制造业新生代农民工工匠精神形成的动力与路径——基于德胜洋楼的案例研究

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 基于德胜（苏州）洋楼有限公司的单案例，从动机能量理论视角刻画影响新生代农民工主动精益求精的驱动力要素和抑制力要素及要素演化过程。研究发现：①工匠精神形成包括身份补缺、任务使能与惯习匹配三种动力机制，以及积极自我概念构建、积极自我概念强化与应该自我约束三条内生路径；②身份补缺机制驱动新生代农民工构建出积极的自我概念，形成较充沛的心理资源储备；③任务使能机制驱动新生代农民工将工作作为积极自我概念强化的重要途径，进而在工作中投入大量资源；④惯习匹配机制形塑出新生代农民工专注于工作、践行良好职业劳动习惯的应该自我概念，化解其在目标追求过程中的阻力。本研究拓展了动机能量理论的应用情境与解释边界，丰富了工匠精神形成的前因，并拓宽了新生代农民工的工匠精神培育思路。

关键词: 制造业, 新生代农民工, 工匠精神, 动机能量理论, 案例研究

Abstract: Taking Tecsun (Suzhou) Homes Co., Ltd. (Tecsun in short) as the single case study object, and using the cognitive energetics theory, this study explores the driving and restraining forces that affect workers’ active pursuit of excellence, and describes their evolution process. It is found that: (1) The formation of the new generation of migrant workers’ craftsman spirit includes three kinds of driving mechanism, which are identity filling, task enabling and habitus matching, and three endogenous paths, which are establishing positive self-concept, strengthening positive self-concept and ought-self restraining; (2) The identity filling mechanism drives the workers to build a positive self-concept and form an abundant reserve of psychological resources; (3) The task enabling mechanism drives the workers to take work as an important way to strengthen their positive self-concept, and then a lot of resources are invested in their work; (4) The habitus matching mechanism shapes the workers’ ought-self of focusing on their work and practicing good professional labor habits, which restrains the resistance in the process of goal pursuit. This study expands the application situation and interpretation boundary of cognitive energetics theory, enriches the antecedents of the formation of craftsman spirit, and broadens the thought of craftsman spirit cultivation of the new-generation migrant workers.

Key words: manufacturing industry, the new generation of migrant workers, craftsmanship, cognitive energetics theory, case study

过旻钰, 朱永跃, 赵雷. 制造业新生代农民工工匠精神形成的动力与路径——基于德胜洋楼的案例研究[J]. 管理评论, 2024, 36(9): 274-288.

Guo Minyu, Zhu Yongyue, Zhao Lei. The Formation Dynamics and Path of the New Generation of Migrant Workers’ Craftsmanship in Manufacturing Industry: A Case Study Based on Tecsun[J]. Management Review, 2024, 36(9): 274-288.

