领导拒谏如何影响下属？基于情感事件理论视角

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 上级对下属建言的消极反应（即领导拒谏）是否及如何影响下属的工作结果这一问题长久以来被学者们所忽视。本研究基于情感事件理论，考察了员工工作挫折感在领导拒谏与员工工作结果（工作满意度、建言行为和反生产行为）之间关系的中介作用以及员工情绪调节自我效能感对其关系的调节作用。通过对235位员工的调查研究，结果显示：（1）领导拒谏与员工工作满意度和建言行为负相关，与反生产行为正相关；（2）员工的工作挫折感部分中介了领导拒谏与员工工作结果之间的关系；（3）员工的情绪调节自我效能感调节了领导拒谏对员工工作挫折感的影响，即员工的情绪调节自我效能感越高，领导拒谏与员工工作挫折感的正向关系越弱，反之越强；（4）员工的情绪调节自我效能感调节了员工工作挫折感在领导拒谏与员工工作结果关系间的中介效应，即员工情绪调节自我效能感越高，该中介效应越弱。最后讨论了该研究的意义和不足以及未来的研究方向。

关键词: 领导拒谏, 工作挫折感, 情绪调节自我效能感, 情感事件理论

Abstract: Whether and how the leaders' negative response to employees' voice (e.g. voice non-endorsement) influences employee work outcomes has long been ignored by researchers. Based on affective events theory, this study investigates the mediating role of employee work frustration and the moderating role of employee self-efficacy for emotional regulation in the relationships between voice non-endorsement and employee work outcomes (e.g. job satisfaction, voice behavior and counterproductive behavior). Results indicate that:(1) voice non-endorsement is negatively related to employee job satisfaction and voice behavior, and positively related to counterproductive behavior; (2) work frustration partially mediates these relationships; (3) emotional regulation self-efficacy has a moderating effect on the relationships between voice non-endorsement and work frustration, such that positive association is weaker for employees who have high emotional regulation self-efficacy; and (4) emotional regulation self-efficacy moderates the mediating effect of work frustration. Finally, we discuss the implications, limitations and future research directions of this study.

Key words: voice non-endorsement, work frustration, self-efficacy for emotional regulation, affective events theory

吴松, 翁清雄, 张越. 领导拒谏如何影响下属？基于情感事件理论视角[J]. 管理评论, 2023, 35(2): 216-227.

Wu Song, Weng Qingxiong, Zhang Yue. Voice Non-endorsement and Employee Work Outcomes from the Perspective of Affective Events Theory[J]. Management Review, 2023, 35(2): 216-227.

