "Walk the Talk":Supervisor Undermining and Perceptions of Leader Hypocrisy[J]. Journal of Management, 2015,41(3):929-956
[69] Tsai C-Y., Dionne S. D., Wang A. C., et al. Effects of Relational Schema Congruence on Leader-Member Exchange[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2017,28(2):268-284
[70] 任真,王登峰,陆峥. 文化价值观对领导-部属关系与工作结果、心理健康的调节机制:"关系相处"和"社会交换"视角的比较[J]. 管理评论,2017,29(3):157-167
[71] Lavelle J. J., Rupp D. E., Brockner J. Taking a Multifoci Approach to the Study of Justice, Social Exchange, and Citizenship Behavior:The Target Similarity Model[J]. Journal of Management, 2007,33(6):841-866
[72] 李胜兰,陈小锋,高日光. 仅忠于组织而不忠于主管对组织有益吗?[J]. 当代财经, 2014,(2):79-85
[73] 杜玲毓,孙健敏,尹奎,等. 变革型领导从何而来?变革型领导的形成机理[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2017,(11):87-97
[74] 高日光. 领导正直的前因与结果:一项追踪研究[J]. 心理科学进展, 2015,23(12):2042-2053
[75] 余嘉禾,王碧英. 谦卑型领导为何能提高员工绩效?领导-成员交换和组织自尊的多重中介作用[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2017,(10):52-63
[76] Eisenberger R., Karagonlar G., Stinglhamber F., Neves P., Becker T. E., Gonzalez-Morales M. G., Steiger-Mueller M. Leader-Member Exchange and Affective Organizational Commitment:The Contribution of Supervisor's Organizational Embodiment[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2010,95(6):1085-1103