组织即兴和资源拼凑的内涵及关系研究述评

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 利用手边即时可得的资源实时计划和执行，即兴做出决策，是创业企业应对环境不确定性、克服资源短缺困境的常见选择。组织即兴往往伴随着资源的拼凑，而资源的拼凑过程又容易引发组织即兴。近年来组织即兴和资源拼凑在企业管理研究中迅速兴起，但内容相对碎片化，特别是两者的内涵与关系相对模糊，在一定程度上阻碍了相关研究的进一步拓展。本文对组织即兴、资源拼凑的概念要素进行了系统提炼，并提出更为全面的组织即兴与资源拼凑概念；同时分析了组织即兴与资源拼凑之间的关系，发现即兴和拼凑内涵交叉，且存在多重互动关系，两者在企业的发展过程中相互引致、有涨有消。在相对不确定和多变的经济环境中，企业可将组织即兴和资源拼凑作为打造核心竞争力的重要途径。

关键词: 组织即兴, 资源拼凑, 多重互动

Abstract: Using currently available resources to execute a plan in real time, also known as improvisation, is an efficient way for entrepreneurship to deal with environmental uncertainty and resource scarcity. Organizational improvisation is often accompanied by bricolage, and the process of bricolage can easily lead to organizational improvisation. Although improvisation and bricolage research has gained momentum in the past decade, the literature is diverse and fragmented especially in terms of their connotation and relationship, thus hindering the development of improvisation and bricolage as a promising research area. Based on the research progress and development trend, this paper summarizes the definition elements of improvisation and bricolage, and presents an integrative definition of them. This paper also finds the symbiotic relationship between improvisation and bricolage, with overlapping connotations and multiple interactive relations, and they cause each other and change with each other in the process of enterprise development. Enterprises can take improvisation and bricolage as an important way to build core competitiveness in the rapidly changing environment of risks and uncertainty.

Key words: organizational improvisation, bricolage, multiple interaction

刘海龙, 许文. 组织即兴和资源拼凑的内涵及关系研究述评[J]. 管理评论, 2022, 34(7): 115-128.

Liu Hailong, Xu Wen. The Connotation and Relationship between Organizational Improvisation and Bricolage: An Integrative Literature Review[J]. Management Review, 2022, 34(7): 115-128.

