供应链整合与企业绩效的关系研究——基于Meta分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

采用Meta分析方法，基于2000-2015年间的57个独立研究样本，研究了供应链整合对企业绩效的影响，并进一步探讨了供应链整合各个维度对企业绩效的影响，最后运用Meta二元分析和Meta回归分析探究了潜在调节变量对两者关系的调节作用。研究表明：供应链整合对企业绩效有中等强度的正向影响；内部整合、供应商整合、顾客整合均对企业绩效具有显著正向影响。两者关系还受到企业规模、市场环境、国家文化、取样地区以及绩效测量类型的调节。具体来说，大型企业相对中小型企业实施整合的效果更好；市场环境稳定时的整合要好于市场环境动荡时的整合；集体主义文化更有益于整合的实施；发展中地区相对发达地区整合的绩效更好；供应链整合最直接的作用是促进企业非财务绩效的提升。

关键词: 供应链整合, 企业绩效, Meta分析, 调节变量

Abstract:

Supply chain integration is a key in the supply chain management. The relationship between supply chain integration and firm performance is a critical issue. But the existing researches reach different conclusions about the relationship:strong correlation, weak correlation, no relation, negative correlation and even reverse U-shape. Based on 57 samples, this paper uses Meta-analysis to analyze the relationship between supply chain integration and firm performance through correlation coefficient. Furthermore, this paper uses re-gression analysis to find out the influence of moderate variable. The results show that:supply chain integration has moderate intensity in-fluence on firm performance. And the moderate variable has different impacts on the relationship between supply chain integration and firm performance.

Key words: supply chain integration, Meta-analysis, firm performance, moderate variable

冯长利, 刘洪涛, 梅小敏. 供应链整合与企业绩效的关系研究——基于Meta分析[J]. , 2016, 28(11): 217-227.

Feng Changli, Liu Hongtao, Mei Xiaomin. Exploring the Relationship between Supply Chain Integration and Firm Performance——Based on Meta Analysis[J]. , 2016, 28(11): 217-227.

