感恩研究知识图谱与演进：近二十年国内外文献的计量分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 随着积极心理学的兴起，感恩研究在心理学领域逐步发展。感恩情绪对个体及组织均有一定积极的影响。然而组织管理领域对感恩的关注仍旧有限，相关研究较为零散，尚未形成较为系统的整体研究框架。基于Web of Science核心合集和中国知网收录的感恩文献，采用文献计量方法和知识图谱技术，结合文献精读和梳理，对国内外组织管理领域1999—2021年间感恩相关研究进行分析和解读。通过描述性结果重点分析了国内外感恩领域的论文发表状况、最高产量国家与期刊分布、最高产量学者、热点关键词，并且整体呈现了其相互间的关系。此后，通过对国内外组织管理领域感恩研究分别构建共现及共引网络图谱，系统地对比梳理国内外研究的起源、研究成果、研究前沿热点、结构分布、发展脉络和演进趋势，分析和识别了现有研究中存在的不足，并对组织管理领域感恩研究的未来方向进行了讨论。

关键词: 感恩研究, 文献计量, 知识图谱, 研究展望

Abstract: With the rise of positive psychology, gratitude research has gradually developed in the fields of psychology and management. Gratitude has a certain positive impact on individuals and organizations, but it has not attracted enough attention in the field of organization management, and the relevant researches are too scattered to form a systematic overall research framework. Based on gratitude literature in the Web of Science Core Collection and Chinese Journal Full-text database, utilizing bibliometric analysis and knowledge mapping technology, and combining with intensive reading and review, this paper analyzes domestic and foreign researches on gratitude in the field of organization management from 1999 to 2021. This paper focuses on the analysis of the publication status, the distribution of the most academically prolific countries, the distribution of the most prolific journals, the most prolific scholars and hot keywords at home and abroad via descriptive results, and reveals the whole relationship between them. Then, we construct co-occurrence and co-citation network maps of domestic and foreign researches on gratitude, systematically sort out the research origin, research findings, research hotspots, research structure, research development and evolution trend, analyze and identify the limitations of existing researches, and discuss the potential direction for future researches.

Key words: gratitude research, bibliometric analysis, knowledge mapping, research prospect

郭一蓉, 陈黎梅, 高子茵, 郑晓明. 感恩研究知识图谱与演进：近二十年国内外文献的计量分析[J]. 管理评论, 2023, 35(5): 148-162.

Guo Yirong, Chen Limei, Gao Ziyin, Zheng Xiaoming. The Knowledge Map and Evolution of Gratitude Research:A Bibliometric Study of Domestic and Foreign Literature in Recent 20 Years[J]. Management Review, 2023, 35(5): 148-162.

