企业为什么不实施民主参与管理:来自海峡两岸的证据

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

在综合回顾人力资源管理与劳动关系学关于工作场所管理理论的基础上,本文基于两岸四地的调查数据,探讨两岸企业民主参与管理的影响因素。结果显示:组织结构有机化与组织气氛的改善有利于两岸企业的民主参与管理行为,而组织规模与企业的人文关怀与决策参与等民主参与管理行为呈U型关系。外部因素在组织因素与企业民主参与管理之间具有调节效应,劳动力市场的规范与公民参与意识的提升促进了大规模企业的相关民主参与管理行为,但也弱化了组织气氛与组织结构对民主参与管理的作用。如何提升组织结构的有机化,并营造良好的组织气氛,去实现民主参与管理,成为企业内外部制度设计的关键。

关键词: 民主参与管理, 民营企业, 影响因素

Abstract:

Based on a comprehensive review of human resource management and labor relations theory, and private enterprise's survey data of four areasacross the Taiwan Strait, this paper discusses the factors that affect private enterprises' participative and democratic management. Results show that organic structure and good organizational climate are beneficial to enterprises management. There is a u-shaped relationship between organization scale and humanistic caring and decision-making participation. External factors moderate the effect of organizational factors on enterprise democratic management. Labor market standardization and citizen participation promotes democratic participation management in large enterprises, but weakens the role that organizational atmosphere and organizational structure play in democratic management. How to make organizational structure more organic and create good atmosphere to realize participative and democratic management is the key to enterprises' internal and external system design.

Key words: participative and democratic management, private enterprise, factors

郑文智, 许苗苗, 庄伯超. 企业为什么不实施民主参与管理:来自海峡两岸的证据[J]. , 2016, 28(3): 116-125.

Zheng Wenzhi, Xu Miaomiao, Zhuang Bochao. Why Private Enterprise Don't Implement Participative and Democratic Management: Evidence from Both Sides across the Taiwan Strait[J]. , 2016, 28(3): 116-125.