参考文献

[1] Grant A. M. Rocking the Boat but Keeping It Steady:The Role of Emotion Regulation in Employee Voice[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2013,56(6):1703-1723
[2] Tangirala S., Ramanujam R. Exploring Nonlinearity in Employee Voice:The Effects of Personal Control and Organizational Identification[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2008,51(6):1189-1203
[3] Liang J., Farh C. I. C., Farh J. L. Psychological Antecedents of Promotive and Prohibitive Voice:A Two-Wave Examination[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2012,55(1):71-92
[4] 李方君,陈晨. 员工建言发生和领导者建言采纳:权力感的视角[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2020,37(7):119-134
[5] 易洋,朱蕾. 下属建言与领导纳言——基于ELM理论一个被中介的调节模型[J]. 南方经济, 2015,33(7):93-107
[6] 周浩. 管理者权力对采纳建言的影响:管理者自我效能与权力距离的作用[J]. 四川大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2016,(3):123-131
[7] Garner J. T. Open Doors and Iron Cages:Supervisors' Responses to Employee Dissent[J]. International Journal of Business Communication, 2016,53(1):27-54
[8] Piezunka H., Dahlander L. Idea Rejected, Tie Formed:Organizations' Feedback on Crowdsourced Ideas[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2019,62(2):503-530
[9] Milliken F. J., Morrison E. W., Hewlin P. F. An Exploratory Study of Employee Silence:Issues That Employees don't Communicate Upward and Why[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2003,40(6):1453-1476
[10] Howell T. M., Harrison D. A., Burris E. R., et al. Who Gets Credit for Input? Demographic and Structural Status Cues in Voice Recognition[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2015,100(6):1765-1784
[11] Fast N. J., Burris E. R., Bartel C. A. Managing to Stay in the Dark:Managerial Self-efficacy, Ego Defensiveness, and the Aversion to Employee Voice[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2014,57(4):1013-1034
[12] Li J., Barnes C. M., Yam K. C., et al. Do Not Like It When You Need It the Most:Examining the Effect of Manager Ego Depletion on Managerial Voice Endorsement[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2019,40(8):869-882
[13] 魏昕,张志学. 上级何时采纳促进性或抑制性进言?——上级地位和下属专业度的影响[J]. 管理世界, 2014,(1):132-143
[14] Burris E. R. The Risks and Rewards of Speaking Up:Managerial Responses to Employee Voice[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2012,55(4):851-875
[15] Whiting S. W., Maynes T. D., Podsakoff N. P., et al. Effects of Message, Source, and Context on Evaluations of Employee Voice Behavior[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2012,97(1):159-182
[16] 孙露莹,陈琳,段锦云. 决策过程中的建议采纳:策略、影响及未来展望[J]. 心理科学进展, 2017,25(1):169-179
[17] 韩翼,肖素芳. 领导为什么拒谏:基于动机社会认知视角的阐释[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2020, 42(8):68-80
[18] Bernichon T., Cook K. E., Brown J. D. Seeking Self-evaluative Feedback:The Interactive Role of Global Self-esteem and Specific Self-views[J]. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 2003,84(1):194-204
[19] Senko C., Harackiewicz J. M. Performance Goals:The Moderating Roles of Context and Achievement Orientation[J]. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2002,38(6):603-610
[20] Shea C. M., Howell J. M. Efficacy-Performance Spirals:An Empirical Test[J]. Journal of Management, 2000,26(4):791-812
[21] Ilies R., Judge T. A. Goal Regulation across Time:The Effects of Feedback and Affect[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2005,90(3):453-467
[22] 张璇,龙立荣,夏冉. 心理契约破裂与破坏性建言行为:自我损耗的视角[J]. 管理科学, 2017,30(3):3-13
[23] 韩翼,刘庚. 为何言路难开?领导拒谏构念维度与形成机理探究[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2021,38(4):111-124
[24] He W., Han Y., Hu X., et al. From Idea Endorsement to Idea Implementation:A Multilevel Social Network Approach Toward Managerial Voice Implementation[J]. Human Relations, 2019,73(1):1563-1582
[25] Morrison E. W., Milliken F. J. Organizational Silence:A Barrier to Change and Development in a Pluralistic World[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2000,25(4):706-725
[26] Detert J. R., Burris E. R. Leadership Behavior and Employee Voice:Is the Door Really Open?[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2007,50(4):869-884
[27] Dasborough M. T. Cognitive Asymmetry in Employee Emotional Reactions to Leadership Behaviors[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2006,17(2):163-178
[28] Dasborough M. T., Ashkanasy N. M., Tee E. Y. J., et al. What Goes around Comes around:How Meso-level Negative Emotional Contagion can Ultimately Determine Organizational Attitudes Toward Leaders[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2009,20(4):571-585
