农村集体经济组织成员身份认定的“困境”与“突围”——基于公共价值管理范式的研究

管理评论 ›› 2024, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (1): 276-288.

• 案例研究 • 上一篇

农村集体经济组织成员身份认定的“困境”与“突围”——基于公共价值管理范式的研究

魏广成¹, 孔祥智², 李欣², 高强³, 许光清⁴

1. 中国农业科学院农业经济与发展研究所, 北京 100081;
2. 中国人民大学农业与农村发展学院, 北京 100872;
3. 南京林业大学经济管理学院, 南京 210037;
4. 中国人民大学环境学院, 北京 100872

收稿日期:2021-06-09 出版日期:2024-01-28 发布日期:2024-03-06
通讯作者: 许光清(通讯作者),中国人民大学环境学院副教授,博士生导师,博士。
作者简介:魏广成,中国农业科学院农业经济与发展研究所助理研究员,博士;孔祥智,中国人民大学农业与农村发展学院教授,博士生导师,博士;李欣,中国人民大学农业与农村发展学院硕士研究生;高强,南京林业大学经济管理学院教授,博士生导师,博士。
基金资助:
清华大学中国农村研究院博士论文奖学金项目（202121）；江苏省社会科学基金重点项目（19GLA001）。

“Dilemma” and “Breakthrough” in the Identification of the Membership of Rural Collective Economic Organizations—Research on the Paradigm of Public Value Management

Wei Guangcheng¹, Kong Xiangzhi², Li Xin², Gao Qiang³, Xu Guangqing⁴

1. Institute of Agriculture Economics and Development, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 100081;
2. School of Agriculture Economics and Rural Development, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872;
3. College of Economics and Management, Nanjing Forestry University, Nanjing 210037;
4. School of Environment & Natural Resources, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872

Received:2021-06-09 Online:2024-01-28 Published:2024-03-06

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 基于公共价值管理范式，本文对访谈与文本资料的内容进行编码分析，采用案例研究方法刻画了两家集体经济组织推进成员身份认定的历程，从制定与调整方案入手，将成员身份认定划分为改革陷入“困境”和迎来“突围”两个阶段，深入探究其突破“困境”、完成成员身份认定的历程，从公共价值管理的视角归纳出集体经济组织成员身份认定的演化机制，从构建主体、构建能力、构建环境、构建条件四个维度探究其实现公共价值构建的过程。研究表明，多方参与是实现公共价值的重要前提，参与主体能力建设是构建公共价值的必要保证，因地制宜的制度设计是构建公共价值的制度保障，顺畅的信息传递机制是构建公共价值的重要基础。

关键词: 集体产权制度改革, 成员身份认定, 公共价值管理

Abstract: Based on the paradigm of public value management, this paper makes coding analysis of interviews and texts, depicts the process of promoting membership identification of two collective economic organizations by using case study method, starts with the formulation and adjustment of the reform plan by the property rights reform group, divides membership identification into two stages:the "stagnation" and the "turnaround" of the reform, and deeply explores how the membership identification breaks through the "predicament" and completes the membership identification. From the perspective of public value management, this paper sums up the evolution mechanism of membership identification of collective economic organizations, and probes into the process of realizing public value construction from four dimensions:building subject, building ability, building environment and building conditions. The research shows that multi-party participation in reform is an important prerequisite for realizing public value, the ability building of participants is a necessary guarantee for building public value, the system design according to local conditions is the system guarantee for building public value, and the smooth information transmission mechanism is an important foundation for building public value.

Key words: collective property rights system reform, membership identification, public value management

魏广成, 孔祥智, 李欣, 高强, 许光清. 农村集体经济组织成员身份认定的“困境”与“突围”——基于公共价值管理范式的研究[J]. 管理评论, 2024, 36(1): 276-288.

Wei Guangcheng, Kong Xiangzhi, Li Xin, Gao Qiang, Xu Guangqing. “Dilemma” and “Breakthrough” in the Identification of the Membership of Rural Collective Economic Organizations—Research on the Paradigm of Public Value Management[J]. Management Review, 2024, 36(1): 276-288.

