政府战略管理:国外理论发展趋势与中国研究展望

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 政府战略管理日益成为国际关注的重要研究领域。本文选取Web of Science核心合集收录的政府战略管理领域的文献作为分析对象,运用Citespace和Vosviewer软件对国外政府战略管理理论的研究概况、发展脉络、研究热点及发展趋势进行分析。研究结果表明:(1)政府战略管理理论研究成果日益丰硕,受到公共管理学、经济学、计算机科学等领域学者的关注;(2)政府战略管理理论经历了理论萌芽期、理论突破期和理论融合期,近年来的研究热点主要聚焦于政府战略三角模型、政府战略类型、政府战略规划、政府战略绩效管理四个方面;(3)政府战略管理理论发展趋势主要包括以下四个方面:政府战略管理角色转型、政府战略管理组织与机制转型、政府战略管理中的组织伦理研究、政府战略管理方法创新。同时,本文简要回顾国内理论发展近况,并展望未来中国政府战略管理理论的本土化研究。

关键词: 政府战略管理, 战略规划, 公共价值, 文献研究

Abstract: Government strategic management has increasingly become a significant research field of international concerns. This paper selects the government strategic management literature collected by Web of Science as the analysis objects and uses Citespace and Vosviewer software to analyze the research overview, research venation, research hotspots and development trends of foreign government strategic management theories. The research results illustrate that:(1) The research achievements of the government strategic management theories are increasingly abundant, attracting the attention of scholars in the fields of public administration, economics, computer science and others; (2) The government strategic management theories have experienced the theoretical infancy stage, the theoretical breakthrough stage and the theoretical integration stage. In recent years, the research focuses on four aspects:government strategic triangle model, government strategic types, government strategic planning and government strategic performance management; (3) Future theoretical development trend mainly includes the following four aspects:transformation of the role of government strategic management, transformation of the organization and mechanism of government strategic management, organizational ethics in government strategic management and the technique innovation of government strategic management. At the same time, this paper briefly reviews the development of domestic theories, and looks ahead to the future localization research of Chinese government strategic management theory.

Key words: government strategic management, strategic planning, public value, literature research

赵景华, 亓靖. 政府战略管理:国外理论发展趋势与中国研究展望[J]. 管理评论, 2023, 35(8): 301-314.

Zhao Jinghua, Qi Jing. Government Strategic Management:The Development Trends of Foreign Theories and the Prospects of Chinese Studies[J]. Management Review, 2023, 35(8): 301-314.