参考文献

[1] 李群,栗宪,张宏如. 制造业高质量发展背景下师徒指导关系对新生代农民工创新绩效的影响机制——一个双调节的中介模型[J]. 宏观质量研究, 2020,8(5):14-26 Li Q., Li X., Zhang H. R. The Influence of the Mentoring Relationship on the Innovation Performance of the New-generation Migrant Workers Against the Background of High Quality Development in Manufacturing Industry: A Mediation Model with Double Moderation[J]. Journal of Macro-Quality Research, 2020,8(5):14-26
[2] 彭花,贺正楚,张雪琳. 企业家精神和工匠精神对企业创新绩效的影响[J]. 中国软科学, 2022,(3):112-123 Peng H., He Z. C., Zhang X. L. Influence of Entrepreneurship and Craftsmanship on Enterprise Innovation Performance[J]. China Soft Science, 2022,(3):112-123
[3] 李群,唐芹芹,张宏如,等. 制造业新生代农民工工匠精神量表开发与验证[J]. 管理学报, 2020,17(1):58-65 Li Q., Tang Q. Q., Zhang H. R., et al. Artisan Spirit Scale Development and Validation of New-generation Migrant Workers in Manufacturing Industry[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2020,17(1):58-65
[4] 朱永跃,王世贤,欧阳晨慧. 职业污名对产业工人工匠精神的影响:基于认知和情感的双路径研究[J]. 系统管理学报, 2023,32(3):605-616 Zhu Y. Y., Wang S. X., Ouyang C. H. Influence of Occupational Stigma on Craftsman Spirit of Industrial Workers: A Dual Path Study Based on Cognition and Emotion[J]. Journal of Systems & Management, 2023,32(3):605-616
[5] 陈景秋,范清月,黄敏妍. 农民工的工作退缩行为:基于多重嵌入和身份压力的视角[J]. 心理科学进展, 2022,30(9):1955-1967 Chen J. Q., Fan Q. Y., Huang M. Y. The Withdrawal Behaviors of Rural Migrant Workers: A Perspective from Multiple Embeddedness and Identity Strain[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2022,30(9):1955-1967
[6] 胡少云. 新生代农民工工匠精神“系统性缺失”及其培育路径[J]. 当代教育论坛, 2019,(1):97-103 Hu S. Y. On the Systematic Deficiency of the Craftsmen Spirit of the New Generation of Migrant Workers and Its Cultivation Path[J]. Forum on Contemporary Education, 2019,(1):97-103
[7] 高中华,赵晨,付悦. 工匠精神的概念、边界及研究展望[J]. 经济管理, 2020,42(6):192-208 Gao Z. H., Zhao C., Fu Y. The Concept, Boundary and Research Prospect of Craftsmanship[J]. Business and Management Journal, 2020,42(6):192-208
[8] 段升森,迟冬梅,张玉明. 信念的力量:工匠精神对组织韧性的影响研究[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2021,43(3):57-71 Duan S. S., Chi D. M., Zhang Y. M. Power of Faith: The Influence of Craftsman Spirit on Organizational Resilience[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2021,43(3):57-71
[9] 郭会斌,郑展,单秋朵. 工匠精神的资本化机制:一个基于八家“百年老店”的多层次构型解释[J]. 南开管理评论, 2018,21(2):95-106 Guo H. B., Zheng Z., Shan Q. D. An Interpretive Research on Capitalization Mechanism of the Craftsmanship: A Multi-level Configuration Based on Eight Time-honored Shops[J]. Nankai Business Review, 2018,21(2):95-106
[10] 郭会斌,郑耀洲,张景云,等. 匠心租金的构念、获取路径与演化过程——基于六家“百年老店”的阐释[J]. 管理世界, 2023,39(7):100-120 Guo H. B., Zheng Y. Z., Zhang J. Y., et al. The Construct, Garnering Paths and Evolution Process of Ingenuity Rent: Based on the Interpretation of Six “Time-honored Shops”[J]. Journal of Management World, 2023,39(7):100-120
[11] 喻文德. 工匠精神的伦理文化分析[J]. 伦理学研究, 2016,(6):69-73 Yu W. D. An Ethical and Cultural Analysis of Artisan Spirit[J]. Studies in Ethics, 2016,(6):69-73
[12] Yu H., Luo Q. L. Reform of the Construction of Industrial Workers under the Craftsman Spirit[J]. International Journal of Frontiers in Sociology, 2020,2(9):158-165