[29] 王桢,陈乐妮. 领导者情感的作用机制:一个跨层的整合观点[J]. 心理科学进展, 2014,22(1):122-129
[30] Mignonac K., Herrbach O. Linking Work Events, Affective States, and Attitudes:An Empirical Study of Managers' Emotions[J]. Journal of Business & Psychology, 2004,19(2):221-240
[31] Fox S., Spector P. E. A Model of Work Frustration-Aggression[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1999,20(6):915-931
[32] Diefendorff J. M., Richard E. M., Yang J. Linking Emotion Regulation Strategies to Affective Events and Negative Emotions at Work[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2008,73(3):498-508
[33] Ilies R., Scott B. A., Judge T. A. The Interactive Effects of Personal Traits and Experienced States on Intraindividual Patterns of Citizenship Behavior[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2006,49(3):561-575
[34] Bandura A., Caprara G. V., Barbaranelli C., et al. Role of Affective Self-Regulatory Efficacy in Diverse Spheres of Psychosocial Functioning[J]. Child Development, 2003,74(3):769-782
[35] 朱玥,王永跃. 服务型领导对员工工作结果的影响:亲社会动机的中介效应和互动公平的调节效应[J]. 心理科学, 2014,37(4):968-972
[36] 章凯,时金京,罗文豪. 建言采纳如何促进员工建言:基于目标自组织视角的整合机制[J]. 心理学报, 2020,52(2):121-131
[37] Zhang Y., Lepine J. A., Buckman B. R., et al. It's Not Fair … or Is It? The Role of Justice and Leadership in Explaining Work Stressor-Job Performance Relationships[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2015,57(3):675-697
[38] Reio Jr. T. G. Supervisor and Coworker Incivility:Testing the Work Frustration-Aggression Model[J]. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 2011,13(1):54-68
[39] Fitness J. Anger in the Workplace:An Emotion Script Approach to Anger Episodes between Workers and Their Superiors, Co-workers and Subordinates[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2000,21(2):147-162
[40] Klaas B. S., Olson-Buchanan J. B., Ward A. K. The Determinants of Alternative Forms of Workplace Voice:An Integrative Perspective[J]. Journal of Management, 2012,38(1):314-345
[41] Morgeson F. P., Aguinis H., Ashford S. J. Employee Voice and Silence[J]. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 2014,1(1):173-197
[42] Mccoll-Kennedy J. R., Anderson R. D. Impact of Leadership Style and Emotions on Subordinate Performance[J]. Leadership Quarterly, 2002,13(5):545-559
[43] Chang Y. P., Lee D. C., Wang H. H. Violence-revention Climate in the Turnover Intention of Nurses Experiencing Workplace Violence and Work Frustration[J]. Journal of Nursing Management, 2018,26(8):961-971
[44] 段锦云,傅强,田晓明,等. 情感事件理论的内容、应用及研究展望[J]. 心理科学进展, 2011,19(4):599-607
[45] Rusting C. L., DeHart T. Retrieving Positive Memories to Regulate Negative Mood:Consequences for Mood-Congruent Memory[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000,78(4):737-752
[46] 李育辉,王桢,黄灿炜,等. 辱虐管理对员工心理痛苦和工作绩效的影响:一个被调节的中介模型[J]. 管理评论, 2016,28(2):127-137
[47] Dunnette M. D., Hough L. M. Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology[C]. Rand-McNally, Chicago:Consulting Psychologists Press, 1976
[48] Barker R. G., Dembo T., Lewin K. Frustration and Regression. In:R. G. Barker et al. (Eds) Child Behavior and Development[M]. New York:McGrawHill, 1943
[49] Tang Y. Y., Posner M. I. Attention Training and Attention State Training[J]. Trends in Cognitiveences, 2009,13(5):222-227
[50] Dollard J., Doob L. W., Miller N. E., et al. Frustration and Aggression[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1939,92(7):1654-1667
[51] Spector P. E. Relationships of Organizational Frustration with Reported Behavioral Reactions of Employees[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1975,60(5):635-637
[52] Chen Y., Ferris D. L., Kwan M., et al. Self-love's Lost Labor:A Self-enhancement Model of Workplace Incivility[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2013,56(4):1199-1219
[53] 樊耘,阎亮,马贵梅. 权力需要、组织承诺与角色外行为的关系研究——基于组织文化的调节效应[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2013,34(1):135-146
[54] 李锐,凌文辁,柳士顺. 上司不当督导对下属建言行为的影响及其作用机制[J]. 心理学报, 2009,41(12):1189-1202
[55] Carnahan S., Kryscynski D., Olson D. When does Corporate Social Responsibility Reduce Employee Turnover? Evidence from Attorneys Before and After 9/11[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2017,60(5):1932-1962
[56] Yildiz M., Ehtiyar R. Organizational Silence:A Survey on Employees Working in a Chain Hotel[J]. Tourism & Hospitality Management, 2008,14(1):51-68
[57] Dyne L. V., Ang S., Botero I. C. Conceptualizing Employee Silence and Employee Voice as Multidimensional Constructs[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2003,40(6):1359-1392