参考文献

[1] Boyne G. A., Gould-Williams J. S., Law J., et al. Problems of Rational Planning in Public Organizations:An Empirical Assessment of the Conventional Wisdom[J]. Administration & Society, 2004,36(3):328-350
[2] Bryson J. Strategic Planning for Public and Nonprofit Organizations:A Guide to Strengthening and Sustaining Organizational Achievement (3rd Edition)[M]. New Jersey:Wiley, 2004
[3] Berry F. S. Strategic Planning as a Tool for Managing Organizational Change[J]. International Journal of Public Administration, 2007,30(3):331-346
[4] Poister T. H., Streib G. D. Strategic Management in the Public Sector:Concepts, Models, and Processes[J]. Public Productivity & Management Review, 1999,22(3):308-325
[5] Moore M. H. Creating Public Value:Strategic Management in Government[M]. Cambridge:Harvard University Press, 1995
[6] 赵景华,李代民.政府战略管理三角模型评析与创新[J].中国行政管理, 2009,(6):47-49
[7] Moore M. H. Public Value as the Focus of Strategy[J]. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 1994,53(3):296-303
[8] 曹堂哲.西方30年来公共部门战略管理研究的总体特征——主题、学科和方法的定性与定量分析[J].中国行政管理, 2011,(2):116-121
[9] 李杰.科学知识图谱原理及应用——Vosviewer和CitNetExplorer初学者指南[M].北京:高等教育出版社, 2018
[10] East R. J. Comparison of Strategic Planning in Large Corporations and Government[J]. Long Range Planning, 1972,5(2):2-8
[11] Bunning C. R. Effective Strategic Planning in the Public Sector:Some Learnings[J]. International Journal of Public Sector Management, 1992,5(4):54
[12] Poister T. H., Streib G. Elements of Strategic Planning and Management in Municipal Government:Status after Two Decades[J]. Public Administration Review, 2005,65(1):45-56
[13] Chesley J. A., Wenger M. S. Transforming an Organization:Using Models to Foster a Strategic Conversation[J]. California Management Review, 1999,41(3):54-73
[14] Kaplan R. S., Norton D. P. The Balanced Scorecard[M]. Boston:Harvard Business Review Press, 1996
[15] Nutt P. C., Backoff R. W. Strategic Management of Public and Third Sector Organizations:A Handbook for Leaders[M]. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass, 1992
[16] Miles R. E., Snow C. C. Organizational Strategy, Structure and Process[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill, 1978
[17] Boyne G. A., Walker R. M. Strategy Content and Public Service Organizations[J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 2004,14(2):231-252
[18] Poister T. H. The Future of Strategic Planning in the Public Sector:Linking Strategic Management and Performance[J]. Public Administration Review, 2010,70(1):S246-S254
[19] Bryson J. M., Berry F. S., Yang K. The State of Public Strategic Management Research:A Selective Literature Review and Set of Future Directions[J]. The American Review of Public Administration, 2010,40(5):495-521
[20] Stoker G. Public Value Management:A New Narrative for Networked Governance? [J]. The American Review of Public Administration, 2006,36(1):41-57
[21] Bozeman B. Public-Value Failure:When Efficient Markets may Not Do[J]. Public Administration Review, 2002,62(2):145-161
[22] Meynhardt T. A. Public Value Inside:What Is Public Value Creation? [J]. International Journal of Public Administration, 2009,32(3-4):192-219
[23] Benington J., Moore M. H. From Private Choice to Public Value? In Public Value:Theory and Practice[M]. Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan, 2011
[24] Moore M. H. Recognizing Public Value[M]. Cambridge:Harvard University Press, 2013
[25] Meier K. J., O'Toole L. J., Boyne G. A., et al. Strategic Management and the Performance of Public Organizations:Testing Venerable Ideas against Recent Theories[J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 2007,17(3):357-377
[26] Wolf C., Floyd S. W. Strategic Planning Research:Toward a Theory-Driven Agenda[J]. Journal of Management, 2017,43(6):1754-1788
[27] George B., Walker R., Monster J. Does Strategic Planning Improve Organizational Performance? A Meta-Analysis[J]. Public Administration Review, 2019,79(6):810-819