参考文献

[1] 孔祥智,赵昶. 农村集体产权制度改革的实践探索与政策启示——基于7省13县(区、市)的调研[J]. 中州学刊, 2020,(11):25-32 Kong X. Z., Zhao C. Practical Exploration and Policy Enlightenment of Rural Collective Property Right System Reform-Based on the Investigation of 13 Counties (Autonomous Regions and Municipalities) in 7 Provinces[J]. Academic Journal of Zhongzhou, 2020,(11):25-32
[2] 高强,鞠可心. 农村集体产权制度的改革阻点与破解路径——基于江苏溧阳的案例观察[J]. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2021,21(2):1-10 Gao Q., Ju K. X. Obstacles and Solutions to the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System-Based on the Case Observation of Liyang, Jiangsu Province[J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2021,21(2):1-10
[3] 闵师,王晓兵,项诚,等. 农村集体资产产权制度改革:进程、模式与挑战[J]. 农业经济问题, 2019,(5):19-29 Min S., Wang X. B., Xiang C., et al. Reform of Rural Collective Property Right System:Process, Model and Challenge[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2019,(5):19-29
[4] 宋洪远,高强. 农村集体产权制度改革轨迹及其困境摆脱[J]. 改革, 2015,(2):108-114 Song H. Y., Gao Q. The Reform Track of Rural Collective Property Right System and Its Predicament[J]. Reform, 2015,(2):108-114
[5] 陈美球,廖彩荣,冯广京,等. 农村集体经济组织成员权的实现研究——基于"土地征收视角下农村集体经济组织成员权实现研讨会"的思考[J]. 中国土地科学, 2018,32(1):58-64 Chen M. Q., Liao C. R., Feng G. J., et al. Research on the Realization of the Membership Rights of Rural Collective Economic Organizations-Based on the "Seminar on the Realization of the Membership Rights of Rural Collective Economic Organizations from the Perspective of Land Expropriation"[J]. China Land Science, 2018,32(1):58-64
[6] 夏英,钟桂荔,曲颂,等. 我国农村集体产权制度改革试点:做法、成效及推进对策[J]. 农业经济问题, 2018,(4):36-42 Xia Y., Zhong G. L., Qu S., et al. China's Rural Collective Property Rights System Reform Pilot:Practice, Effect and Promotion Countermeasures[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2018,(4):36-42
[7] 农业部经管司课题组,黄延信. 农村集体产权制度改革若干问题的思考[J]. 农村经营管理, 2015,(1):25-28 Research Group of Economic Management Department of Ministry of Agriculture, Huang Y. X., Reflections on Some Problems of Rural Collective Property Right System Reform[J]. Management and Administration on Rural Cooperative, 2015,(1):25-28
[8] 钟桂荔,夏英. 农村集体资产产权制度改革——以云南大理市8个试点村为例[J]. 西北农林科技大学学报(社会科学版), 2017,17(6):109-117 Zhong G. L., Xia Y. Reform of Property Right System of Rural Collective Assets-Taking 8 Pilot Villages in Dali City, Yunnan Province as Examples[J]. Journal of Northwest A&F University (Social Science Edition), 2017,17(6):109-117
[9] 张红宇. 深化农村集体产权制度改革的方向[N]. 学习时报, 2017-04-19(001) Zhang H. Y. The Direction of Deepening the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System[N]. Study Times, 2017-04-19(001)
[10] 张红宇. 关于农村集体产权制度改革的若干问题[J]. 农村经营管理, 2015,(8):6-10 Zhang H. Y. Some Problems on the Reform of Rural Collective Property Right System[J]. Management and Administration on Rural Cooperative, 2015,(8):6-10
[11] 农村集体产权制度改革和政策问题研究课题组,夏英,袁崇法. 农村集体产权制度改革中的股权设置与管理分析——基于北京、上海、广东的调研[J]. 农业经济问题, 2014,35(8):40-44 Research Group on Rural Collective Property Right System Reform and Policy Issues, Xia Y., Yuan C. F. Analysis of Equity Setting and Management in the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System-Based on the Survey of Beijing, Shanghai and Guangdong[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2014,35(8):40-44
[12] 方志权. 农村集体经济组织产权制度改革若干问题[J]. 中国农村经济, 2014,(7):4-14 Fang Z. Q. Some Problems in the Reform of Property Right System of Rural Collective Economic Organizations[J]. China Rural Economy, 2014,(7):4-14
[13] 黄延信,余葵,师高康,等. 对农村集体产权制度改革若干问题的思考[J]. 农业经济问题, 2014,35(4):8-14 Huang Y. X., Yu K., Shi G. K., et al. Reflections on the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2014,35(4):8-14
[14] 余葵,王刚,高鸣. 稳步推进改革确保农民财产权——关于海南省农村集体产权制度改革情况调研[J]. 农村经营管理, 2019,(12):25-27 Yu K., Wang G., Gao M. Steadily Advancing Reform and Ensuring Farmers' Property Rights-Investigation on the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System in Hainan Province[J]. Management and Administration on Rural Cooperative, 2019,(12):25-27