参考文献

[1] Cunha M.P., Cunha J.V., Kamoche K.Organizational Improvisation:What, When, How, and Why[J].International Journal of Management Reviews, 1999,1(3):299-341
[2] Baker T., Miner A.S., Eesley D.T.Improvising Firms:Bricolage, Account Giving and Improvisational Competencies in the Founding Process[J].Research Policy, 2003,32(2):255-276
[3] Baker T., Nelson R.E.Creating Something from Nothing:Resource Construction through Entrepreneurial Bricolage[J].Administrative Science Quarterly, 2005,50(3):329-336
[4] 祝振铎,李新春.新创企业成长战略:资源拼凑的研究综述与展望[J].外国经济与管理, 2016,38(11):71-82
[5] Weick K.Organizational Redesign as Improvisation[A].Glick W., Huber G.Organizational Change and Redesign[C].Oxford:Oxford University Press, 1993
[6] Pfeffer J., Salancik G.R.The External Control of Organizations:A Resource Dependence Perspective[J].Social Science Electronic Publishing, 2003,23(2):123-133
[7] 吕一博,韩少杰,苏敬勤.企业孵化器战略模式与资源获取方式的适配演化研究[J].管理评论, 2018,30(1):256-272
[8] Kamoche K., Cunha M.P., Cunha J.V.Toward a Theory of Organizational Improvisation:Looking Beyond the Jazz Metaphor[J].Journal of Management Studies, 2003,40(8):2023-2051
[9] Weick K.The Collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations:The Mann Gulch Disaster[J].Administrative Science Quarterly, 1993b, 38(4):628-652
[10] Miner A.S., Bassoff P., Moorman C.Organizational Improvisation and Learning:A Field Study[J].Administrative Science Quarterly, 2001,46(2):304-337
[11] Hatch M.J., Shrivastava P., Huff A.S., et al.Jazzing up the Theory of Organizational Improvisation[J].Advances in Strategic Management, 1997,14:181-191
[12] Johnson B.M., Rice R.E.Reinvention in the Innovation Process:The Case of Word Processing[A].Rice R.E.The New Media[C].Beverly Hills, CA:Sage Publications, 1984
[13] Orlikowski W.J., Hoffman J.D.An Improvisational Model for Change Management:The Case of Groupware Technologies[J].Sloan Management Review, 1997,38(2):11-21
[14] 梁强,罗英光,谢舜龙.基于资源拼凑理论的创业资源价值实现研究与未来展望[J].外国经济与管理, 2013,35(5):14-22
[15] Peters M.D., Wieder B., Sutton S.G.Organizational Improvisation and the Reduced Usefulness of Performance Measurement Bi Functionalities[J].International Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 2018,29:1-15
[16] Di Domenico M.L., Haugh H., Tracey P.Social Bricolage:Theorizing Social Value Creation in Social Enterprises[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 2010,34(4):681-703
[17] 程聪.即兴行为、资源拼凑与企业制度逻辑变革——基于吉利并购沃尔沃的案例分析[C].中国企业管理案例与质性研究论坛, 2017
[18] Moorman C., Miner A.S.Organizational Improvisation and Organizational Memory[J].Academy of Management Review, 1998, 23(4):698-723
[19] Moorman C., Miner A.S.The Convergence of Planning and Execution:Improvisation in New Product Development[J].Journal of Marketing, 1998,62(3):1-20
[20] Vera D., Crossan M.Theatrical Improvisation:Lessons for Organization[J].Organization Studies, 2004,25(5):727-749
[21] McKnight B., Bontis N.E-improvisation:Collaborative Groupware Technology Expands the Reach and Effectiveness of Organizational Improvisation[J].Knowledge and Process Management, 2001,9(4):219-227
[22] Vera D., Crossan M.Improvisation and Innovative Performance in Teams[J].Organization Science, 2005,16(3):203-224
[23] Crossan M., Lane H.W., White R.E., et al.The Improvising Organization:Where Planning Meets Opportunity[J].Organizational Dynamics, 1996,24(4):20-35
[24] 买忆媛,叶竹馨,陈淑华.从"兵来将挡,水来土掩"到组织惯例形成——转型经济中新企业的即兴战略研究[J].管理世界, 2015,(8):147-165
[25] Barrett F.J.Creativity and Improvisation in Jazz and Organizations:Implications for Organizational Learning[J].Organization Science, 1998,9(5):605-622
[26] 黎赔肆,焦豪.动态环境下组织即兴对创业导向的影响机制研究[J].管理学报, 2014,11(9):1366-1371
[27] 叶竹馨,买忆媛.探索式即兴与开发式即兴:双元性视角下的创业企业即兴行为研究[J].南开管理评论, 2018,21(4):15-25
[28] 郑秀芝,龙丹.基于过程观的创业决策研究述评与展望[J].外国经济与管理, 2012,34(8):11-17
[29] 徐光.组织即兴诱发机理研究[D].哈尔滨工业大学博士学位论文, 2013
[30] Hmieleski K.M., Corbett A.C.Proclivity for Improvisation as a Predictor of Entrepreneurial Intentions[J].Journal of Small Business Management, 2006,44(1):45-63
[31] Crossan M., Cunha M.P., Vera D., et al.Time and Organizational Improvisation[J].The Academy of Management Review, 2005,30(1):129-145
[32] Hadida A.L., Tarvainen W., Rose J.Organizational Improvisation:A Consolidating Review and Framework[J].International Journal of Management Reviews, 2015,17(4):437-459
[33] Hmieleski K.M., Corbett A.C.The Contrasting Interaction Effects of Improvisational Behavior with Entrepreneurial Self-efficacy on New Venture Performance and Entrepreneur Work Satisfaction[J].Journal of Business Venturing, 2008,23(4):482-496
[34] Weick K.E.The Aesthetic of Imperfection in Orchestras and Organizations[A].Cunha M.P., Marques C.A.Readings in Organization Science:Organizational Change in a Changing Context[C].Lisbon:ISPA, 1999