[28] Bryson J. M., Crosby B. C., Bloomberg L. Public Value Governance:Moving Beyond Traditional Public Administration and the New Public Management[J]. Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):445-456
[29] Felício T., Samagaio A., Rodrigues R. Adoption of Management Control Systems and Performance in Public Sector Organizations[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2020,124:593-602
[30] Hoglund L., Martensson M., Thomson K. Strategic Management, Management Control Practices and Public Value Creation:The Strategic Triangle in the Swedish Public Sector[J]. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 2021,34(7):1608-1634
[31] Makasi T., Tate M., Desouza K. C. Value-Based Guiding Principles for Managing Cognitive Computing Systems in the Public Sector[J]. Public Performance & Management Review, 2021,44(4):929-959
[32] Walker R. M. Strategic Management and Performance in Public Organizations:Findings from the Miles and Snow Framework[J]. Public Administration Review, 2013,73(5):675-685
[33] Kim N. Y., Berry F. S. Strategic Stances and Programme Performance:Assessing Outcomes of the US States' Delivery of the Child Support Enforcement Programme[J]. Public Management, 2018,20(24):545-562
[34] Johnsen A. Impacts of Strategic Planning and Management in Municipal Government:An Analysis of Subjective Survey and Objective Production and Efficiency Measures in Norway[J]. Public Management Review, 2018,20(3):397-420
[35] Bryson J., Sancino A., Benington J., et al. Towards a Multi-Actor Theory of Public Value Co-creation[J]. Public Management Review, 2017,19(5):640-654
[36] Geuijen K., Moore M. H., Cederquist A., et al. Creating Public Value in Global Wicked Problems[J]. Public Management Review, 2016,19(5):1-19
[37] Hartley J., Alford J., Hughes O., et al. Public Value and Political Astuteness in the Work of Public Managers:The Art of the Possible[J]. Public Administration, 2015,93(1):195-211
[38] Jacobsen D. I., Johnsen A. Alignment of Strategy and Structure in Local Government[J]. Public Money & Management, 2020,40(4):276-284
[39] Porter M. E. Competitive Strategy[M]. New York:Free Press, 1980
[40] Bryson J. M. The Future of Public and Nonprofit Strategic Planning in the United States[J]. Public Administration Review, 2010,70(S1):255-267
[41] Johanson J. E., Johnsen A. Strategic Management in Finnish and Norwegian Government Agencies[J]. Administrative Sciences, 2019,9(4):1-20
[42] Meyfroodt K., Desmidt S., Goeminne S. Is the Governing Coalition a Strategic Coalition? Analysing the Relationship between Political Group Characteristics, Strategic Plan Quality and Strategic Consensus[C]. European Group for Public Administration Conference, 2017
[43] Desmidt S., Meyfroodt K. Debate:Unravelling Strategic Planning Effectiveness——What about Strategic Consensus? [J]. Public Money & Management, 2018,38(4):255-256
[44] Desmidt S., Meyfroodt K. What Motivates Politicians to Use Strategic Plans as a Decision-Making Tool? Insights from the Theory of Planned Behaviour[J]. Public Management Review, 2021,23(3):447-474
[45] Ajzen I. The Theory of Planned Behavior[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision, 1991,50(2):179-211
[46] George B., Desmidt S., Moyer J. D. Strategic Decision Quality in Flemish Municipalities[J]. Public Money & Management, 2016,36(5):317-324
[47] Moore M. H. Public Value Accounting:Establishing the Philosophical Basis[J]. Public Administration Review, 2014,74(4):465-477
[48] Grant B. J. The Particular Applicability of Public Value Creation to Local Government[J]. International Journal of Public Administration, 2021,44(10):835-844
[49] Moore M. H. Recognising Public Value:The Challenge of Measuring Performance in Government[M]. Canberra:ANU E Press, 2007