[13] 李园园,刘建华,段珅. 中国本土文化情境下老字号品牌传承研究:维度探索与量表开发[J]. 南开管理评论, 2023,26(6):26-37 Li Y. Y., Liu J. H., Duan S. Research on the Inheritance of Time-honored Brands in the Context of Chinese Local Culture: Dimension Exploration and Scale Development[J]. Nankai Business Review, 2023,26(6):26-37
[14] 赵晨,付悦,高中华. 高质量发展背景下工匠精神的内涵、测量及培育路径研究[J]. 中国软科学, 2020,(7):169-177 Zhao C., Fu Y., Gao Z. H. Connotation, Measurement and Cultivation of Craftsmanship under the Background of High-quality Development[J]. China Soft Science, 2020,(7):169-177
[15] 钱欣,刘淑桢,刘园园. 职场地位视角下员工工匠精神的形成机制[J]. 科研管理, 2021,42(9):201-208 Qian X., Liu S. Z., Liu Y. Y. The Forming Mechanism of Employees’ Craftsman Spirit from the Perspective of Workplace Status[J]. Science Research Management, 2021,42(9):201-208
[16] 朱永跃,马媛,欧阳晨慧. 家长式领导与制造企业员工工匠精神:工作卷入和团队积极情绪氛围的影响[J]. 系统管理学报, 2022,31(1):89-103 Zhu Y. Y., Ma Y., Ouyang C. H. Paternalistic Leadership and Craftsmanship of Manufacturing Employees: Influence of Job Involvement and Team Positive Emotional Climate[J]. Journal of Systems & Management, 2022,31(1):89-103
[17] 徐伟,周恒娟,宋思根. 老字号员工工匠精神量表开发与验证研究[J]. 管理学报, 2023,20(2):221-230 Xu W., Zhou H. J., Song S. G. Craftsman Spirit Scale Development and Validation of Time-honored Enterprise Employees[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2023,20(2):221-230
[18] 李朋波,靳秀娟,罗文豪. 服务业员工工匠精神的结构维度探索与测量量表开发[J]. 管理学报, 2021,18(1):69-78 Li P. B., Jin X. J., Luo W. H. Exploration on the Structural Dimension of the Craftsmanship Spirit of Service Employees and Development of Measurement Scale[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2021,18(1):69-78
[19] 李云,刘霁. 新时代高职院校“工匠型”教师队伍建设研究[J]. 湖南社会科学, 2021,(6):128-136 Li Y., Liu Q. Research on the Construction of “Craftsman” Teachers in Higher Vocational Colleges in the New Era[J]. Social Sciences in Hunan, 2021,(6):128-136
[20] Xiong M. S. Discussion on the Function of Craftsman Spirit Integrating into Traditional Culture Education[J]. International Journal of Higher Education Teaching Theory, 2020,1(4):113-116
[21] 曾颢,赵宜萱,赵曙明. 构建工匠精神对话过程体系模型——基于德胜洋楼公司的案例研究[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2018,35(10):124-135 Zeng H., Zhao Y. X., Zhao S. M. Construct the Process Model of the Craftsmanship Discourse System—The Case of Tecsun[J]. Human Resources Development of China, 2018,35(10):124-135
[22] 邓志华,肖小虹. 自我牺牲型领导对员工工匠精神的影响研究[J]. 经济管理, 2020,42(11):109-124 Deng Z. H., Xiao X. H. The Impact of Self-sacrificial Leadership to the Employee’s Artisan Spirit[J]. Business and Management Journal, 2020,42(11):109-124
[23] 高中华. 工匠精神对员工主动性行为的影响机制研究[J]. 管理学报, 2022,19(6):851-860 Gao Z. H. The Mechanism of Craftsmanship on Employees’ Proactive Behavior[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2022,19(6):851-860
[24] 叶龙,刘园园,郭名. 传承的意义:企业师徒关系对徒弟工匠精神的影响研究[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2020,4(7):95-107 Ye L., Liu Y. Y., Guo M. Significance of Inheritance: The Influence of Mentoring Relationship on Protégés’ Craftsman Spirit[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2020,4(7):95-107
[25] Kruglanski A. W., Bélanger J. J., Chen X. The Energetics of Motivated Cognition: A Force-field Analysis[J]. Psychological Review, 2012,119(1):1-20
[26] 胡砚冰,周爱保,鲁小勇. 自我参照效应中“消失”的自我:基于格式塔的心物场观[J]. 心理研究, 2019,12(5):387-393 Hu Y. B., Zhou A. B., Lu X. Y. Self Disappearing in Self-referential Effect: Psychophysical Field Based on Gestalt[J]. Psychological Research, 2019,12(5):387-393