[35] Hatch M.J.Exploring the Empty Spaces of Organizing:How Improvisational Jazz Helps Redescribe Organizational Structure[J].Organization Studies, 1999,20(1):75-100
[36] Kamoche K., Cunha M.P.Teamwork, Knowledge-Creation and Improvisation[C].Proceedings from the International Workshop on Teamworking, 1997
[37] Moorman C., Miner A.S.Walking the Tightrope:Improvisation and Information in New Product Development[R].Marketing Science Institute Cambridge Massachusetts, 1995
[38] Miner A.S., Moorman C., Bassoff P.Organizational Improvisation in New Product Development[R].Marketing Science Institute Cambridge Massachusetts, 1997
[39] Crossan M.M.Improvise to Innovate[J].Ivey Business Journal, 1997,62(1):36-42
[40] Crossan M.M.Improvisation in Action[J].Organization Science, 1998,9(5):593-599
[41] Davidsson P., Baker T., Senyard J.M.A Measure of Entrepreneurial Bricolage Behavior[J].International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior and Research, 2017,23(1):114-135
[42] Duymedjian R., Rüling C.C.Towards a Foundation of Bricolage in Organization and Management Theory[J].Organization Studies, 2010,31(2):133-151
[43] Chen J., Ma J.The Role of Improvisation in Entrepreneurial Processes[C].IEEE International Engineering Management Conference, 2005
[44] Baker T., Aldrich H.E.Bricolage and Resource-seeking:Improvisational Responses to Dependence in Entrepreneurial Firms[R].The Global Conference on Entrepreneurship Research, 2000
[45] Eisenhardt K.M., Tabrizi B.N.Accelerating Adaptative Processes:Product Innovation in the Global Computer Industry[J].Administrative Science Quarterly, 1995,40(1):84-110
[46] 李海东,林志扬.组织即兴:一个尚需深入研究的领域[J].管理学家(学术版), 2011,(3):45-58
[47] Du W., Wu J., Liu S., et al.Effective Organizational Improvisation in Information Systems Development:Insights from the Tencent Messaging System Development[J].Information and Management, 2019,56(4):614-624
[48] Mintzberg H., McHugh A.Strategy Formation in an Adhocracy[J].Administrative Science Quarterly, 1985,30(2):160-197
[49] Claude Lévi-Strauss.The Savage Mind[M].Chicago:The University of Chicago Press, 1966
[50] Førde A.Female Antrepreneurs in a West-African Context:Networks, Improvisation and Dependency[J].Journal of International Women's Studies, 2013,14(3):83-95
[51] Garud R., Gehman J.Theory Eevaluation, Entrepreneurial Processes, and Performativity[J].Academy of Management Review, 2016,41(3):544-549
[52] 陈格.组织双元学习与新创企业创业绩效关系研究[D].浙江工商大学硕士学位论文, 2017
[53] 苏芳,毛基业,谢卫红.资源贫乏企业应对环境剧变的拼凑过程研究[J].管理世界, 2016,(8):137-149
[54] 朱秀梅,鲍明旭,方琦.变革领导力与创业拼凑:员工建言与刻意练习的权变作用研究[J].南方经济, 2018,(6):102-119
[55] Senyard J., Baker T., Steffens P., et al.Bricolage as a Path to Innovativeness for Resource-Constrained New Firms[J].Journal of Product Innovation Management, 2014,31(2):211-230
[56] Fuglsang L.Bricolage and Invisible Innovation in Public Service Innovation[J].Journal of Innovation Economics, 2010,5(1):67-87
[57] Desa G., Basu S.Optimization or Bricolage?Overcoming Resource Constraints in Global Social Entrepreneurship[J].Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, 2013,7(1):26-49
[58] Senyard J.M.Bricolage and Early Stage Firm Performance[D].PhD Thesis of Queensland University of Technology, 2015
[59] Bacq S., Ofstein L.F., Kickul J.R., et al.Bricolage in Social Entrepreneurship:How Creative Resource Mobilization Fosters Greater Social Impact[J].International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 2015,16(4):283-289
[60] Gundry L.K., Kickul J.R., Griffiths M.D., et al.Creating Social Change out of Nothing:The Role of Entrepreneurial Bricolage in Social Entrepreneurs'Catalytic Innovations[A].Lumpkin G.T., Katz J.A.Social and Sustainable Entrepreneurship[C].Bingley:Emerald, 2011
[61] 于晓宇,李雅洁,陶向明.创业拼凑研究综述与未来展望[J].管理学报, 2017,14(2):306-316
[62] Senyard J.M., Baker T., Steffens P.Entrepreneurial Bricolage and Firm Performance:Moderating Effects of Firm Change and Innovativeness[R].2010 Annual Meeting of the Academy of Management, 2010
[63] Baker T.Resources in Play:Bricolage in the Toy Store (y)[J].Journal of Business Venturing, 2007,22(5):694-711
[64] Cunha M.P.Bricolage in Organizations[R].Faculda de Economia, Universidade Novade Lisboa, 2005
[65] Miettinen R., Virkkunen J.Epistemic Objects, Artefacts and Organizational Change[J].Organization, 2005,12(3):437-456
[66] Bingham C.B., Eisenhardt K.M.Rational Heuristics:The'Simple Rules'that Strategists Learn from Process Experience[J].Strategic Management Journal, 2011,32(13):1437-1464
[67] Bingham C.B., Eisenhardt K.M.Heuristics in Strategy and Organizations:Response to Vuori and Vuori[J].Strategic Management Journal, 2014,35(11):1698-1702
[68] 万建香,钟以婷.社会资本对企业绩效的影响——基于中国经济转型阶段的研究[J].管理评论, 2018,30(1):60-66
[69] 杜运周.组织与创业领域——组态视角下的创业研究[J].管理学季刊, 2019,3(3):31-41