[50] Rubin E. V. Recognizing Public Value[J]. American Review of Public Administration, 2015,45(6):760-762
[51] Mcgregor E. B. Recognizing Public Value[J]. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2014,33(3):854-860
[52] Faulkner N., Kaufman S. Avoiding Theoretical Stagnation:A Systematic Review and Framework for Measuring Public Value[J]. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 2018,77(1):69-86
[53] Shepherd D. Defining Public-Sector Entrepreneurship:A Conceptual Operational Construct[J]. The International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 2017,18(3):153-163
[54] Klijn E. H., Koppenjan J. Debate:Strategic Planning after the Governance Revolution[J]. Public Money & Management, 2020,40(4):260-261
[55] Agarwal R., Helfat C. E. Strategic Renewal of Organizations[J]. Organization Science, 2009,20(2):281-293
[56] Lane J. E., Wallis J. Strategic Management and Public Leadership[J]. Public Management Review, 2009,11(1):101-120
[57] Kools M., George B. Debate:The Learning Organization-A Key Construct Linking Strategic Planning and Strategic Management[J]. Public Money & Management, 2020,40(4):262-264
[58] Meijer A., Boon W. Digital Platforms for the Co-creation of Public Value[J]. Policy and Politics, 2021,49(2):231-248
[59] O'Reilly T. Government as a Platform[J]. Innovations:Technology, Governance, Globalization, 2011,6(1):13-40
[60] Cordella A., Paletti A. Government as a Platform, Orchestration, and Public Value Creation:The Italian Case[J]. Government Information Quarterly, 2019,36(4):1-15
[61] Palmi P., Corallo A., Prete M. I., et al. Balancing Exploration and Exploitation in Public Management:Proposal for an Organizational Model[J]. Journal of Public Affairs, 2020,21(1):1-12
[62] Keene J., Nalbandian J., O'Neill J., et al. How Professionals can Add Value to Their Communities and Organizations[J]. Public Management, 2007,89(2):32-39
[63] Dwivedi Y. K., Hughes L., Ismagilova E., et al. Artificial Intelligence (AI):Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Emerging Challenges, Opportunities, and Agenda for Research, Practice and Policy[J]. International Journal of Information Management, 2019,57(7):1-47
[64] Zakeri S., Yang Y., Hashemi M. Grey Strategies Interaction Model[J]. Journal of Strategy and Management, 2019,12(1):30-60
[65] Paucar-Caceres A., dos Santos P. R., Wright G., et al. Soft Situational Strategic Planning (SSSP):A Method and Case Study of Its Application in a Brazilian Municipality[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2019,71(3):1-18
[66] Tsotsolas N., Alexopoulos S. Towards a Holistic Strategic Framework for Applying Robust Facilitated Approaches in Political Decision Making[J]. Operational Research, 2019,19(2):501-541
[67] Bryson J. M., Ackermann F., Eden C. Discovering Collaborative Advantage:The Contributions of Goal Categories and Visual Strategy Mapping[J]. Public Administration Review, 2016,76(6):912-925
[68] 何立峰.党领导发展改革工作的重大成就和宝贵经验[N].学习时报, 2021-12-10(001)
[69] 胡鞍钢,鄢一龙.中国大战略:统筹两个大局与天时地利人和[J].国家行政学院学报, 2013,(2):11-15
[70] 陈振明.公共管理需要新的战略思维——评《公共和第三部门组织的战略管理》[J].中国人民大学学报, 2001,15(6):118-120
[71] 汪大海.试论公共部门战略管理的十大误区[J].中国行政管理, 2004,(6):19-23
[72] 倪星,杨芳.试论新时期中国公共部门战略管理能力的提升[J].武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2006,59(1):96-101
[73] 周省时.政府战略绩效管理与战略规划关系探讨及对领导干部考核的启示[J].管理世界, 2013,(1):176-177
[74] 李宇环.地方政府战略管理能力评价模型与指标体系[J].中国行政管理, 2015,(2):72-77
[75] 王林川,寿志勤,吴慈生.政府数据开放平台服务绩效评价指标体系研究:基于公共价值视角[J].中国行政管理, 2022,(1):40-47
[76] 赵景华,李宇环.公共战略学的学科构建与发展趋势[J].中国行政管理, 2010,(8):112-116
[77] 赵景华,李宇环.公共战略管理的价值取向与分析模式[J].中国行政管理, 2011,(12):32-37
[78] 赵景华,马忻,李宇环.公共战略学的战略拐点理论[J].中国行政管理, 2014,(1):65-70
[79] 赵景华,邢华.政府战略管理的SWOT模型:一个概念框架[J].中国行政管理, 2010,(5):23-27
[80] 包国宪,文宏,王学军.基于公共价值的政府绩效管理学科体系构建[J].中国行政管理, 2012,(5):98-104
[81] 包国宪,王学军.以公共价值为基础的政府绩效治理——源起、架构与研究问题[J].公共管理学报, 2012,9(2):89-97
[82] 包国宪,保海旭.以公共价值为基础的政府战略管理[J].兰州大学学报(社会科学版), 2015,43(4):24-30