[15] 李宽,熊万胜. 农村集体资产产权改革何以稳妥进行——以上海松江农村集体资产产权改革为例[J]. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2015,15(2):8-16 Li K., Xiong W. S. How to Carry out the Property Right Reform of Rural Collective Assets Steadily-Taking the Property Right Reform of Rural Collective Assets in Songjiang, Shanghai as an Example[J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2015,15(2):8-16
[16] 马翠萍,郜亮亮. 农村集体经济组织成员资格认定的理论与实践——以全国首批29个农村集体资产股份权能改革试点为例[J]. 中国农村观察, 2019,(3):25-38 Ma C. P., Gao L. L. Theory and Practice of Membership Confirmation of Rural Collective Economic Organizations-Taking the First Batch of 29 Rural Collective Assets Share Rights Reform Pilots in China as an Example[J]. China Rural Survey, 2019,(3):25-38
[17] 张瑞涛,夏英. 我国农村集体资产产权科层分析[J]. 农业经济问题, 2020,(11):8-15 Zhang R. T., Xia Y. Hierarchical Analysis of Property Rights of Rural Collective Assets in China[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2020,(11):8-15
[18] 孔祥智. 产权制度改革与农村集体经济发展——基于"产权清晰+制度激励"理论框架的研究[J]. 经济纵横, 2020,(7):32-41 Kong X. Z. Reform of Property Rights System and Development of Rural Collective Economy-Based on the Theoretical Framework of "Clear Property Rights+Institutional Incentive" [J]. Economic Review, 2020,(7):32-41
[19] 张应良,杨芳. 农村集体产权制度改革的实践例证与理论逻辑[J]. 改革, 2017,(3):119-129 Zhang Y. L., Yang F. Practical Examples and Theoretical Logic of Rural Collective Property Right System Reform[J]. Reform, 2017,(3):119-129
[20] 张应良,徐亚东. 农村"三变"改革与集体经济增长:理论逻辑与实践启示[J]. 农业经济问题, 2019,(5):8-18 Zhang Y. L., Xu Y. D. Rural "Three Changes" Reform and Collective Economic Growth:Theoretical Logic and Practical Enlightenment[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2019,(5):8-18
[21] 梁春梅,李晓楠. 农村集体产权制度改革的减贫机制研究[J]. 理论学刊, 2018,(4):55-61 Liang C. M., Li X. N. Research on Poverty Reduction Mechanism of Rural Collective Property Right System Reform[J]. Academic Journal of Theory, 2018,(4):55-61
[22] 马池春,马华. 农村集体产权制度改革的三重维度与秩序均衡——一个政治经济学的分析框架[J]. 农业经济问题, 2018,(2):4-11 Ma C. C., Ma H. Triple Dimensions and Order Balance of Rural Collective Property Right System Reform-An Analytical Framework of Political Economy[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2018,(2):4-11
[23] 何艳玲. "公共价值管理":一个新的公共行政学范式[J]. 政治学研究, 2009,(6):62-68 He Y. L. "Public Value Management":A New Paradigm of Public Administration[J]. Political Science Research, 2009,(6):62-68
[24] 王学军,马翔. 政府绩效生成路径:新范式下的理论及其解释[J]. 上海行政学院学报, 2015,16(4):24-32 Wang X. J., Ma X. The Path of Government Performance Generation:Theory and Interpretation under the New Paradigm[J]. Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute, 2015,16(4):24-32
[25] 惠建利. 农村集体产权制度改革中的妇女权益保障——基于女性主义经济学的视角[J]. 中国农村观察, 2018,(6):73-88 Hui J. L. The Protection of Women's Rights and Interests in the Reform of Rural Collective Property Rights System-Based on the Perspective of Feminist Economics[J]. China Rural Survey, 2018,(6):73-88
[26] 单菲菲,包国宪. 社会价值建构视角下的村庄治理绩效实现路径——广州市下围村"蝶变"的案例研究[J]. 公共管理学报, 2018,15(4):139-148 Shan F. F., Bao G. X. The Path of Realizing Village Governance Performance from the Perspective of Social Value Construction-A Case Study of "Butterfly Change" in Xiawei Village, Guangzhou[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2018,15(4):139-148
[27] 王学军,王子琦. 政民互动、公共价值与政府绩效改进——基于北上广政务微博的实证分析[J]. 公共管理学报, 2017,14(3):31-43 Wang X. J., Wang Z. Q. Interaction between Government and People, Public Value and Improvement of Government Performance-An Empirical Analysis Based on Weibo, a Government Official in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2017,14(3):31-43
[28] 包国宪,周云飞. 政府绩效评价的价值载体模型构建研究[J]. 公共管理学报, 2013,10(2):101-109 Bao G. X., Zhou Y. F. Research on the Construction of Value Carrier Model of Government Performance Evaluation[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2013,10(2):101-109