参考文献

[1] Wood A. M., Froh J. J., Geraghty A. W. Gratitude and Well-Being:A Review and Theoretical Integration[J]. Clinical Psychology Review, 2010,30(7):890-905
[2] Emmons R. A., Mccullough M. E. Counting Blessings versus Burdens:An Experimental Investigation of Gratitude and Subjective Well-Being in Daily Life[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2003,84(2):377-389
[3] Spence J. R., Brown D. J., Keeping L. M., et al. Helpful Today, but Not Tomorrow? Feeling Grateful as a Predictor of Daily Organizational Citizenship Behaviors[J]. Personnel Psychology, 2014,67(3):705-738
[4] Grant A. M., Wrzesniewski A. I won't Let You Down… or will I? Core Self-Evaluations, Other-Orientation, Anticipated Guilt and Gratitude, and Job Performance[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2010,95(1):108-121
[5] Fehr R., Fulmer A., Awtrey E., et al. The Grateful Workplace:A Multilevel Model of Gratitude in Organizations[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2017,42(2):361-381
[6] 刘军,朱征,王琦琦,等. 工作场所感恩研究述评与展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2019,41(9):61-74
[7] Aria M., Cuccurullo C. Bibliometrix:An R-Tool for Comprehensive Science Mapping Analysis[J]. Journal of Informetrics, 2017,11(4):959-975
[8] 邱均平,段宇锋,陈敬全,等. 我国文献计量学发展的回顾与展望[J]. 科学学研究, 2003,21(2):143-148
[9] 王勇超,罗胜文,杨英宝,等. 知识图谱可视化综述[J]. 计算机辅助设计与图形学学报, 2019,31(10):1666-1676
[10] Kim J., Yammarino F. J., Dionne S. D., et al. State-of-the-Science Review of Leader-Follower Dyads Research[J]. The Leadership Quarterly, 2020,31(1):1-18
[11] Zhu J., Song L. J., Zhu L., et al. Visualizing the Landscape and Evolution of Leadership Research[J]. The Leadership Quarterly, 2019,30(2):215-232
[12] 李昊,潘宇光,王磊. Bibliometrix:一款新的基于R语言的文献计量软件介绍与评价[J]. 大学图书情报学刊, 2018,36(4):93-104
[13] Romani S., Grappi S., Bagozzi R. P. Explaining Consumer Reactions to Corporate Social Responsibility:The Role of Gratitude and Altruistic Values[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2012,114(2):193-206
[14] Raggio R. D., Walz A. M., Godbole M. B., et al. Gratitude in Relationship Marketing[J]. European Journal of Marketing, 2014,48(1/2):2-24
[15] 何安明,刘华山,惠秋平. 感恩三维结构理论模型的建构[J]. 心理研究, 2013,6(3):11-17
[16] 喻承甫,张卫,李董平,等. 感恩及其与幸福感的关系[J]. 心理科学进展, 2010,18(7):1110-1121
[17] 王建平,喻承甫,曾毅茵,等. 青少年感恩的影响因素及其机制[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2011,27(3):39-45
[18] McCullough M. E., Kilpatrick S. D., Emmons R. A., et al. Is Gratitude a Moral Affect?[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 2001,127(2):249-266
[19] Lazarus R. S. Progress on a Cognitive-Motivational-Relational Theory of Emotion[J]. American Psychologist, 1991,46(8):819-834
[20] Bartlett M. Y., Desteno D. Gratitude and Prosocial Behavior[J]. Psychological Science, 2006,17(4):319-325
[21] McCullough M. E., Emmons R. A., Tsang J. A. The Grateful Disposition:A Conceptual and Empirical Topography[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2002,82(1):112-127
[22] Palmatier R. W., Jarvis C. B., Bechkoff J. R., et al. The Role of Customer Gratitude in Relationship Marketing[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2009,73(5):1-18
[23] Morales A. C. Giving Firms an "E" for Effort:Consumer Responses to High-Effort Firms[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2005,31(4):806-812
[24] Tsang J. A. Gratitude and Prosocial Behaviour:An Experimental Test of Gratitude[J]. Cognition & Emotion, 2006,20(1):138-148
[25] McCullough M. E., Kimeldorf M. B., Cohen A. D. An Adaptation for Altruism[J]. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 2008,17(4):281-285