参考文献

[1] THUN J. H. Angles of Integration:An Empirical Analysis of the Alignment of Internet-Based Information Technology and Global Supply Chain Integration[J]. Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2010,46(2):30-44
[2] Rahiman S. A. The Effect of Supply Chain Integration on Information Sharing:Enhancing the Supply Chain Performance[J]. Inter-national Journal of Management, IT and Engineering, 2013,3(6):269-281
[3] Germain R., Iyer K. N. S. The Interaction of Internal and Downstream Integration and Its Association with Performance[J]. Jour-nal of Business Logistics, 2006,27(2):29-52
[4] Koufteros X. A., Rawski G. E., Rupak R. Organizational Integration for Product Development:The Effects on Glitches, on-Time Execution of Engineering Change Orders, and Market Success[J]. Decision Sciences, 2010,41(1):49-80
[5] Narasimhan R., Swink M., Viswanathan S. On Decisions for Integration Implementation:An Examination of Complementarities be-tween Product-Process Technology Integration and Supply Chain Integration[J]. Decision Sciences, 2010,41(2):355-372
[6] Terjesen S., Patel P. C., Sanders N. R. Managing Differentiation-Integration Duality in Supply Chain Integration[J]. Decision Sciences, 2012,43(2):303-339
[7] Droge C., Vickery S. K., Jacobs M. A. Does Supply Chain Integration Mediate the Relationships between Product/Process Strategy and Service Performance? An Empirical Study[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2012,137(2):250-262
[8] Swink M., Narasimhan R., Wang C. Managing Beyond the Factory Walls:Effects of Four Types of Strategic Integration on Manu-facturing Plant Performance[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2007,25(1):148-164
[9] Danese P., Romano P. Supply Chain Integration and Efficiency Performance:A Study on the Interactions between Customer and Supplier Integration[J]. Supply Chain Management:An International Journal, 2011,16(4):220-230
[10] 赵丽,孙林岩,李刚,等.中国制造企业供应链整合与企业绩效的关系研究[J]. 管理工程学报, 2011,25(3):1-9
[11] Allred C. R., Fawcett S. E., Wallin C., et al. A Dynamic Collaboration Capability as a Source of Competitive Advantage[J]. De-cision Sciences, 2011,42(1):129-161
[12] Devaraj S., Krajewski L., Wei J. C. Impact of Ebusiness Technologies on Operational Performance:The Role of Production Infor-mation Integration in the Supply Chain[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2007,25(6):1199-1216
[13] Paulraj A., Lado A. A., Chen I. J. Inter-Organizational Communication as a Relational Competency:Antecedents and Perform-ance Outcomes in Collaborative Buyer-Supplier Relationships[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2008,26(1):45-64
[14] Zhao X., Huo B., Flynn B. B., et al. The Impact of Power and Relationship Commitment on the Integration between Manufactur-ers and Customers in a Supply Chain[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2008,26(3):368-388
[15] Chen H., Daugherty P. J., Landry T. D. Supply Chain Process Integration:A Theoretical Framework[J]. Journal of Business Lo-gistics, 2009,30(2):27-46
[16] Glaister K. W., Buckley P. J. Measures of Performance in Uk International Alliances[J]. Organization Studies, 1998,19(1):89-118
[17] Mustafa K. M., Irani Z. Analysing Supply Chain Integration through a Systematic Literature Review:A Normative Perspective[J]. Supply Chain Management:An International Journal, 2014,19(5/6):523-557
[18] Power D. Supply Chain Management Integration and Implementation:A Literature Review[J]. Supply Chain Management:An In-ternational Journal, 2005,10(4):252-263
[19] 曾敏刚,吴倩倩.供应链设计、供应链整合、信息共享与供应链绩效的关系研究[J]. 工业工程与管理, 2012,17(4):8-14
[20] Prajogo D., Olhager J. Supply Chain Integration and Performance:The Effects of Long-Term Relationships, Information Technol-ogy and Sharing, and Logistics Integration[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2012,135(1):514-522
[21] Barney J. B. Purchasing, Supply Chain Management and Sustained Competitive Advantage:The Relevance of Resource-Based Theory[J]. Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2012,48(2):3-6
[22] Flynn B. B., Huo B., Zhao X. The Impact of Supply Chain Integration on Performance:A Contingency and Configuration Ap-proach[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2010,28(1):58-71
[23] Zhao X., Huo B., Selen W., et al. The Impact of Internal Integration and Relationship Commitment on External Integration[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2011,29(1):17-32
[24] 许德惠,李刚,孙林岩,等. 环境不确定性, 供应链整合与企业绩效关系的实证研究[J]. 科研管理, 2012,33(12):40-49
[25] Wong C. Y., Boon-Itt S., Wong C. W. Y. The Contingency Effects of Environmental Uncertainty on the Relationship between Supply Chain Integration and Operational Performance[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2011,29(6):604-615
[26] Yu W., Jacobs M. A., Salisbury W. D., et al. The Effects of Supply Chain Integration on Customer Satisfaction and Financial Performance:An Organizational Learning Perspective[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2013,146(1):346-358
[27] Braunscheidel M. J., Suresh N. C. The Organizational Antecedents of a Firm's Supply Chain Agility for Risk Mitigation and Re-sponse[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2009,27(2):119-140
[28] Huo B. The Impact of Supply Chain Integration on Company Performance:An Organizational Capability Perspective[J]. Supply Chain Management, 2012,17(6):596-610
[29] 林枫,徐金发,潘奇.企业创业导向与组织绩效关系的元分析[J]. 科研管理, 2011,32(8):74-83
[30] 郑秋莹,姚唐,范秀成,等.基于meta分析的"顾客满意-顾客忠诚"关系影响因素研究[J]. 管理评论, 2014,26(2):111-120
[31] Pagell M. Understanding the Factors That Enable and Inhibit the Integration of Operations, Purchasing and Logistics[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2004,22(5):459-487
[32] Thakkar J., Kanda A., Deshmukh S. Supply Chain Management in Smes:Development of Constructs and Propositions[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, 2008,20(1):97-131
[33] Palomero S., Chalmeta R. A Guide for Supply Chain Integration in Smes[J]. Production Planning & Control, 2014,25(5):372-400
[34] Iyer K. N., Germain R., Claycomb C. B2b E-Commerce Supply Chain Integration and Performance:A Contingency Fit Perspec-tive on the Role of Environment[J]. Information & Management, 2009,46(6):313-322
[35] Gimenez C., van der Vaart T., Pieter van Donk D. Supply Chain Integration and Performance:The Moderating Effect of Supply Complexity[J]. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 2012,32(5):583-610
[36] 朱镇,赵晶,王飞,等.电子供应链合作中IT使能合作优势的实现:基于关系观的实证研究[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(2):168-177
[37] Hofstede G., Hofstede G. J., Minkov M. Cultures and Organizations[M]. New York, NY:McGraw Hill, 1997
[38] Smith P. B., Dugan S., Peterson A. F., et al. Individualism:Collectivism and the Handling of Disagreement. A 23 Country Study[J]. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 1998,22(3):351-367
[39] Chen D. Q., Preston D. S., Xia W. Enhancing Hospital Supply Chain Performance:A Relational View and Empirical Test[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 2013,31(6):391-408
[40] Graham G., Zailani S., Rajagopal P. Supply Chain Integration and Performance:Us Versus East Asian Companies[J]. Supply Chain Management:An International Journal, 2005,10(5):379-393
[41] 曾敏刚,朱佳.环境不确定性与政府支持对供应链整合的影响[J]. 科研管理, 2014,35(9):79-86
[42] Ralston P. M., Blackhurst J., Cantor D. E., et al. A Structure-Conduct-Performance Perspective of How Strategic Supply Chain Integration Affects Firm Performance[J]. Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2015,51(2):47-64
[43] Liu H., Ke W., Wei K. K., et al. Effects of Supply Chain Integration and Market Orientation on Firm Performance:Evidence from China[J]. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 2013,33(3):322-346
[44] 魏红果,李海.保险营销员胜任特征模型:一个定性元分析[J]. 管理评论, 2015,27(7):146-155
[45] Hoek R. V., Ellinger A. E., Johnson M. Great Divides:Internal Alignment between Logistics and Peer Functions[J]. Interna-tional Journal of Logistics Management, 2008,19(2):110-129
[46] Jayaram J., Xu K. The Relative Influence of External Versus Internal Integration on Plant Performance in China[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2013,146(1):59-69