[27] Kruglanski A. W., Chernikova M., Schori-Eyal N. From Readiness to Action: How Motivation Works[J]. Polish Psychological Bulletin, 2014,45(3):259-267
[28] 陶厚永,施靖娴,张蒙. 注意力视角下平台化转型企业的可持续创业实现机制——基于盛隆群体老板制的案例研究[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2022,44(8):24-41 Tao H. Y., Shi J. X., Zhang M. Sustainable Entrepreneurship Realization Mechanism of Platform Transformation Enterprises from the Perspective of Attention: A Case Study Based on the Sheng Long Group Boss System[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2022,44(8):24-41
[29] Richard S., Hennekam S. Constructing a Positive Identity as a Disabled Worker through Social Comparison: The Role of Stigma and Disability Characteristics[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2021,125:103528
[30] 赵巍. 从留守儿童到三和青年——新生代农民工的社会化与自我认同[J]. 求索, 2021,(2):90-97 Zhao W. From Left-behind Children to Sanhe Youth: Socialization and Self-identification of the New Generation of Migrant Workers[J]. Seeker, 2021,(2):90-97
[31] 赵卫红,张昊辰,曹霞. 身份差序格局对新生代农民工离职倾向的影响机制研究——基于制造业新生代农民工的调查数据[J]. 农村经济, 2020,(2):131-137 Zhao W. H., Zhang H. C., Cao X. Research on the Influence of Identity Differential Mode on Turnover Tendency of New-Generation Migrant Workers：Based on the Survey Data of the New Generation of Migrant Workers in Manufacturing Industry[J]. Rural Economy, 2020，(2):131-137
[32] Shrauger J. S. Responses to Evaluation as a Function of Initial Self-perceptions[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 1975,82(4):581-596
[33] 张宝山,刘琳. 工作自我概念的界定、测量及相关研究[J]. 西南大学学报(社会科学版), 2015,41(2):89-99 Zhang B. S., Liu L. Definition, Measurement and Related Research of Working Self-concept[J]. Journal of Southwest University (Social Sciences Edition), 2015,41(2):89-99
[34] Bélanger J. J., Kruglanski A. W., Chen X. Bending Perception to Desire: Effects of Task Demands, Motivation, and Cognitive Resources[J]. Motivation and Emotion, 2014,38(6):802-814
[35] 袁靖华. 大众传媒的符号救济与新生代农民工的城市融入——基于符号资本的视角[J]. 新闻与传播研究, 2011,18(1):60-69 Yuan J. H. Mass Medias Symbolic Relief and the Social Integration of the New Generation of Migrant Workers: A Symbolic Capital Perspectives[J]. Journalism & Communication, 2011,18(1):60-69
[36] 樊子立,程垦,马君. 个性化工作协议与追随行为: 文化自我表征视角[J]. 管理评论, 2023,35(10):218-227 Fan Z. L., Chen K., Ma J. Idiosyncratic Deals and Followship Behavior: A Cultural Self-representation Perspective[J]. Management Review, 2023,35(10):218-227
[37] 宫留记. 布迪厄的社会实践理论[J]. 理论探讨, 2008,(6):57-60 Gong L. J. Bourdieu’s Theory of Social Practice[J]. Theoretical Investigation, 2008,(6):57-60
[38] 刘启超,陈安平. 社会网络:农民工人力资本积累的垫脚石还是绊脚石?[J]. 数量经济技术经济研究, 2024,41(1):172-191 Liu Q. C., Chen A. P. Social Network: A Stepping Stone or a Stumbling Block for the Human Capital Accumulation of Rural-Urban Migrants?[J]. Journal of Quantitative & Technological Economics, 2024,41(1):172-191
[39] 罗兴武,张皓,刘洋. 数字平台企业如何从事件中塑造数字创新能力——基于事件系统理论的钉钉成长案例研究[J]. 南开管理评论, 2023,26(4):234-247 Luo X. W., Zhang H., Liu Y. How Platform Enterprises Shape Digital Innovation Capabilities through Events—A Case Study of Enterprise Growth Based on Event System Theory[J]. Nankai Business Review, 2023,26(4):234-247