[26] Algoe S. B., Haidt J., Gable S. L. Beyond Reciprocity:Gratitude and Relationships in Everyday Life[J]. Emotion, 2008,8(3):425-429
[27] Tsang J. A. The Effects of Helper Intention on Gratitude and Indebtedness[J]. Motivation and Emotion, 2006,30(3):198-204
[28] McCullough M. E., Tsang J. A., Emmons R. A. Gratitude in Intermediate Affective Terrain:Links of Grateful Moods to Individual Differences and Daily Emotional Experience[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2004,86(2):295-309
[29] Soscia I. Gratitude, Delight, or Guilt:The Role of Consumers' Emotions in Predicting Postconsumption Behaviors[J]. Psychology and Marketing, 2007,24(10):871-894
[30] Wulf K. D., Odekerken-Schr der G., Iacobucci D. Investments in Consumer Relationships:A Cross-Country and Cross-Industry Exploration[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2001,65(4):33-50
[31] Wetzel H. A., Hammerschmidt M., Zablah A. R. Gratitude versus Entitlement:A Dual Process Model of the Profitability Implications of Customer Prioritization[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2014,78(2):1-19
[32] Xia L., Kukar-Kinney M. Examining the Penalty Resolution Process[J]. Journal of Service Research, 2013,16(4):518-532
[33] Raggio R. D., Folse J. A. G. Gratitude Works:Its Impact and the Mediating Role of Affective Commitment in Driving Positive Outcomes[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2009,37(4):455-469
[34] 李兆良,周芳蕊. 大学生内隐感恩与外显感恩对主观幸福感的影响[J]. 中国临床心理学杂志, 2018,26(4):813-820
[35] 蒲清平,朱丽萍. 大学生"知恩图报"的心理反应特点[J]. 心理科学, 2012,35(5):1185-1189
[36] 何安明,惠秋平,刘华山. 大学生情绪智力与感恩的交叉滞后分析[J]. 心理科学, 2015,38(2):349-354
[37] 宋友志,田媛,周宗奎,等. 青少年公正世界信念对抑郁的影响:感恩和自尊的序列中介作用[J]. 心理科学, 2018,41(4):828-834
[38] 罗雪峰,沐守宽. 高中生感恩对心理幸福感的影响:领悟社会支持和基本心理需要的链式中介作用[J]. 心理科学, 2017,40(4):878-884
[39] 喻承甫,张卫,曾毅茵,等. 青少年感恩与问题行为的关系:学校联结的中介作用[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2011,27(4):425-433
[40] 杨强,叶宝娟. 感恩对青少年生活满意度的影响:领悟社会支持的中介作用及压力性生活事件的调节作用[J]. 心理科学, 2014,37(3):610-616
[41] 刘建岭. 感戴研究进展[J]. 首都师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2010,(2):80-84
[42] 郭一蓉,宋继文,李雪. 体验抽样法与准实验法的结合探究:基于组织中感恩研究的应用与展望[J]. 中国人力资源开发, 2019,36(1):53-69
[43] 廖军和,欧阳儒阳,左春荣,等. 贫困大学生感戴与主观幸福感的关系:链式中介效应分析[J]. 中国临床心理学杂志, 2015,23(4):722-728
[44] 叶宝娟,杨强,胡竹菁. 感恩对青少年学业成就的影响:有调节的中介效应[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2013,29(2):192-199
[45] 陈彦垒,叶宝娟,胡竹菁,等. 中学生的烟酒使用与压力性生活事件和感恩心态[J]. 中国心理卫生杂志, 2012,26(10):796-800
[46] 王红丽,陈思宇. 状态感恩的激发过程、影响效应及边界条件研究[J]. 管理学报, 2019,16(11):1640-1649
[47] 聂琦,张捷. 家庭代际支持的溢出效应——积极情感的中介作用与感恩特质的调节作用[J]. 软科学, 2019,33(10):70-75
[48] 杨春时. 中国恩情文化批判[J]. 东南学术, 2014,8(1):77-84
[49] 文超,张卫,李董平,等. 初中生感恩与学业成就的关系:学习投入的中介作用[J]. 心理发展与教育, 2010,26(6):598-605
[50] Cain I. H., Cairo A., Duffy M., et al. Measuring Gratitude at Work[J]. Journal of Positive Psychology, 2019,14(4):440-451
[51] Wood A. M., Maltby J., Stewart N., et al. A Social-Cognitive Model of Trait and State Levels of Gratitude[J]. Emotion, 2008,8(2):281-290
[52] Fredrickson B. L. What Good Are Positive Emotions?[J]. Review of General Psychology, 1998,2(3):300-319
[53] Algoe S. B. Find, Remind, and Bind:The Functions of Gratitude in Everyday Relationships[J]. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2012,6(6):455-469
[54] 王震,许灏颖,宋萌. "说话算话"的领导让下属更效忠:中国传统"报"文化视角下的领导言行一致与下属忠诚[J]. 管理评论, 2018,30(4):106-119
[55] 王琦琦,李增鑫,刘军. 顾客感激表达对员工工作表现的影响及机制[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2021,43(8):121-137
[56] Grant A. M., Gino F. A. Little Thanks Goes a Long Way:Explaining Why Gratitude Expressions Motivate Prosocial Behavior[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2010,98(6):946-955