[29] 王学军,张弘. 公共价值的研究路径与前沿问题[J]. 公共管理学报, 2013,10(2):126-136 Wang X. J., Zhang H. Research Path and Frontier Issues of Public Value[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2013,10(2):126-136
[30] Moore M. Creating Public Value:Strategic Management in Government[M]. Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press, 1995
[31] 包国宪,王学军. 以公共价值为基础的政府绩效治理——源起、架构与研究问题[J]. 公共管理学报, 2012,9(2):89-97 Bao G. X., Wang X. J. Government Performance Governance Based on Public Value:Origin, Structure and Research Issues[J]. Journal of Public Management, 2012,9(2):89-97
[32] Yang K., Holzer M. The Performance-trust Link:Implications for Performance Measurement[J]. Public Administration Review, 2006,66(1):114-126
[33] Borman W. C., Motowidlo S. M. Expanding The Criterion Domain to Include Elements of Contextual Performance[J]. Psychology Faculty Publications, 1993,11(1):71-98
[34] 林雪霏. 放权社区:基于政策适应性的治理结构创新——以C市集体产权改革的政策过程为例[J]. 中国行政管理, 2020,(5):106-113 Lin X. F. Decentralized Community:Innovation of Governance Structure Based on Policy Adaptability-Taking the Policy Process of Collective Property Right Reform in C City as an Example[J]. China Administration, 2020,(5):106-113
[35] 包国宪, 道格拉斯·摩根. 政府绩效管理学——以公共价值为基础的政府绩效治理理论与方法[M]. 北京:高等教育出版社, 2015 Bao G. X., Douglas M. Government Performance Management Theory and Method of Government Performance Governance Based on Public Value[M]. Beijing:Higher Education Press, 2015
[36] Eisenhardt K. M. Building Theories from Case Study Research[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1989,14(4):532-550
[37] Yin R. K. Case Study Research:Design and Methods[M]. London and Singapore:Sage, 2009
[38] Yan A., Gray B. Bargaining Power, Management Control, and Performance in United States-China Joint Ventures:A Comparative Case Study[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1994,37(6):1478-1517
[39] Lee T. W. Using Qualitative Methods in Organizational Research[M]. Beverly Hills,CA:Sage, 1999
[40] 吴晓波,马如飞,毛茜敏. 基于二次创新动态过程的组织学习模式演进——杭氧1996~2008纵向案例研究[J]. 管理世界, 2009,(2):152-164 Wu X. B., Ma R. F., Mao Q. M. Evolution of Organizational Learning Model Based on the Dynamic Process of Secondary Innovation-A Longitudinal Case Study of Hangyang from 1996 to 2008[J]. Journal of Management World, 2009,(2):152-164
[41] 李飞,陈浩,曹鸿星,等. 中国百货商店如何进行服务创新——基于北京当代商城的案例研究[J]. 管理世界, 2010,(2):114-126 Li F., Chen H., Cao H. X., et al. How to Carry out Service Innovation in China Department Stores-Based on the Case Study of Beijing Contemporary Shopping Mall[J]. Journal of Management World, 2010,(2):114-126
[42] 忻榕,徐淑英,王辉,等. 中国企业管理的前沿研究[M]. 北京:北京大学出版社, 2004 Xin R., Xu S. Y., Wang H., et al. Research on the Frontier of Enterprise Management in China[M]. Beijing:Peking University Press, 2004
[43] 丁关良. 农村社区集体主体问题研究——以农民集体土地所有权为例剖析[J]. 南京农业大学学报(社会科学版), 2008,8(4):1-6 Ding G. L. Study on the Collective Subject of Rural Communities-Taking the Collective Land Ownership of Farmers as an Example[J]. Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University (Social Science Edition), 2008,8(4):1-6
[44] 吴建南,阎波. 地方政府绩效评估体系的路径选择——福建的分析[J]. 中国行政管理, 2008,(2):25-29 Wu J. N., Yan B. Path Selection of Local Government Performance Evaluation System-An Analysis of Fujian[J]. China Administration, 2008,(2):25-29
[45] 徐双敏. 政府绩效的影响因素研究[J]. 行政论坛, 2007,(6):9-12 Xu S. M. Research on Influencing Factors of Government Performance[J]. Administrative Forum, 2007,(6):9-12

农村集体经济组织成员身份认定的“困境”与“突围”——基于公共价值管理范式的研究

“Dilemma” and “Breakthrough” in the Identification of the Membership of Rural Collective Economic Organizations—Research on the Paradigm of Public Value Management

PDF (PC)

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 0

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价