参考文献

[1] Kaufman B. E. Theorising Determinants of Employee Voice:An Integrative Model across Disciplines and Levels of Analysis[J]. Human Resource Management Journal, 2015,25(1):19-40
[2] Nightingale D. V. Workplace Democracy:An Inquiry into Employee Participation in Canadian Work Organizations[M]. Toronto:University of Toronto Press, 2015
[3] Yazdani N. Organizational Democracy and Organization Structure Link:Role of Strategic Leadership & Environmental Uncertainty[J]. Global Financial Crisis:Causes, Emerging Trends and Strategy, 2010,5(2):51-72
[4] Daft R. Organization Theory and Design[M]. NewYork:Cengage Learning, 2015
[5] Conner P. E. Decision-making Participation Patterns:The Role Organization Context[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1992,35(1):218-232
[6] Glew D. J., Kelly A. N., Griffin R. W., Van F. D. Participation in Organizations:A Preview of the Issues and Proposed Framework for Future Analysis[J]. Journal of Management, 1995,21(3):395-421
[7] Conger J. A., Kanuhgo R. N. The Empowerment Process:Integrating Theory and Practice[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1988,13(3):471-482
[8] Harrington R. J., Kendall K. W. Uncovering the Interrelationships Among Firm Size, Organizational Involvement, Environmental Uncertainty, and Implementation Success[J]. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, 2007,8(2):1-23
[9] Smith S. C. Employee Participation in China's TVEs[J]. China Economic Review, 1995,6(1):157-167
[10] 张震,马力,马文静.组织气氛与员工参与的关系[J]. 心理学报, 2002,34(3):312-318
[11] 陈万思,余彦儒.国外参与式管理研究述评[J]. 管理评论, 2010,22(4):73-81
[12] Zhang B., Morris J. L. High-performance Work Systems and Organizational Performance:Testing the Mediation Role of Employee Outcomes Using Evidence from PR China[J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2014,25(1):68-90
[13] Arando S., Gago M., Jones D. C., et al. Efficiency in Employee-Owned Enterprises an Econometric Case Study of Mondragon[J]. ILR Review, 2015,68(2):398-425
[14] 向常春,龙立荣.参与型领导与员工建言:积极印象管理动机的中介作用[J]. 管理评论, 2013,25(7):156-166
[15] Likert R. The Human Organization[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill, 1967
[16] Wegge J., Jeppesen H. J., Weber W. G., et al. Promoting Work Motivation in Organizations[J]. Journal of Personnel Psychology, 2011,11(2):154-171
[17] Downey S. N., Werff L., Thomas K. M., et al. The Role of Diversity Practices and Inclusion in Promoting Trust and Employee Engagement[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2015,45(1):35-44
[18] Srivastava A., Bartol K. M., Locke E. A. Empowering Leadership in Management Teams:Effects on Knowledge Sharing, Efficacy, and Performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2006,49(6):1239-1251
[19] Kougiannou K., Redman T., Dietz G. The Outcomes of Works Councils:The Role of Trust, Justice and Industrial Relations Climate[J]. Human Resource Management Journal, 2015,25(4):458-477
[20] Wang T., Zhao B., Thornhill S. Pay Dispersion and Organizational Innovation:The Mediation Effects of Employee Participation and Voluntary Turnover[J]. Human Relations, 2015,68(7):1155-1181
[21] 方嬿榕.组织伦理气候对员工参与知识管理之影响[D]. 长荣大学硕士论文, 2008
[22] 吴承丰.企业伦理的实践[M]. 台北:前程文化事业有限公司, 2010
[23] Almond G. A.,Verba S. The Civil Culture[M]. Boston:Little, Brown & Co., 1965
[24] Becker C. Democracy in the Workplace:Union Representation Elections and Federal Labor law[J]. Minnesota Law Review, 1992,77(1):495-585
[25] Collom V. E., Bonacich E. Social Inequality and the Politics of Production:Americans' Attitudes toward Workplace Democracy[M]. California:University of California, 2001
[26] 李萍.工业民主对管理哲学研究的时代意义[J]. 中国人民大学学报, 2006,(4):10-15
[27] 郑文智,张华.民主参与管理与家族企业共享价值观的实现[J]. 经济管理, 2015,(7):74-83
[28] 杨晶照,杨东涛,马洪旗.组织结构的测量[J]. 统计与决策, 2012,(3):74-77
[29] Campbell J. J., Dunnette M. D., Lawler E. E., et al. Managerial Behavior, Performance and Effectiveness[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill, 1970
[30] Smith P. D., Propst D. B. Are Topic-Specific Measures of Socio-Political Control Justified? Exploring the Realm of Citizen Participation in Natural Resource Decision Making[J]. Journal of Community Psychology, 2001,29(2):179-187
[31] 朱瑜,李云健,马智妍,等.员工组织规避劳动合同法认知,工作不安全感与组织报复行为的关系:基于华南地区新生代员工的实证研究[J]. 管理评论, 2014,26(3):113-127
[32] Parnell J. A., Bell E. D., Taylor R. The Propensity for Participative Management:A Conceptual and Empirical Analysis[J]. Mid-Atlantic Journal of Business, 1992,28(2):31-42
[33] Zwick T. Employee Participation and Productivity[J]. Labour Economics, 2004,11(6):715-740
[34] 詹婧.企业民主参与动力研究:基于劳资双赢的经济学视角[M]. 北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社, 2010
[35] 王振源,孙珊珊,戴瑞林.同事离职对留任员工离职意图的影响机制研究——一个被中介的调节作用模型[J]. 管理评论, 2014,26(4):82-92
[36] Welsh D. H. B., Luthans F., Sommer S. M. Managing Russian Factory Workers:The Impact of US-based Behavioral and Participative Techniques[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1993,36(1):58-79
[37] Pateman C. Participation and Democratic Theory[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1970
[38] Barry M., Wilkinson A. Pro-Social or Pro-Management? A Critique of the Conception of Employee Voice as a Pro-Social Behavior within Organizational Behavior[J]. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 2015,7(1):1066-1080