[58] Bandura. A Social Foundation of Thought and Action:A Social Action Cognitive Theory[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1986,56(1):11-18
[59] Erben G. S., Güneşer A. B. The Relationship between Paternalistic Leadership and Organizational Commitment:Investigating the Role of Climate Regarding Ethics[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2008,82(4):955-968
[60] 马吟秋,席猛,许勤,等. 基于社会认知理论的辱虐管理对下属反生产行为作用机制研究[J]. 管理学报, 2017,14(8):1153-1161
[61] 凌文辁,杨海军,方俐洛. 企业员工的组织支持感[J]. 心理学报, 2006,38(2):281-287
[62] George J. M. Emotions and Leadership:The Role of Emotional Intelligence[J]. Human Relations, 2000,53(8):1027-1055
[63] Riggio R. E., Reichard R. J. The Emotional and Social Intelligences of Effective Leadership:An Emotional and Social Skill Approach[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2008,23(2):169-185
[64] Ashkanasy N. M., Härtel C. E., Daus C. S. Diversity and Emotion:The New Frontiers in Organizational Behavior[J]. Journal of Management, 2002,28(3):307-338
[65] Barsade S. G., Gibson D. E. Why does Affect Matter in Organizations?[J]. Academy of Management Perspectives, 2007,21(1):36-59
[66] Elfenbein H. A. 7Emotion in Organizations:A Review and Theoretical Integration[J]. Ssrn Electronic Journal, 2007,1(1):371-457
[67] Wang M., Liao H., Zhan Y., et al. Daily Customer Mistreatment and Employee Sabotage Against Customers:Examining Emotion and Resource Perspectives[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2011,54(2):312-334
[68] Weiss H. M., Cropanzano R. Affective Events Theory:A Theoretical Discussion of the Structure, Causes and Consequences of Affective Experiences at Work[J]. Research in Organizational Behavior, 1996,18(3):1-74
[69] 汤冬玲,董妍,俞国良,等. 情绪调节自我效能感:一个新的研究主题[J]. 心理科学进展, 2010,18(4):598-604
[70] Harold C. M., Oh I. S., Holtz B. C., et al. Fit and Frustration as Drivers of Targeted Counterproductive Work Behaviors:A Multifoci Perspective[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2016,101(11):1513-1535
[71] Peters L. H., O'Connor E. J., Rudolf C. J. The Behavioral and Affective Consequences of Performance-Relevant Situational Variables[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1980,25(1):79-96
[72] Tsui A. S., Egan T. D., O'Reilly III C. A. Being Different:Relational Demography and Organizational Attachment[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1992,37(4):549-579
[73] Lepine J. A., Van Dyne L. Predicting Voice Behavior in Work Groups[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1998,83(6):853-868
[74] Aquino K., Bradfield L. M. Justice Constructs, Negative Affectivity, and Employee Deviance:A Proposed Model and Empirical Test[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1999,20(7):1073-1091
[75] 舒睿,梁建. 基于自我概念的伦理领导与员工工作结果研究[J]. 管理学报, 2015,12(7):1012-1020
[76] 郭文臣,杨静,付佳,等. 以组织犬儒主义为中介的组织支持感、组织公平感对反生产行为影响的研究[J]. 管理学报, 2015,12(4):530-537
[77] Podsakoff P. M., Mackenzie S. B., Lee J. Y., et al. Common Method Biases in Behavioral Research:A Critical Review of the Literature and Recommended Remedies[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2003,88(5):879-903
[78] Preacher K. J., Hayes A. F. Asymptotic and Resampling Strategies for Assessing and Comparing Indirect Effects in Simple and Multiple Mediator Models[J]. Behavior Research Methods, 2008,40(3):879-891
[79] Preacher K. J., Rucker D. D., Hayes A. F. Addressing Moderated Mediation Hypotheses:Theory, Methods, and Prescriptions[J]. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 2007,42(1):185-227
[80] Spector P. E., Fox S. Counterproductive Work Behavior and Organisational Citizenship Behavior:Are They Opposite Forms of Active Behavior?[J]. Applied Psychology, 2010,59(1):21-39
[81] Payne R. B., Hauty G. T. Effect of Psychological Feedback Upon Work Decrement[J]. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1955,50(6):343-351
[82] Grant A. M., Mayer D. M. Good Soldiers and Good Actors:Prosocial and Impression Management Motives as Interactive Predictors of Affiliative Citizenship Behaviors[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2009,94(4):900-912
[83] Leung K., Su S., Morris M. W. When Is Criticism Not Constructive? The Roles of Fairness Perceptions and Dispositional Attributions in Employee Acceptance of Critical Supervisory Feedback[J]. Human Relations, 2001,54(9):1155-1187
[84] Steelman L. A., Rutkowski K. A. Moderators of Employee Reactions to Negative Feedback[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2004,19(1/2):6-18